Criminal Defense Attorneys Seek To Find Solution To Logjam Between Judge Steelman, Public Defender Garth

Monday, August 27, 2012

Leaders of the local chapter of the Tennessee Criminal Defense Attorneys Association are offering to find a "compromise" to break the logjam that is causing public defender cases to back up in the courtroom of Criminal Court Judge Barry Steelman.

Public Defender Ardena Garth has sought to have Judge Steelman recuse himself from 150 cases of indigent defendants, saying he has been "venomous" toward her office and is biased against her and her staff.

At the start of a hearing on the motions on Monday afternoon, attorneys Hank Hill and Rich Heinsman asked for a couple of days "to see if some common ground can be found."

Attorney Hill said, "If there is any middle ground, we'd like to find it."

He said the attorneys plan "to make a proposal to the court as a compromise and a solution to all of this. That's our hope."

Attorney Hill said a motion to intervene could be filed Tuesday and the attorneys be ready by Wednesday. Judge Steelman reset the motions for Friday.

He said, "I don't know what is contemplated by this," but he said he was not opposed to the delay.

Ms. Garth also asked that the defense attorneys have time to intervene.

One woman who is indigent told the court she wanted to resolve her case, saying it had been worked out that she had a bed waiting at a rehab place. However, Judge Steelman said he could not act on her case while the motion to recuse is still active. He said the public defender's office was free to try to work out the case with another judge.

 

 


Apison To Get New Fire Hall, Community Room, Voting Spot

The Apison community will be getting a new fire hall to replace a metal building at the old Apison Elementary School site. The County Commission is expected to approve a resolution next Wednesday to accept the low bid of J&J Contractors for $2,833,700. It is the Tri-Community Volunteer Fire Department's Fire Hall #3. There were five bidders. The cost will be covered ... (click for more)

Private Lease On Cleveland's Waterville Golf Course Goes Into Default

A plan for the city of Cleveland to lease out the Waterville golf course has not worked out as the  lease is in default and the city is now owed $20,000, Cleveland City Council members were told Tuesday.   The council voted to officially terminate the contract with the current management company. This will allow the city to reimburse current members who have ... (click for more)

County Officials Need To Provide A Decent Animal Shelter

Once upon a time, a group of citizens concerned about the decaying building housing the Humane Educational Society on Highland Park raised their voices in an outcry about the deplorable state of the HES facility and the over-population of unwanted and unspayed/unneutered cats and dogs in Hamilton County.   What happened then was that the City Council stepped ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Is It Ever Worth It?

There is a better-than-average chance General John Kelly could soon be named as the new Commandant of the United States Marine Corps. He’s one of four men who have been mentioned in prudent fashion to follow General Joseph Dunford (remember that name for a few minutes) as head of the Corps. General Dunford, who held the job less than a year, has just been chosen by President Obama ... (click for more)

Tull Named SoCon Athlete Of The Year

University of Tennessee at Chattanooga defensive end Davis Tull has been named the 2015 Southern Conference Male Athlete of the Year, the league announced today (May 26). Tull will be honored as part of the league’s annual Honors Dinner on Wednesday night in Hilton Head Island, S.C.   Tull becomes the first Moc to win the Male Athlete of the Year Award. As a senior, he ... (click for more)

Soccer Abounds For Chattanooga FC

The Chattanooga FC soccer team continues it's busy schedule this week with games on Wednesday and Friday in two separate national tournaments.    Chattanooga hosts the Atlanta Silverbacks on Wednesday in the third round of the US Open Cup. The Silverbacks are a professional team that plays in the NASL.   The Silverbacks ended Chattanooga's run in the last year's ... (click for more)