Bart Whiteman: What Does Sixty-Five Percent Mean?

Monday, May 30, 2005 - by Bart Whiteman

Recently, several local media sources have been reporting the fact that a 65% majority of Tennesseans support an anti-gay marriage amendment to the Constitution as if this information was worthy of reporting or some sort of surprise. What should be a surprise is that 35% of Tennesseans don’t support such a move. This is such an easy bandwagon to get on.

There is very little threat to oneself in preaching or supporting discrimination against gay couples. They are not exactly likely to be out there taking over public buildings or leading urban riots. Their economic leverage is miniscule.

You have to wonder who or what is pushing for this fact to get it such broad coverage. It is not exactly new news. The numbers haven’t changed much and are unlikely to do so for the foreseeable future. Is it news that people harbor bigotry in their souls and try to dress it up with religious pronunciations and documentation or claims that the “majority” supports the curtailment of someone else’s life and options?

If “majority” support were the criteria for everything, we would live in a very bizarre world indeed. For years, during the suffragette movement, the majority of women didn’t think they had the right to vote. Men knew best how to make important decisions. The “majority” of Germans voted Adolf Hitler into power knowing full well what he stood for and supported him right up until the end. You could probably find some who still do. You probably could have taken a poll among Black slaves in America around 1750 and learned that the “majority” preferred the known perils of slavery as opposed to the unknown perils of freedom.

In fact, most of the Earth’s wiser and better developments have started as minority actions, sometimes a minority of one. Many of these “ones” are now household names – Columbus, Einstein, Wright, Luther, Edison, Walton, Ford et al, and even Jesus. If any of these people had waited for majority support, they’d be waiting still. It takes time for a majority to be won over or to see the light, sometimes a long time. Didn’t the “majority” of the throng vote to have Jesus crucified when they had the chance? Pilate just counted the votes.

People will always favor what they know, the familiar ground. Very few Tennesseans have had to deal with the reality of gay marriage. Most gay people move away from places like Tennessee when they can. A few remain, mostly in the closet. I once taught at a prominent boy’s school in Tennessee where it was obvious that if anyone were to actually be “overt” on campus, they would probably get killed. It very nearly happened.

In the sort of environment of ignorance and malice that exists around this issue in Tennessee, we are supposed to put a firm belief in and commitment to any precipitous action like amending the Constitution? It is a sad commentary that this revered document has been devalued to the point of being a nothing more than a volleyball that can be batted and blown around in the wind, subject to the whim of every kook and their cousins. Sadder still is that we have among us “educated” politicians who should know better, but still prey upon these prejudicial matters in order to gain political favor and electoral victory.

It may be a long time before the “majority” of people are comfortable with the idea of gay marriage. However, the issue is hardly going to go away even if the Constitution is amended. Somehow I believe there was a grander purpose to its design than the chore of fencing people in.

As fate would have it, our Founding Fathers seemed to understand this perverse inclination of mankind and included numerous items in the Constitution that needed a two-thirds majority to override or vote in. Simple majorities were not good enough to stem and check the tide of fashion, trend, inclination, popularity, and all the other attendant ills of large groups of people. You had to do something a little more than temporarily convincing most of the people in the room to get your way.

Lately, there has been a movement afoot to do away with this safeguard in practically every instance. Everything is to be decided by a simple majority, no matter how slim. The “majority” is in a pout and wants to change the rules so they can have it all. 65% support of the gay marriage ban would mean that they are still two percentage points away from reaching even the Constitutional threshold. The answer: do away with the Constitutional threshold. Dialogue, reason, compromise, the art of argumentation, and the art of the deal are becoming lost arts and are giving way to locked steps and locked minds. Why be artful when you have money and might?

At some point, this masterful “majority” will have to come to grips with the basic transitory nature of human and all existence on the planet. “And the first shall be last…”

Bart Whiteman
Bartwhiteman@aol.com



City Puts Another Crimp In The Fading Affordable House

We love to have conversations around affordable housing and how big bad developers are only chasing the dirty dollar. But then the same administration proposes an increase in all the costs that go into an affordable house. We see countless examples of building codes and zoning ordinances tightening up regulations. A couple months ago, Red Bank increased the minimum house size (tax ... (click for more)

Equity Study - And Response

What exactly is an Equity Study? Is the the damage control that comes in the wake of the UnifiEd outburst a few weeks ago? I can save the board a whole lot of hassle since the mere mention of doing such a study means that the study will reveal inequities, regardless of any basis.  If they would like to throw a quarter million down the drain for 20 pages ... (click for more)

Corker, Aide Help Gain Release Of Holts From Venezuelan Prison

 Senator Bob Corker (R-Tenn.), chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, welcomed the release of American citizen Josh Holt and his wife, Thamy, who have been detained in a Venezuelan prison for the last two years.   “I am pleased to join Senator Hatch and President Trump in announcing the release of Josh and Thamy Holt,” said Senator Corker. “Senator ... (click for more)

1st Vote On Controversial Signal Mountain Grocery Proposal Set June 13; Town To Choose Either Tennessee American Or Waldens Ridge For Water Service

The next steps in rezoning 617 Cauthen Way were discussed at the Signal Mountain work session Friday afternoon. Since the last council meeting, Town Manager Boyd Veal created a list of conditions to include in the zoning ordinance relating to the proposed commercial development designed to assure that there is no negative impact to the surrounding properties or to the interest of ... (click for more)

Summertown Stops Sale Creek's Bid For A State Class 1A State Softball Title, 7-5

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – Sale Creek had its sight set on making some softball history Friday. The Lady Panthers reached their first TSSAA state softball championship with a 3-1 victory over Cascade, powered by a Trinity Liner three-run homer on her 18 th birthday. A few hours later, they wanted to beat Summertown and set up a second title game for all the marbles. ... (click for more)

Silverdale Wins D-II-A State Softball Title

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – Kaili Phillips got disqualified in the first inning of Thursday’s game against the Tipton-Rosemark Lady Rebels and nobody gave the Silverdale Lady Seahawks a snowball’s chance of winning that game. But they did. Nobody gave the Lady Seahawks much of a chance of repeating that feat less than 24 hours later in the winner-take-all final game, but once again, ... (click for more)