Mae Beavers Knows What She's Talking About

Sunday, January 22, 2012

Re: Lee Davis: Tennessee Legislature To Claim It Is The Supreme Court?

Mr. Davis,
In response to your editorial dated Jan. 21, 2011, I would submit that Senator Mae Beavers has two advantages over lawyers such as yourself: 1) She is a non-lawyer and not encumbered with judicial misinformation and 2) She can read.

The Tennessee Constitution Art VI, Sec 2 (like Art III, Sec 2 of the U.S. Constitution) provides that the “jurisdiction of this Court shall be appellate only, under such restrictions and regulations as may from time to time be prescribed by law” (U.

S. Constitution: “the Supreme Court shall have appellate jurisdiction, both as to law and fact, with such exceptions, and under such regulations as the Congress shall make”).

The decision in Marbury v. Madison did not address that constitutional provision. While the Supreme Court does have the right to decide constitutional issues under the authority of that case and its progeny, it can do so until the Congress or the legislature deprives them of that responsibility. I respectfully suggest that if you read the Constitution which contains the foresaid provisions, then you will see that Senator Beavers knows what she is talking about and apparently you do not and unfortunately most lawyers do not.

The people of Tennessee are blessed to have Mae Beavers as the Chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee because she reads the Constitution and feels the responsibility to do what it says, including helping fulfill the legislature’s constitutionally-mandated role of judicial review. In addition, I applaud her for filing a bill with the goal of seeking to start a statewide conversation regarding the proper roles and power of the various branches of government.

Respectfully submitted,

John Jay Hooker
Friend of the Constitution
Nashville


Words

Words are important. Words give a people, nation, society, or profession a means of communicating ideas and information amongst themselves. Here in these United States of America, the greatest nation to ever grace the face of Planet Terra, we speak English. But it's American English, American, an extension of British, or the Queen's, English, and much broader in scope. It's an amalgamation ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Mr. Murray’s Great Note

In the last several days I have received hundreds of emails after I took a stand for General Nathan Beford Forrest, the South’s rich history, and the indelible fact the War Between The States is still a big part of who were are and what we have become. For the record, as of late yesterday afternoon, I have not heard from one dissenter, although I know there are some who I believe ... (click for more)

President Of Realtor Association And Family Were Starting On Vacation When They Were Caught In Deadly Wreck

The president of the Greater Chattanooga Association of Realtors was starting out on vacation with his wife, Tina, and their two children when they got caught up in last Thursday’s deadly crash along I-75.   Six people were killed and six others injured.   The Close family, including children ages six and 12, was able to escape injury.   They ... (click for more)

Athens, Tn., Doctor, Wife, Daughter Die In Crash Of Small Plane That Hit House Near Boston

An Athens,Tn., physician, his wife and college-age daughter died Sunday evening in the crash of a small plane that struck a house 30 miles southwest of Boston on Sunday evening. The victims were Dr. Joseph Rick Kalister, the emergency room director at Starr Regional Medical Center's Athens campus, wife, Betty, and their daughter. The doctor and his wife were en route for a ... (click for more)

Fort Oglethorpe Swimmers Get First Win Of Season

There are a lot of positive and upbeat coaches in the Chattanooga Area Swim League, but perhaps none any more than Fort Oglethorpe veteran Tony Womac. This guy is always happy, always smiling and always offering something positive to those around him. He may have been just a bit more of all the above on Monday night after his Marlins defeated the Cumberland Currents in a home ... (click for more)

John Shearer: A Look At The Origin Of The Lady Vols’ Name

On Wednesday, the University of Tennessee is scheduled to drop the Lady Vols nickname from all women’s sports teams except the basketball squad.   The change has been a source of much debate, particularly in Knoxville. As evidence, several people wanting to keep the Lady Vols name protested last Thursday along Joe Johnson Drive, near where the UT board of trustees was meeting ... (click for more)