Roy Exum: Chattanooga's Little Lie

Tuesday, October 23, 2007 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

A wave of immeasurable sadness swept across a city this morning when it was learned that Ron Litttlefield, the mayor of Chattanooga, had willingly become part of a sham.

The mayor, who acts for all the people of the city, has announced he will hire embattled former Councilwoman Marti Rutherford for just three days in November so she can become eligible for post-employment benefits.

Marti was embroiled in scandal last month after allegations she lived in the wrong district were convincingly proven. Marti finally quieted the firestorm when she resigned from office, but not before bringing mockery and shame to the other council members and those who elected her.

On Monday the Chattanooga mayor, who had publicly distanced himself from the uproar until now, violated the same public trust when he, in surely an effort of friendship and kindness, revealed he too would mock life’s rule book with what can best be described as “a little lie” to hoodwink the city’s insurance carriers.

Understand, I feel sorry for Marti Rutherford and I believe the 61-year-old woman will someday need medical benefits, but without life’s rules we don’t have standards and, if we fail those standards, none of us have a chance.

I believe Marti thought she was living “a little lie.” But by the time the flames had reached their zenith, after she had gotten a lawyer and smeared herself in gallons of printer’s ink and yards of video tape, that lie had grown into something none of us want to be – a pugnacious cheat.

When she finally resigned from office, there was a collective sigh and all that remained was the question of sanity in anyone who would run such a gauntlet for only $18,000 a year.

But now, in a very sad twist, the mayor himself has revealed a disregard for life’s rules by abusing his power and giving Marti “a little job” in a move that regretfully has the same early markings that “a little lie” does.

You see, the “city” doesn’t offer employee benefits – its citizens, the people, do. And, with kindergarteners all over town being taught “two wrongs don’t make a right,” you can well anticipate an immediate outcry that will put Marti’s own fiasco into the shadows.

The mayor said he expects “political repercussions” over his decision, but that is hardly as worrisome as the larger scope that will place Ron Littlefield under such intense scrutiny for his willingness to also play outside the lines.

The rules are in place for a reason, be they in an employee benefits manual or The Holy Bible. Everybody who plays in a contest is expected to know the rules adroitly and is expected to abide by them to the letter.

When one does not play by the rules, be it living in one district while representing another or fostering a three-day “little lie” to an insurance carrier, there are penalties and, believe me, politics has nothing to do with what is right and what is wrong.

How do we now explain that the mayor of Chattanooga has awarded a cheater with three days on the people’s payroll so that then the two of them can cheat those same people who will pay the difference in the first cheater’s post-employment medical benefits?

Today that is the toughest question in town and, as it is answered in the coming days, you might brace yourself for what happens when somebody tells “a little lie.”

royexum@aol.com


A Good School Takes Involvement

As I have read the articles concerning Normal Park School I can’t keep from thinking when our children started to school in the 1960‘s. The two elementary schools in the city that were considered tops were Barger and Woodmore. We did not live in the zone for either school so we looked for a house to buy that was zoned for Woodmore.   We found ... (click for more)

Government Liability Insurance Is A Bad Idea For Tennessee

Professional Educators of Tennessee opposes the recently introduced legislation HB 2170. This legislation would require the Department of Education to purchase a liability insurance policy for all professional employees through the state’s competitive bid process.  It specifies that the policy shall cover errors and omissions, attorney fee reimbursement in criminal and civil ... (click for more)

Mother Of Man Charged With Killing Sgt. Chapin Given Prison Sentence Of 30 Years, 6 Months

The mother of the man charged with killing Chattanooga Police Sgt. Tim Chapin was sentenced Monday to serve 30 years and six months in federal prison.  Judge Sandy Mattice said the sentence for Kathleen Mathews, 57-year-old mother of Jesse Mathews, as a packed courtroom watched.  Ray Mathews, 51-year-old father of Jesse Mathews, must serve 20 years and 10 months. ... (click for more)

Vince Dean Picks Up For Senate Race; Tommie Brown Headed For Contest With JoAnne Favors

Rep. Vince Dean has picked up papers to run for the Senate District 10 seat now held by Democrat Andy Berke. And Rep. Tommie Brown picked up papers to retain her District 28 seat. That sets up a clash with Rep. JoAnne Favors, who picked up for District 28 earlier. Under Republican redistricting, Rep. Favors wound up in the Brown district. Rep. Dean, a Republican from East ... (click for more)

Lady Mocs Host Georgia Southern Monday On Autograph Night

The Lady Mocs will be gunning for their 13th SoCon victory Monday night when they host Georgia Southern at McKenzie Arena at 7 p. m. Following the game, the Lady Mocs players and coaches will be courtside for an autograph session. The Lady Mocs and the Eagles have met 48 times with UTC holding a 30-18 advantage. At home, Chattanooga is 18-4 against Georgia Southern but struggle ... (click for more)

Jay Fowler, Chris Walker To Speak at Quarterback Club

Jay Fowler and Chris Walker of Fellowship of Christian Athletes are the guest speakers for Monday's Chttanooga Quarterback Club at Finley Stadium at noon. Fowler, a Tyner and West Point graduate,  is the director of The Greater Chattanooga FCA, while Walker, a former University of Tennessee football player, is the FCA campus director for the Chattanooga ... (click for more)