Hearing On Constitutionality Of Red Bank’s Red Light Cameras Is June 30

Tuesday, June 03, 2008 - by Judy Frank

Red Bank officials will be in court June 30 to defend the constitutionality of their red-light camera program aimed at deterring traffic violations.

Soddy-Daisy resident Basil Marceaux, a frequent candidate for public office, is appealing his conviction in Red Bank City Court for running a red light.

The red light cameras – which are being utilized by hundreds of communities across the nation, including the city of Chattanooga – take photos of the rear license plates of vehicles that run red lights.
Red Bank employees then send citations to the registered owners of those vehicles, demanding that they pay $50 fines.

Mr. Marceaux received one of the letters last fall, and has been fighting the matter in court ever since.

In a document signed by both Red Bank City Attorney Arnold Stulce Jr. and Mr. Marceaux, the parties agreed to stipulate that “On September 16, 2007 at approximately 9:42 a.m., the defendant/appellant Basil Marceaux was driving a certain 1997 Mercedes automobile . . . at and through the intersection of Dayton Boulevard (southbound) at Signal Mountain Road in the city of Red Bank.”

But they agree on virtually nothing else, as evidenced by a voluminous file in Hamilton County Criminal Court packed with numerous documents that Mr. Marceaux has filed, contending that the town has no authority for the actions taken against him.

In the documents, Mr. Marceaux describes himself as “ombudsman for for all citizens (who) are victims of the Trojan Horse in the Battle of Troy which allows Red Bank to promote slavery.”

The gist of the case, Mr. Marceaux argued in a memorandum filed Tuesday, is that Red Bank officials and their attorney “are break(ing) the city charter at the same time laughing at higher court decisions . . . passing ordinances that are violating the city charter, the U.S. and state constitution while promoting slavery, at the same time collecting illegal funds to balance their budget.”

Red Bank, in turn, is asking Judge Rebecca Stern to dismiss Mr. Marceaux’s lawsuit on the grounds that the dispute is a civil matter and consequently should not be heard in a criminal court.

“Since this case is civil in nature, this matter is governed by rules in civil cases including retrial on appeal to . . . circuit court,” Mr. Stulce noted in a memorandum supporting the town’s position that the lawsuit should be dismissed.

Further, the attorney noted, none of the numerous arguments that Mr. Marceaux has filed with the court are relevant to the case.


Latest County Jail Booking Reports

Here are the latest county jail booking reports from Hamilton County and Walker County: Hamilton County: APPLEBERRY, CARLOS DEMETRIUS 2404 5TH AVENUE CHATTANOOGA, 37406 23 Hamilton County     CRIMINAL TRESPASSING BALLARD, CHRISTOPHER JAMES GLEASON DRIVE APT 57 EAST RIDGE, 37412 23 East Ridge     DRIVING ON REVOKED, SUSPENDED ... (click for more)

Cleveland Council Applauds School Crossing Guard With 45 Years Of Service; City Getting Pool And Splash Park

 The Cleveland City Council began their voting meeting Monday afternoon by giving special recognition to Claudine Ensley for her 45 years of service as a crossing guard. She began her career at Blythe Avenue Elementary and was later transferred to Blythe Bower Elementary.  Cleveland Mayor Tom Rowland stated, “One of the most difficult jobs in the city in my opinion ... (click for more)

Thoughs On The Mathews Sentencing

It is not by coincidence I haven’t submitted an opinion piece in some time to the Chattanoogan.  The topics I cover are generally vitriolic in regards to local political decisions and their makers regarding public safety and I do not wish to associate my name with more noble subjects such as that of the heroic death and cowardly murder of Chattanooga Police Sergeant Tim Chapin, ... (click for more)

Thank You, Judge Mattice And Chattanooga

I would like to thank Judge Mattice for handing down a 30.5 year sentence for Kathleen Mathews.  Obviously, no amount of jail time, fines, or lashings can bring back Tim Chapin.   A 30-year sentence will, however, make the world just a little safer.  That's what Sgt. Chapin would have wanted.  He was a protector and sacrificed his life so the rest of ... (click for more)

Ford's Game-Winner Leads Irish Past Chargers

Notre Dame is moving on.   The Irish advanced Monday night when steady Steadmon Ford drove a stake in the Chargers’ heart, draining a game-winning 3-pointer with 1.8 seconds left as No. 4 seed Notre Dame defeated fifth-seed Chattanooga Christian, 41-38, in District 7-AA tournament action in Phifer Gymnasium.   It was a thriller.   Notre Dame (10-14) ... (click for more)

Guerry, Cash, Johnson Net Wins

SAN DIEGO, Calif. -- Led by Zan Guerry's straight set win on Sunday, Chattanooga has been well represented among the winners the first two days of the International Tennis Federation Seniors World Championships here. Playing in the Men's 55s, Guerry celebrated his 63rd birthday Sunday with a 6-0, 6-1 triumph against No. 32 seed Carlos Eduardo Freitas Mamede (Brazil). ... (click for more)