Mike Costello: Evaluating The Valuator – Valuation Report Review

Tuesday, May 02, 2006 - by Mike Costello
Mike Costello
Mike Costello

When a valuation practitioner provides a report, how do you really know if it’s any good? Although the value may appear reasonable, the valuation report’s technical contents may be hard to follow. “What’s the difference between a discount rate and a capitalization rate?” you may ask. “What do ‘net free cash flow’ and ‘guideline company’ mean? Help!”

If you’ve ever had trouble evaluating whether an appraiser has written a good report, you’re not alone. Juries often have to decide this issue. Rather than rely on blind faith, here are some guidelines and resources to consider when reviewing business valuation reports.

What To Look For

To start, take the time to read the entire report. If you don’t have the time (or the patience), ask your company’s controller or another trusted manager to review it and jot down a list of questions. Generally, the report should contain the following basic information:

Definition of the entity being valued. This definition should include the “as of” date, the company’s name, the number of shares, the valuation’s purpose and the entity type. When it comes to applying valuation discounts, an important part of the definition is the basis of value: Is it a controlling or minority interest? Is the interest marketable or nonmarketable?

Company information. Throughout a valuation report, the appraiser should consider a company’s unique characteristics. Internal factors to consider include the company’s:

History,
Ownership,
Management,
Products and services,
Customers,
Suppliers,
Facilities, and
Employees.

Appraisers should also consider external factors that affect the company, such as the national and local economies, government regulations, and demographic trends.

Valuation procedures. An experienced valuation practitioner will perform a site visit as well as a detailed financial analysis. Any information he or she uses in the report should have been available (or at least foreseeable) at the valuation’s “as of” date. For instance, if an appraiser is valuing a business as of June 1 and a tornado destroys the facilities on June 2, he or she shouldn’t consider the tornado’s effects.

Valuation methodology. Appraisers can choose from a variety of approaches and methodologies. Depending on the company’s unique characteristics, some methods make more sense than others do. A valuation report should discuss all of the valuation practitioner’s options, including why some approaches may be more appropriate than others.

Valuation discounts. After applying a valuation approach, the appraiser should discuss whether to apply valuation discounts (or premiums) to the preliminary value. Common discounts include the minority interest and marketability discounts. If discounts are applied, the valuation practitioner should discuss when he or she chose a specific discount, based on empirical evidence and the company’s unique characteristics. Novice appraisers often simply apply averages from empirical studies without providing support for their numbers. Such unsupported discounts can make you vulnerable to an IRS or courtroom attack.

Value conclusion. Finally, ask whether the value conclusion makes economic sense, considering both the hypothetical buyer and the hypothetical seller. For example, in divorce cases, spouses that own businesses are often criticized for considering only the hypothetical buyer, thereby undervaluing the business.

Other Points To Check

If your expert covered everything listed above, you may be confident that he or she prepared a quality report. But if you need more convincing, you may want to review:

Workpaper files. To save time (and possibly money), some valuation practitioners omit certain details from their reports. For example, an expert may perform a thorough financial analysis but only touch on it briefly in the report. Regardless of the report’s contents, the workpaper file should contain in-depth information about the steps your valuation practitioner took to value the business. To better understand your expert’s work, ask for a copy of his or her workpaper file.

In a litigation setting, consider issuing a subpoena for the opposing expert’s files. You may find evidence in an inexperienced valuation practitioner’s files, such as draft versions of reports, confidential memos or uncleared review points, which could help you improve your case.

Valuation organization guidelines. Most experienced appraisers belong to one or more professional organizations specializing in business valuation, such as the National Association of Certified Valuation Analysts (NACVA), the Institute of Business Appraisers (IBA), or the American Society of Appraisers (ASA). Each organization lists report requirements. Contact the one to which your expert belongs to find out exactly what his or her report must include.

Another valuation practitioner. Chances are, your valuation report will contain complex analyses that you can’t fully comprehend. Ask your valuation practitioner to explain any confusing information. You might also want to contact another valuation practitioner and hire him or her to review your expert’s report. This alternative is especially practical if you’re bogged down and don’t feel comfortable handing your valuation report to a company insider for review.

If you’re involved in litigation, it’s often a good idea to hire another expert to review the opposing expert’s report. In such a review, your valuation professional can point out weaknesses and flaws in the opposition’s report, and can help develop more pointed deposition and trial questions. Attorneys are legal experts but not necessarily valuation experts—so a valuation report can be as confusing to them as it is to business owners.

IRS Guidelines and Revenue Ruling 59-60

The IRS provides a wealth of useful information when it comes to valuation reports. One such useful source is the IRS’s Business Valuation Guidelines, which include the International Glossary of Business Valuation Terms and the Valuation Report Checklist. To download a free copy of the IRS guidelines, click on “free downloads” at the Business Valuation Resources’ Web site at www.bvlibrary.com.

Revenue Ruling 59-60 is another useful IRS resource. This ruling clearly defines the term “fair market value” and provides a list of eight items valuation practitioner’s need to consider when valuing a business, including:

1. The nature of the business,
2. The economy,
3. The company’s adjusted book value,
4. The company’s earning capacity,
5. The company’s dividend-paying capacity,
6. Goodwill,
7. Sales of comparable companies, and
8. Prior transactions of the company’s stock.
Don’t Take Chances

If you’re sending the report to the IRS or using it in court, you certainly want to minimize your risks. These steps can help increase your confidence that a valuation report is well-supported and well-reasoned. Please call with any valuation questions you may have. We would be glad to advise you.

Local Case Study

In recent litigation, we became involved in reviewing both the plaintiff’s and the defendant’s expert business valuation reports in a shareholder oppression lawsuit. The plaintiff’s expert had recently died, and his firm did not have another credentialed business valuation expert to testify concerning the value of the business.

The defendant’s expert, a Certified Valuation Analyst (CVA), gave testimony at trial, and a CPA/ABV (Certified Public Accountant Accredited in Business Valuation) from Decosimo Corporate Finance also testified. The defendant’s attorney called this the classic ”battle of the experts”, because each valuation expert gave many good reasons to support his respective company value.

The jury never had the opportunity to decide the valuation issue, so we’ll never know who won this “battle”. The parties reached a confidential settlement before the judge sent the decision to the jury.

But we do know this, each expert fought diligently in defending his valuation of the company.


(D. Michael Costello is a Certified Public Accountant, business appraiser and consultant with more than 15 years of training and experience in business valuations and appraisals, business acquisitions and divestitures, and related fields.

He has written several articles for the Tennessee CPA and the AICPA’s Management Consultant newsletter.

He was the Managing Director and President of Costello, Strain & Company, PC, a CPA firm he established in May 1984. The firm was merged with Joseph Decosimo and Company, LLP, CPA’s in September 2003. Joseph Decosimo and Company, LLP was founded in 1972 and today is one of the top 100 CPA firms in the nation.)


The Gear Closet Teams With Clean Vibes To Recover Camping Gear

In April, 2012, Tenne-SEA (Student Environmental Alliance) opened a resale shop for gently used outdoor gear and clothing called the Gear Closet.  Since then, it has grown and this year joined forces with CleanVibes, the company which oversees clean up after big music festivals.   They were invited to Bonnaroo to to help them keep usable camping gear out of the ... (click for more)

New And Used Vehicle Sales Rise In September

New vehicle sales in Hamilton County rose to 1,159 in September, and used vehicle sales rose to 3,435, according to figures from the County Clerk's office. That compares to 1,121 new vehicles sold and 3,179 used vehicles sold in September of last year. Totals for September included 527 new cars and 632 new trucks sold. They included 1,770 used cars and 1,665 used trucks sold. (click for more)

Teen, 17, Charged With Aggravated Rape In Attack On 69-Year-Old North Chattanooga Runner

A 17-year-old has been charged with aggravated rape in connection with an attack on a 69-year-old runner in North Chattanooga on Monday morning. The teen was identified by Juvenile Court officials as Diontae Smartt. Authorities said he has given a confession. Smartt has a detention hearing Thursday at 12:30. The incident happened at approximately 7:30 a.m. ... (click for more)

Berke Implements New Pay Plan For Chattanooga Fire Department

Mayor Andy Berke joined the International Association of Fire Fighters (IAFF) and leadership of the Chattanooga Fire Department to unveil the department’s new pay plan Wednesday afternoon. At a press conference at Fire Hall #1 on Main Street, Mayor Berke and IAFF Local 820 President Jack Thompson signed a memorandum of understanding which sets forth regular raises for fire ... (click for more)

Leaders Lead On Amendment 1

This week the Hamilton County Commission was faced with what I believe may be one of the most important votes they have cast during their tenure.  Granted, the vote was over a "mere" Resolution that resulted in no overt action or new law in our county.  But there are times when simply speaking Truth and taking a stand on a foundational Principle is paramount and as such ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Expert Reasons Why To Vote

Early voting for the November election begins two weeks from today so please jump-start your plans that will assure your choices will be counted. In a fun-filled attempt to show what some of those who actually vote do during the rest of the day, I offer two examples of “those who live among us” from experts. The first are a series of questions from readers of “Dear Abby” who ask ... (click for more)