Breaking News


Hilt Murder Case Moved To Another Judge

Wednesday, May 10, 2006
Nicholas Hilt staggers into court. Click to enlarge.
Nicholas Hilt staggers into court. Click to enlarge.

A murder case has been switched to another judge after Criminal Court Judge Doug Meyer called the defendant "the scum of the earth" and said he "deserves the death penalty."

District Attorney Bill Cox asked for the change, saying, "You do not want to take a chance on possible error."

The murder trial of Nicholas Hilt will be heard by Criminal Court Judge Don Poole beginning June 5.

Hilt once again acted up in court on Wednesday. He let out a blood-curdling scream soon after he was seated at the defense table. He dropped to the floor and a squad of officers immediately surrounded him.

Hilt is outfitted with a device on his leg that can be used to shock him if he is disruptive. He was trying to take the device off in court. It was unclear whether he was given a shock.

Attorney Lee Ortwein had filed a motion to have Judge Meyer recuse himself after the judge made the remarks in court on Monday. Judge Meyer denied the motion.

A jury was selected on Tuesday. Opening statements had been set for Wednesday at 10 a.m.

A new jury will be selected to hear the case.

Hilt twice had to be removed from the courtroom during jury selection as he began screaming and acting out.

Hilt is charged with beating to death his girlfriend's 5-year-old son. The state is seeking a first-degree murder conviction, but not the death penalty.

Hilt had come to court on several occasions in a wheelchair and was non-responsive. However, on Monday he walked into court and was very animated. On Wednesday, he limped to his seat.

Judge Meyer said a defendant can be strapped to a seat if necessary. Or the trial can be conducted without the defendant present.

A mental health expert earlier testified that Hilt was refusing to take medication. The expert said as long as he is on the drug he is competent to stand trial. Judge Meyer ordered him to take the medicine, or he said he will be forced to take it.

Authorities say Hilt repeatedly slammed Nathaniel Upshaw against a wall on the night of Jan. 6, 2003.

Officers said Hilt has made a taped confession to the brutal assault.

Authorities said the young boy was sexually assaulted and that he died of "massive internal injuries and head trauma."

He was brought to a hospital the next morning, but was unconscious until he died.

Hilt is charged with murder, child rape, attempted first-degree murder and aggravated child abuse.

The mother, Altreasa Upshaw, is charged with accessory to murder, aggravated child abuse and filing a false police report.

Judge Doug Meyer
Judge Doug Meyer

Latest County Jail Booking Reports

Here are the latest county jail booking reports from Hamilton County and Walker County: Hamilton County: ANDERSON, TIFFANY M 6616 FLAGSTONE DRIVE OOLTEWAH, 37363 28 Hamilton County     DOMESTIC ASSAULT     ASSAULT     RESISTING ARREST AVILES, DANIEL 190 HIDDEN LANE SPRING CITY, 37381 54 Soddy Daisy     ... (click for more)

Pickup Truck Crosses To Wrong Side Of Hixson Pike: Other Driver Killed

A pickup truck went across Hixson Pike into the opposing lane of traffic on Saturday afternoon, then struck another vehicle. The driver of that car was killed. At 4:51 p.m., Chattanooga Police officers responded to the traffic crash at 4900 Hixson Pike.  The officers found that a pickup truck driven by a 68-year-old man was southbound on Highway 153 and exited onto southbound ... (click for more)

We Are Blessed To Have Ron Littlefield As Our Mayor - And Response (2)

Chattanooga is blessed beyond measure to have Ron Littlefield as our mayor.  It is a total travesty our city has had to endure the long frivolous battle with absolutely  no foundation other than disagreement with policy issues.  It has always been a vendetta directed personally at Mayor Littlefield which, if the "interveners" decide to appeal, will be a proven fact.   ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: What 17 Pills Did To Me

Ah, step into my parlor of first-hand wisdom because, in the School of Hard Knocks, there are priceless lessons that you should know before it becomes your turn to dance. Never in my life have I ever had any back problems but, in early December, I came down with what is called sciatica and I have been a miserable man ever since. There are two big nerves that sprout out of the ... (click for more)

Moc Wrestlers Drop Two At National Duals

The University of Tennessee at Chattanooga wrestling team dropped a pair of matches in the National Wrestling Coaches Association Cliff Keen National Duals Presented by Hibiclens and The Marines in Stillwater, Okla., today. The Mocs fell to No. 10 Wyoming (38-6) and Boise State (25-17) to drop to 11-6 overall. Chattanooga, the fifth seed in the six-team regional, only got ... (click for more)

Kentucky Softball Signs Silverdale's Henderson, Soddy-Daisy's Nunley

LEXINGTON, Ky. –   After racking up the best season in school history in 2011, UK softball coach Rachel Lawson has signed a heralded class of eight highly-touted athletes from across the country for the 2013 season. The Wildcats have signed Silverdale Baptist Academy's Katie Henderson (Hixscon, Tenn.), Kelsey Nunley (Soddy Daisy, Tenn.), Darington Richardson (Duluth, ... (click for more)