Profoundly Deaf Man Facing Murder Charge To Get Evaluation

Monday, June 29, 2009

A man charged with first-degree murder who is profoundly deaf and mentally handicapped will be evaluated to determine his level of comprehension, Criminal Court Judge Rebecca Stern.

A local interpreter testified in court on Monday that he is aware of some state interpreters who do such evaluations. Judge Stern said, "That is what I have been trying to find."

The case of Alex Smith was postponed until next Monday when there will be an update on whether an evaluation can be arranged.

During the hearing, a court reporter sat beside Smith. She typed what was being said in court on a screen. But one of his attorneys, Karla Gothard, said he could not make out what was on the screen. She and attorney Mary Ann Green said Smith is becoming "increasingly frustrated."

Smith was heard saying he wanted bond and he wanted to go home.

Judge Stern noted that he was speaking much louder and more animated than he had in previous court appearances.

Prosecutor Boyd Patterson said the case has dragged on through "multiple hearings" without getting to a trial. He earlier said Smith was able to give a statement about the case to a detective, and he urged that the trial go forward.

Judge Stern said Smith might be given bond, but she said there need to be assurances "that he's not out carrying guns and causing problems."

Prosecutor Patterson said the last time he was released he fired a shot at a man who was dropping off his child. He said the child witnessed the incident.

Defense attorneys said the victim in that case, Terrence Ware, has since been charged in a federal drug case.

Judge Stern previously ruled that Smith is legally deaf.

Smith is charged with gunning down Desmond Foster, who investigators say was trying to get out of his car in East Chattanooga when Smith walked up and opened fire.

Foster tried to escape by climbing back through his car, but fell dead to the pavement, police said.


Wintry Mix Expected Monday Night; Some Closings Announced

A wintry mix is expected in the Chattanooga area on Monday night. There is a chance of rain before 1 a.m., then rain and snow are likely, possibly mixed with freezing rain between 1 a.m. and 4 a.m. Rain is likely, possibly mixed with freezing rain, after 4 a.m. It will be cloudy, with a low around 34. The chance of precipitation is 70 percent. Little or no ice ... (click for more)

Jelena Butler To Officially Announce As Assessor Candidate

Jelena Butler will officially announce her intent to run for Hamilton County Assessor of Property at the Greater Chattanooga Democratic Women’s Club meeting on Tuesday. She is currently a director in sales and leasing at Keller Williams Commercial.   Ms. Butler said she is running because, “Sixteen years is a long time to leave a vital function unchallenged. Hamilton ... (click for more)

Thank You, Judge Mattice And Chattanooga

I would like to thank Judge Mattice for handing down a 30.5 year sentence for Kathleen Mathews.  Obviously, no amount of jail time, fines, or lashings can bring back Tim Chapin.   A 30-year sentence will, however, make the world just a little safer.  That's what Sgt. Chapin would have wanted.  He was a protector and sacrificed his life so the rest of ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: What 17 Pills Did To Me

Ah, step into my parlor of first-hand wisdom because, in the School of Hard Knocks, there are priceless lessons that you should know before it becomes your turn to dance. Never in my life have I ever had any back problems but, in early December, I came down with what is called sciatica and I have been a miserable man ever since. There are two big nerves that sprout out of the ... (click for more)

Lady Mocs Host Georgia Southern Monday On Autograph Night

The Lady Mocs will be gunning for their 13th SoCon victory Monday night when they host Georgia Southern at McKenzie Arena at 7 p. m. Following the game, the Lady Mocs players and coaches will be courtside for an autograph session. The Lady Mocs and the Eagles have met 48 times with UTC holding a 30-18 advantage. At home, Chattanooga is 18-4 against Georgia Southern but struggle ... (click for more)

Jay Fowler, Chris Walker To Speak at Quarterback Club

Jay Fowler and Chris Walker of Fellowship of Christian Athletes are the guest speakers for Monday's Chttanooga Quarterback Club at Finley Stadium at noon. Fowler, a Tyner and West Point graduate,  is the director of The Greater Chattanooga FCA, while Walker, a former University of Tennessee football player, is the FCA campus director for the Chattanooga ... (click for more)