House Passes Legislation For Good Faith Exception In Criminal Law

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

HB 401, “The Exclusionary Rule Reform Act,” passed the full House on Wednesday. The final vote was 89-9.

Rep. Eric Watson (R—Cleveland), the chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, had been the chief sponsor of the bill.

His office said, "Chairman Watson has been a vigilant leader when it comes to protecting the rights and security of victims. Recent news reports have shown an alarming trend with violent criminals taking advantage of a loophole in Tennessee’s legal code."

HB 401 creates a “good faith exception” to the Exclusionary Rule "so courts will have an legitimate alternative to allow evidence to be heard in a case and sets out a clear definition so there will be clarity on the issue."

Chairman Watson said, “Criminals and defense attorneys have taken advantage of this loophole for years causing violent offenders, including murderers, to be released from jail because of small clerical errors. In an effort to protect society and honor victims, I am proud to say we have closed this loophole.”

He said one news report revealed a convicted drug dealer serving 29 years for drug dealing and weapons charges will be set free because of a minor clerical error on a search warrant. When the typographical error was discovered, the Criminal Court of Appeals ruled it constituted a “fatal flaw” and all the evidence gathered in the execution of the investigation must be discarded. The flaw was a time signature that read 10:35 p.m. when the warrant was actually written at 10:35 a.m. He said, "HB 401 will close these types of loopholes for criminals."


Chattanooga Drug Dealer Gets 80-Month Federal Sentence

A Chattanooga man with prior convictions for selling drugs was sentenced to serve 80 months for being a felon in possession of a weapon. Kevyn Nash appeared before Judge Travis McDonough. On Feb., 28, 2016, while on patrol in the 3700 block of Dodds Avenue, a city police officer observed a white Chrysler Concord traveling north on Dodds Avenue. Upon catching up to the vehicle ... (click for more)

Cleveland Man Who Passed Out At Sonic With Gun Near Him Gets 42-Month Federal Sentence

A Cleveland man who passed out at a drive-in restaurant with a gun in the seat near him was sentenced to serve 42 months in Federal Court. Samuel Hill appeared before Judge Travis McDonough. Last April 3, Cleveland Police responded to a report of a white male passed out in a car at the Sonic on Waterlevel Highway. An officer tried to nudge and then shake the man, but he ... (click for more)

Tennessee Business Expansions On Rise Across State

In 2016, Tennessee was named State of the Year for Economic Development by Southern Business & Development Magazine based on project totals and the variety of industries that invested in the state and created jobs. To a great extent, Bradley and Polk Counties have benefited from that investment.   From February 2015 to February 2016, Cleveland/Bradley County led the ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: DeVos Changes Everything

I believe that from every point on my moral compass the state’s hijacking of five public schools in Hamilton County is wrong. I also believe I can argue with success from any direction on my compass against any of the proposals or terms that Commissioner Candice McQueen just threatened to impose on the county’s Department of Education. But today let’s go to ‘True North’ on my compass ... (click for more)

State Softball, Baseball Matchups Set

The opening 2017 state tournament baseball and softball matchups involving local high school teams have been finalized. The next-to-last pairing came Sunday morning when Ooltewah (32-8) drew Dyer County (19-15) for a Tuesday game with a 4 p.m. (CT) start on Field 1 at the Starplex softball complex in Murfreesboro. Ooltewah, which lost to Soddy-Daisy in the District 5-3A ... (click for more)

Boyd-Buchanan Reaches Class A/AA State Soccer Tournament

The setting was nothing new for the seven seniors on the Boyd-Buchanan boys’ soccer team, but this time the Bucs got to celebrate a different outcome.   Playing in their fourth consecutive Class A/AA state sectional, the Bucs put three years of heartbreak behind them by earning a 1-0 victory over Merrol Hyde and a trip to this week’s state tournament in Murfreesboro. ... (click for more)