Widow Of Byron De La Beckwith Wins Jury Verdict

Sunday, July 7, 2002

Thelma Neff Beckwith, the widow of Byron De La Beckwith, has been awarded $175,000 in punitive damages by a Hamilton County Chancery Court jury.

The two-day trial and jury verdict also set aside a deed from Mrs. Beckwith to Judy Skiba, the defendant in the case.

Mrs. Beckwith was 92 years old at the time she signed a deed to property she owned on Wilson Avenue on Signal Mountain. The jury found that the deed was procured by "fraud and undue influence" on Mrs. Beckwith by Ms. Skiba.

Attorney Mitchell Byrd said Ms. Skiba had befriended Mrs. Beckwith after she (Ms. Skiba) was released from prison in Georgia. He said Ms. Skiba shared the "political views" of Mrs. Beckwith's late husband, who was convicted of the civil rights murder of Medgar Evers in Mississippi. Mr. Beckwith died in prison in Mississippi in January 2001.

Attorney Byrd told the Chancery Court jury that the case was an "old story of racism, hatred, bitterness and greed" by Ms. Skiba. He urged the jury to "send a message to all those like Judy Skiba in our community and state that this abuse of trust and fraud toward the helpless, oppressed and elderly would not be tolerated in our community."

Attorney Byrd said, "It is the responsibility of a trial lawyer to use the system of jury trial for not only the cause of his client, but in proper circumstances to extend the principles of justice beyond the particular facts of the case. This punitive verdict should be viewed by those who abuse others, whether it be a spouse, a child or as in this case, a 92-year-old woman, that our community and legal system will not tolerate such abuses. They will be punished severely by both the criminal and the civil systems of law that we trial lawyers respect so much."

Mr. Byrd continued, "The jury system is still the best realm of protection for wrongs done to all our citizens. It must be protected and cherished as one of our greatest rights through history and into the future. This was not a 'run away' verdict. The 12 men and women who decided this case certainly rose to the occasion in patriotism, compassion, justice and fairness."


City Council Approves Tax Abatement For Flats At Fifty Eight

The City Council on Tuesday night approved a PILOT (payment in lieu of taxes) tax break sought by Trent Development for a planned apartment complex on Highway 58. Opposed were Chip Henderson and Jerry Mitchell. The Flats at Fifty Eight is a project costing over $17 million across from Linda's Produce and just up from Central High School. Alex Trent said rents will range ... (click for more)

Carjacking Suspect At Lakesite Was Caught On Camera

The Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office is investigating a reported carjacking which occurred on Monday, Feb. 13, in the Lakesite area of Hamilton County. Authorities said in the early morning hours, a white male approached the victim as he exited his car on the parking lot of a business.  The man told the victim that he needed his car, then he brandished a pistol.    ... (click for more)

Judge Doug Meyer Lived A Full Life Helping Many

I was sadden to learn of the death of Judge Doug Meyer.  Judge Meyer retired from the Criminal Court bench here in 2006.  Prior to that he had been the Chattanooga city judge for several years.  As a young attorney I tried many cases in front of Judge Meyer.  Also while I was awaiting my case to be tried, I would observe him on the bench.  Judge Meyer ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Blackburn Good As Gone

I didn’t know until I read John Adams’ column in the Knoxville News-Sentinel that one person who doesn't personally know UTC Athletic Director David Blackburn said he heard he has a drinking problem. I also didn’t know that “the best thing to ever happen to UTC athletics” had health problems, according to a second person who does not personally know him. It is also being said David ... (click for more)

MVP Howard Leads Bradley To Seventh Straight District 5-3A Tourney Title

Two key Bradley Central scoring sprees spelled basketball doom for East Hamilton in Monday’s District 5-3A tournament championship game at Soddy-Daisy. One, the top-ranked and unbeaten Bearettes (29-0) went on a 15-1 to close the second quarter, building a 37-20 halftime lead. Two, Bradley Central started the third period on a 22-6 run and extended the lead to 59-26 and ... (click for more)

Brainerd Girls, Howard Boys Win 6-AA Consolations

It was consolation night at Hixson High School for the District 6-AA basketball tournament and East Ridge came out on the short end in both games. Brainerd’s girls rallied for a 39-35 win in the first game while Howard’s Hustlin’ Tigers did enough at the end to hold off the East Ridge boys by a 61-57 final. The tournament concludes on Tuesday with both championship games. ... (click for more)