Soddy-Daisy Commission Pays Wimpies For Damages Caused By Public Works Error

Saturday, December 20, 2008 - by Jim Ashley
David Smith Sr., left, and his son, David, co-owners of Wimpies Country Restaurant, talk to the Soddy Daisy City Commission.
David Smith Sr., left, and his son, David, co-owners of Wimpies Country Restaurant, talk to the Soddy Daisy City Commission.
- photo by Jim Ashley

The Soddy-Daisy City Commission made the owners and employees of Wimpies Country Restaurant very happy Thursday evening when the governing body voted to give them an early Christmas present, $1,835.

New commissioner Shane Harmon, who said he was a frequent visitor to the restaurant, was instrumental in making the gift possible.

Meeting with the commission during its regularly scheduled second December meeting, Mr. Harmon pointed out that the city’s public works department accidentally cut the gas line to the popular Soddy-Daisy eating establishment Thursday and forced it to shut down its business the rest of the day.

Public works personnel, he explained, were digging on the road in front of Wimpies when the accidental cut occurred.

David Smith, co-owner with his father, David Smith Sr., told the commission that he not only lost money, but his employees also lost wages and tips and that “it hurts right here at Christmas.”

The younger Smith explained to the commission that the restaurant lost $1,835 in sales and tips and food that he had purchased and prepared but had to throw away.

“I personally think he needs to be compensated,” Mr. Harmon said, making a motion to the commission. “I feel like we did it. I feel like we’re responsible. I’m not pointing a finger at anybody and saying it’s anybody’s fault, but if you’re digging, you’re going to tear something out today.”

Mr. Harmon then said that the marking company that marked the area for identifying the gas line may be at fault but that marking companies “don’t like to take responsibility for anything.”

The commissioner noted that he knows that is true because he owns a company that has used marking companies that incorrectly marked areas that resulted in mistakes and cost him money.

“I’m up for suggestions on how to handle this,” he said of the Wimpies situation.

Soddy-Daisy City Attorney Sam Elliott said the commission should first find out who was at fault and noted that, according to law, the city may not be liable for such mistakes when it involves “our right of way.”

He suggested that the commission contact its “insurance carrier and see what their viewpoint is.”

Public Works Director Bill Renfro said the gas lines were plastic and that their exact location could not be determined by a metal detector.

Mr. Harmon said that “regardless of what our insurance carrier says, the right thing is we are responsible. You either do the right thing or you weasel out of it. I’m not saying that’s what we want to do, but an insurance carrier 99 out of a hundred will try its best to weasel out of anything.”

A lengthy discussion ensued and included a request by Commissioner Jim Adams to “get more information” and a comment by Vice Mayor Bob Privett that those who incorrectly marked the site should be “considered for liability.”

Mr. Adams also expressed concern that compensating Wimpies might set a precedent that could be costly for the city in the future.

Commissioner David Skiles noted that the Smiths have been an asset to the Soddy-Daisy community for years and that he was making a motion to “pay him what he says we owe him because I don’t think anybody else will accept fault.”

Mr. Harmon noted that he had already made a motion for the compensation. The commission then voted to approve the motion and also to pursue identifying others who might me liable.

Also during the Thursday meeting, the commission approved on first reading an ordinance “creating a new Section 3-206 of the municipal code relating to the employment of collection agencies to collect municipal fines and cost.”

Additionally, the commission discussed hiring a company via low bid to clean up brush on city-owned property, mulch it and make the mulch available to city residents.

The meeting began with Cathy Loftis presenting numerous awards to Soddy-Daisy organizations who participated in the recent Christmas parade.


Latest County Jail Booking Reports

Here are the latest county jail booking reports from Hamilton County and Walker County: Hamilton County: APPLEBERRY, CARLOS DEMETRIUS 2404 5TH AVENUE CHATTANOOGA, 37406 23 Hamilton County     CRIMINAL TRESPASSING BALLARD, CHRISTOPHER JAMES GLEASON DRIVE APT 57 EAST RIDGE, 37412 23 East Ridge     DRIVING ON REVOKED, SUSPENDED ... (click for more)

Cleveland Council Applauds School Crossing Guard With 45 Years Of Service; City Getting Pool And Splash Park

 The Cleveland City Council began their voting meeting Monday afternoon by giving special recognition to Claudine Ensley for her 45 years of service as a crossing guard. She began her career at Blythe Avenue Elementary and was later transferred to Blythe Bower Elementary.  Cleveland Mayor Tom Rowland stated, “One of the most difficult jobs in the city in my opinion ... (click for more)

Thoughs On The Mathews Sentencing

It is not by coincidence I haven’t submitted an opinion piece in some time to the Chattanoogan.  The topics I cover are generally vitriolic in regards to local political decisions and their makers regarding public safety and I do not wish to associate my name with more noble subjects such as that of the heroic death and cowardly murder of Chattanooga Police Sergeant Tim Chapin, ... (click for more)

Thank You, Judge Mattice And Chattanooga

I would like to thank Judge Mattice for handing down a 30.5 year sentence for Kathleen Mathews.  Obviously, no amount of jail time, fines, or lashings can bring back Tim Chapin.   A 30-year sentence will, however, make the world just a little safer.  That's what Sgt. Chapin would have wanted.  He was a protector and sacrificed his life so the rest of ... (click for more)

Ford's Game-Winner Leads Irish Past Chargers

Notre Dame is moving on.   The Irish advanced Monday night when steady Steadmon Ford drove a stake in the Chargers’ heart, draining a game-winning 3-pointer with 1.8 seconds left as No. 4 seed Notre Dame defeated fifth-seed Chattanooga Christian, 41-38, in District 7-AA tournament action in Phifer Gymnasium.   It was a thriller.   Notre Dame (10-14) ... (click for more)

Jay Fowler, Chris Walker To Speak at Quarterback Club

Jay Fowler and Chris Walker of Fellowship of Christian Athletes are the guest speakers for Monday's Chttanooga Quarterback Club at Finley Stadium at noon. Fowler, a Tyner and West Point graduate,  is the director of The Greater Chattanooga FCA, while Walker, a former University of Tennessee football player, is the FCA campus director for the Chattanooga ... (click for more)