In My Humble Opinion: No Time Like The Present

Sunday, December 19, 2004 - by Mike North
Mike North
Mike North

Why put off until tomorrow what can be done today? That is the pressing question for Congress and the administration as President Bush prepares for his second term. The pressing issues are tax reform and Social Security reform.

As the economy continues to pick up steam in the wake of recent tax reductions, only the most stubborn critics can deny a proven historical fact: lower tax rates lead to economic growth. Four times in history our leaders have responded to recession with tax cuts, four times the economy has responded with economic growth. The increased growth led to growth in revenue to the federal coffers.

It’s not enough to say, “Let’s make the Bush cuts permanent.” Nothing in Washington is permanent. This year’s “permanent” tax cut can be repealed next year. It’s time for total systemic change. Two tax reform proposals are being kicked about in discussions. One is a flat tax, the other a national retail sales tax.

Either proposal is better than the “Marx Lite” version of progressive taxation that we have today, but I favor the “Fair Tax” proposal – the national retail sales tax.

The two primary complaints against the sales tax are that it would add too much to the consumer price of goods, and that it would be unfair to the poor. Neither is true.

Every consumer good you buy today has embedded in its price about 20 to 25 percent of its cost in corporate taxes and compliance costs. Most serious economists who have studied this proposal agree that these costs will disappear when the sales tax takes effect. Decrease the price by 20% when corporate taxes are eliminated; add 20% back in for the retail sales tax. Voila – no price increase. And those below a certain income level, be they elderly or simply the working poor, will be entitled to either an exemption or rebate. According to Americans for Fair Taxation, a family of four earning less than $24,980 would pay no tax, and a family of four earning less than $49,960 would only pay at the11.5 percent rate.

Another benefit is that we, as consumers, control to a certain extent how much we pay in taxes. Want to keep more of your money? Cut back on that spending just a little, and save what you would have given to Uncle Sam. Our tax code has for too long offered no real incentive for saving. The Fair Tax proposal would change that.

One of the best features is this: no more withholding, except for Medicare and Social Security. If you make $40,000 per year, you bring home most of that.

Speaking of Social Security, that is the area most in need of reform. Forget all of the rhetoric and political posturing. Just look at a few simple facts. When the Social Security Act took effect, there were 40 workers for every retiree. The plan was financed with a 3% payroll tax. There are now three workers for every retiree, and the Social Security tax rate is 12 percent. If nothing is done to reform this program, by the time the baby boom generation retires there will be less than two workers per retiree, and the effective rate to support the program will be between 16 and 20 percent. Even with these rates, the program may be 10 trillion dollars in debt by that time. If nothing changes, the program will go into the red by 2014, and by 2037 it will be insolvent.

Do we want our children to pay 1 dollar out of every five to support us? And what of their prospects for retirement under such a system?

We could wait until the problem reaches crisis proportions to take action, or we can begin now with a common sense, systematic approach to the problem. Let’s allow those who still have time to pad their own nest egg to retain and invest a portion of their social security taxes in private accounts. The remainder of their payroll taxes will go toward funding survivor and disability benefits.

Such a program, initiated early enough and pursued progressively, can offer retirement benefits equal to or better than the current system while remaining solvent. And solvency is something the current plan simply cannot guarantee.

President Bush and Congress have a chance to make history. They can either coddle the groups that have a vested interest in the current system of taxation and retirement funding, or they can step out and look toward the future – and help improve the futures of those who deserve no less reliable a system than their parents enjoyed.

For information on the Fair Tax proposal, visit

For information on Social Security reform, visit

(Mike North writes a regular op-ed column for six newspapers in the southeast Tennessee, northwest Georgia and northeast Alabama region. He is a professional land surveyor with True Line Company, Land Surveyors. He is a former Walker County School Board member and a student of history and political science. He can be reached at
His columns are at
Mike North Columns )

Good Discussions About Education

I had the pleasure to represent Tennessee PTA at the National PTA Legislative Conference in Washington, DC. I want to thank Senator Bob Corker for allowing me to speak about education and school safety to his legislative assistant. We had a good discussion about common sense school safety measures and about supporting family education. In particular, I asked for support about ... (click for more)

Can Anyone Say Who's Relieving Themselves At Downtown Establishments?

Roy, as usual you run first without getting all the facts. I've known several people, even relatives, who work or have worked at downtown restaurants or other places of business. It's not unusual for them to happen upon some individual, not a beggar or homeless person, while taking out trash or going outside on a break, spraying the side of a restaurant wall while relieving themselves, ... (click for more)

Strong Wave Of Storms Could Bring Possibility Of Tornadoes, Large Hail

The National Weather Service is warning that a strong line of storms moving into the Chattanooga area on Monday could bring the possibility of tornadoes and large hail. The storm will cause temperatures to drop on Tuesday and Wednesday into the 30s. Here is the special weather statement: THUNDERSTORMS EXPECTED LATE THIS AFTERNOON AND EVENING ACROSS THE PLATEAU, PARTS ... (click for more)

North Carolina Corporation Resubmits Rezoning Request For 38,000-Square-Foot Grocery Store On Signal

Undeterred by the standing-room-only crowds who turned out last year to oppose its proposal to build a 38,000-square-foot supermarket directly across Taft Highway from Signal’s longtime hometown grocery, a North Carolina-based corporation has resubmitted its rezoning request.   This time around, however, the Keith Corp. (TKC) isn’t asking that the entire 8.25 ... (click for more)

Ooltewah Wins Wildcat Classic Again

Early season prep baseball tournaments are meant for a few things; primarily competition, repetition, and learning a few things about your team over the course of a few games.   The Ooltewah Owl baseball nine apparently has learned it likes collecting championship trophies in them as well.   For the second year in a row, the Owls won the longstanding ... (click for more)

Lady Vols Fall To Oregon State, 66-59, In 2nd Round Of NCAA's

KNOXVILLE-- Senior center Mercedes Russell logged her 46th career double-double with 21 points and 14 rebounds to lead Tennessee, but it wasn't enough as the No. 12/13 Lady Vols (25-8) fell to No. 13/12 Oregon State (25-7) in the second round of the NCAA Women's Basketball Tournament. Freshman Anastasia Hayes also had a double-digit outing for the No. 3 seed Lady Vols, posting ... (click for more)