Breaking News


Stuart James' Petition For House Race Not Accepted Due To Copy Error

Thursday, April 03, 2008

The petition by attorney Stuart James to run against Rep. JoAnne Favors for House District 29 was ruled invalid on Thursday morning - just before the qualifying deadline.

Charlotte Mullis-Morgan of the election office said someone in the James campaign had used a photocopy of a petition to gather names.

She said, "It was done improperly. Under state law, there cannot be any copies of documents."

Attorney James said he accepts the ruling. He said, "I messed up."

Linda Mosley got her petition in for School Board District 7. Also running are Michael Dzik and Kevin Burke.

Rhonda Thurman is unopposed.

Joe Dumas, a UTC professor, is running against Chip Baker.

Debra Matthews is opposed by Kenneth Simpson and Gregg Juster.

Congressman Zach Wamp has opposition from Democrat Doug Vandergriff and Independent Jean Howard-Hill.

Sheriff candidates are Democrat Greg Beck, Republican Jim Hammond and Independents Jim Winters and Tim Akins.

Legislators with no opposition are Rep. Richard Floyd, Gerald McCormick and Tommie Brown.

Former legislator Jim Vincent has qualified to try to unseat Rep. Jim Cobb of Rhea County in House District 31.

Basil Marceaux Jr. is running against Rep. Favors.

Basil Marceaux Sr. is opposing Sen. Andy Berke.

Attorney James said, "I just learned that the petition for office I filed with the election commission this morning could not be accepted by the Hamilton County Election Commission. Although we had enough signatures to qualify for office, and all signatures were original, one page of the petition was a copy signature page and could not be accepted to qualify for office.

"The responsibility is mine, to put it bluntly 'I messed up.' The rules governing the obtaining of signatures apparently require the signatures not only be original, but the signatures must be on the document that is the original document received from the Election Commission. A candidate is not permitted to copy a signature page, and put original signatures on the copied signature page. The signature page must be original. The signatures must be original.

"The responsibility, and blame, lie soley with me, not with the individuals who helped me get signatures. When I make a mistake I admit it, and the mistake and subesquent consequences are mine alone to bear. Fault does not lie with the election commission nor does it lie with any other individual in this quest for the State House of Representatives seat.

"Let me be clear - the Election Commission did its job.

"The first rule of politics is to plan ahead - I made a last minute decision to seek this seat. My message to anyone running for office, do not make this type of decision unless circumstances clearly dictate a last-minute run - under those circumstances be very careful.

"Timing is everything - my advice to candidates for office is to never make such a last minute decision. I felt, however, in making the decision that it was time for a new direction. I sincerely apologize to my supporters for my error. I know that as humans we make mistakes and I hope my supporters will forgive me.

"Life is full of hard knocks and we learn from our mistakes. I hope that I can be a better person and learn from this mistake.

"I am asking all of those who supported me to support JoAnne Favors for another term in the House. I hope that you cast your vote for her in the August primary and the November general election, I know that I will."

Mr. James also said, “I was asked to review the decision of the Election Commission regarding the rejection of the qualifying petition for state House. I reviewed the code section governing petitions, and although the code is very liberal on additional pages and appears not to require the same formalities as the issuance of the original petition, I have decided that the error is on my part and not on the part of the Election Commission. Therefore, I have decided not to pursue any appeal of the commission’s decision.

“The signatures on the photocopied petition are original and valid. However, the code appears to require that a candidate who wants extra pages go to the commission to obtain them. The Election Commission is allowed to photo copy additional pages, so long as the official 'shall indicate in the upper right hand corner of each page that the document was photocopied by the county Election Commission prior to distributing the form to a candidate.'

”I am, therefore, accepting responsibility for the error. Most of the signatures for the petition were on the copied page. Since the 'buck stops with me' I accept responsibility for the petition not being accepted by the state or local officials.”

Congress Third District

  • Jean Howard-Hill (I) qualified
  • Doug Vandergriff (D) qualified
  • Zach Wamp (R) qualified

    Tennessee Senate District 10

  • Andy Berke (D) qualified
  • Basil Marceaux Sr. (R) qualified

    House District 26

  • Gerald McCormick (R) qualified

    House District 27

  • Richard Floyd (R) qualified

    House District 28

  • Tommie Brown (D) qualified

    House District 29

  • JoAnne Favors (D) qualified
  • Basil Marceaux Jr. (R) qualified

    House District 30

  • Vince Dean (R) qualified

    House District 31 (parts of Hamilton and Rhea counties)

  • Jim Cobb (R) qualified
  • Jim Vincent (R) qualified

    County School Board District 1

  • Rhonda Thurman qualified

    County School Board District 2

  • Chip Baker qualified
  • Joe Dumas qualified

    County School Board District 4

  • Gregg Juster qualified
  • Debra Matthews qualified
  • Kenneth Simpson qualified

    County School Board District 7

  • Kevin Burke qualified
  • Michael Dzik qualified
  • Linda Mosley qualified

    Sheriff

  • Tim Akins (I) qualified
  • Greg Beck (D) qualified
  • Jim Hammond (R) qualified
  • Jim Winters (I) qualified

    The qualifying deadline was Thursday at noon.



  • Latest County Jail Booking Reports

    Here are the latest county jail booking reports from Hamilton County and Walker County: Hamilton County: ALLEN, JOHN R 615 SHERWOOD FORREST DRIVE RINGGOLD, 30736 51 Hamilton County     FAILURE TO APPEAR ARNOLD, MASON TUCKER 4801 NORTH ELDRIDGE ROAD HIXSON, 37343 34 Chattanooga     DOMESTIC ASSAULT ATKINS, TRACY DEWAYNE ... (click for more)

    Woman Critically Injured In Cleveland Crash

    A woman was critically injured in a crash in Cleveland on Wednesday night. Shortly after 7 p.m., there was a serious traffic accident on North Lee Highway at the intersection of North Lee and Tasso Lane. Bradley County Emergency Medical Service responded three ambulances and a paramedic supervisor to the scene. Involved was a dump truck, an Oldsmobile, and a Pathfinder. ... (click for more)

    In Defense Of Discretionary Spending

    Dear Roy,   I am flattered that you and I think a lot alike and that we both use the same 'Rule Book.'  I also agree with you that it is healthy to offer differing opinions.  However, I disagree with you on the issue of discretionary spending.   I did not see you at the Hamilton County Pachyderm Club meeting on Monday.  Sorry that I did not see you ... (click for more)

    Roy Exum: Tennessee’s ‘Saint’ Turns 50

    Back when I was in my late 20s, still really dumb but all eager to make a difference in the world, I got tangled up in a life-changing caper late one night. A close friend called and frantically asked if I knew anybody who had a private plane. She said a real sick child needed to get to St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital in Memphis  – it was desperate -- and the life-or-death ... (click for more)

    Moc Wrestlers Open National Duals With No. 10 Wyoming

    The University of Tennessee at Chattanooga wrestling team will take part in the National Wrestling Coaches Association Cliff Keen National Duals Presented by Hibiclens and The Marines this weekend. The Mocs (11-4, 4-1 SoCon) will compete at the Oklahoma State regional on Sunday, Feb. 12, in Stillwater, Okla. The 24-team event is broken into six regionals. The Mocs are the ... (click for more)

    Owls, Bearettes Favorites In District 5-AAA Tournament

    CLEVELAND, Tenn. – It was already obvious that Ooltewah’s Owls and Bradley Central’s state-ranked Bearettes, would be the No. 1 seeds for next week’s District 5-AAA high school basketball tournament at Bradley Central High School.   Everything else was cleared up when the district’s boys and girls coaches met Wednesday morning at the Mountain View Inn to iron out the ... (click for more)