If Emissions Testing Really Helps Pollution, Where Is The Proof? - And Response

Thursday, February 09, 2012

After starting a petition to stop vehicle emissions testing, I received several comments about my petition being wrong. I have taken it upon myself to do research about these comments and this is what I found.

First, I want to make it clear that I am in total support of the EPA, TDEC, and APCB in saving our environment. I am not against research and testing of any kind, if it helps and does not hurt people in the process. I do believe there should be proof that their testing is effective. After exploring the internet and speaking with 12 different people through email and phone calls from EPA, TDEC, and APCB, I finally got some answers to comments people are making.
Several people commented that emissions testing should not be stopped because it has helped our environment. My question is, where is the proof? After speaking with those 12 individuals, I was finally told that there is no written proof. This testing alone can not be measured. Emission testing is just one part of many programs set up to reduce pollution. EPA has guidelines that Tennessee must meet to be considered “attainable”. Because of several different programs used to meet those standards, Tennessee has reached the attainable standard. There is no proof emissions testing has been effective in this attainability program. 

Asthma: According to http://www.aafa.org, no one really knows the causes of asthma. There are more than 20 different things that can trigger an Asthma attack. Is emissions testing crucial in reducing these triggers? No, the testing is one of many programs used to help in pollution and there is no proof it has helped at all.

The Money: This is where your $10 is going. $.25 goes to Hamilton County Clerk for extra costs associated with registration, $1.80 to TDEC for overseeing and auditing the contractor, and $7.95 to Envirotest (State contractor in Nashville / Corporate Headquarters in CT) to cover operating expenses, salaries, debt retirement on approximately $6 million local building costs, and profit. In 2010,  272,411 vehicles were tested. That means in 2010 Hamilton County received $68,102.75, TDEC received $490,339.80, and Envirotest received $2,165,667.45 according to the figures they gave me.

There were a few statements during this research, I found to be very interesting yet hurtful. I was told emissions testing will end when we get all the old polluting cars off the road. This statement is proof that this testing is and will continue to hurt people. If you can’t afford to buy a newer vehicle, you will have to continue to sink money in your older vehicle to get it up to their standards. I was also told I should be taking this up with the manufacturer who established the standards for the testing and not the testing itself, but the testing is the reason people are having to spend money for unnecessary repairs. I say get rid of the required testing, and we have no more unnecessary repairs and no one telling us we can’t drive a vehicle we paid thousands for.

A little common sense will tell you if we are the only county in this area with this testing and people from all over Tennessee, Georgia and Alabama, (who do not have this testing) drive through here daily and we sell our cars to them to drive through here daily, there is no way this testing has or will ever help our environment.

Could emissions testing be stopped? Yes. Will stopping emissions testing hurt our environment? No. It is just one little part of several programs used to make Hamilton County an attainable area and there is absolutely no written proof or way to measure results of it to show that it has helped in any way. There are however hundreds of stories showing that emissions testing has hurt people and will continue doing so if it is not stopped. Please sign my petition!
http://www.thepetitionsite.com/1/stop-emission-testing-in-tn/ Thank you,

Eva Milligan

* * *

The original reason we started having testing was so we would not lose funds due to clean air restrictions. We were going to lose money, so the solution, sack the citizens.  If we pay then it doesn't matter if the air is clean or not. It is more "new age" environmental religion thrust on us all.

This is the same city that has been recognized nationally for cleaning up our town, and running off all the industry. I remember the smog that made it impossible to see across town coming through the ridge cut, now we have a clean city and they still carp about it as though we were still the "Dynamo of Dixie". 

The only solution is to re-route I-24 and I-75 around the city and not right through the middle of it. It is a joke to think making us pay will help when thousands of trucks and passenger vehicles come through every hour.

Keith Roberts 



Great Work, City Auditor

As a voter, I was skeptical about having an independent city auditor’s office. This office was created by referendum of the voters. The public wanted third party oversight of city government, for good cause.  I will be the first to admit I was wrong.  A primary problem was the auditor being hired and fired by the mayor’s office, who could also set the auditors operating ... (click for more)

Commissioner Mackey Asks All to Support Football Mocs

The moment that many of us have been waiting for six months is upon us---it is football time in Tennessee.  If you live within the greater Chattanooga area I am asking you to join me in looking upon the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga as being our hometown football team.  And it is an exciting team that we can be proud of.    The Chattanooga Mocs will ... (click for more)

Plan Revived For 5-Story Boutique Hotel Next To The Walnut Street Bridge

Plans have been revived for a five-story boutique hotel next to the Walnut Street Bridge. Vision Hospitality Group said the yet-to-be named hotel will provide 90 rooms featuring high-end amenities and exemplary service in the city's art district. Plans for a similar hotel were announced in 2012, but the proposal was later withdrawn. The hotel is slated for 102 Walnut ... (click for more)

Grand Jury Says County Needs To Start "Immediately" On Funding A New County Jail

Members of the Hamilton County Grand Jury said in a final report that the county needs to start "immediately" on funding a replacement for the Hamilton County Jail. The report, read by Foreman Robert Smith, says, "The Jail is near and/or over capacity and understaffed!  Hard-working corrections officers are in constant danger.  Being responsible for 80-100 inmates per ... (click for more)

Big John Henderson Will Be Vols "Legend" At Sunday Opener

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. – From 1999-2001, John Henderson cast a long shadow on the defensive line for Tennessee. Sunday, the man and the shadow return to Neyland Stadium for the first time since his final run through the “T”. Henderson will be honored before the Tennessee-Utah State game as the Legend of the Game, celebrating a decorated career at UT that saw the Nashville native pick ... (click for more)

Santiago No-Hits Smokies

Starting pitcher Andres Santiago no-hit the Tennessee Smokies (32-34) to lead the Chattanooga Lookouts  (32-32)  to a 1-0 win and propel them into sole possession of first place for the first time this season.  The no-hitter was the Lookouts’ first since June 1, 1996 when Travis Buckley threw one against the Huntsville Stars. Santiago was lights out since the ... (click for more)