Mayor Littlefield Set To Testify In United Pet Supply Lawsuit Case

Sunday, January 27, 2013

Mayor Ron Littlefield is listed among the witnesses in a trial set to start in Federal Court on Feb. 11 in which the parent company of The Pet Shop is suing the city and the McKamey Animal Center for $10 million.

Also set to testify are some of the mayor's top staff members, including Dan Johnson, Marie Chinery and Richard Beeland. City Councilman Jack Benson is also on the city's witness list.

The 29-page complaint by United Pet Care says McKamey illegally took the permit for its store at Hamilton Place Mall and also illegally confiscated most of the animals at the store. It says McKamey was acting with ulterior motives when it took 82 animals and the company business records in a raid June 15, 2010. The permit was eventually returned to the store along with most of the animals.

City Judge Sherry Paty stepped down from the case, saying Mayor Littlefield had improperly interfered. An outside judge later dismissed the case, citing "double jeopardy."

City Judges Paty and Russell Bean say relations with Mayor Littlefield deteriorated after that flap.

The suit says McKamey "prosecuted the charges against the Pet Shop with an ulterior motive and for an improper purpose: to damage and destroy Plaintiff's lawful business, based on an ideological and political antipathy to pet stores, and to unlawfully extract the payment of money and surrender of property from the Pet Shop."

It says defendants "conducted an unreasonable search and seizure of the
Pet Shop in violation of the Fourth Amendment" and says the City Code as written and as applied to the Pet Shop "conflicts with, infringes on, and disregards rights specifically granted by state law, and the accompanying regulatory scheme, governing the licensing of commercial pet dealers in the state of Tennessee."

The suit says the defendants "unlawfully deprived the Pet Shop of its basic right to procedural due process in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution and the Tennessee Constitution. The Pet Shop was damaged as a result of defendants' actions."

It says a hearing should have been conducted prior to the raid.

The suit says a German Shepherd taken by McKamey was not returned despite a request by The Pet Shop veterinarian and it died.

It says in early October, 2010, the Pet Shop retrieved the remainder of its animals from McKamey, "which were no longer puppies. They could not be sold, were underweight, and in various states of poor health, having been retained at defendant McKamey's facility for nearly four months. After subsequent veterinary treatment and care by the Pet Shop's veterinarian, the Pet Shop adopted out its dogs without charge."

The suit says the raid was carried out early in the morning prior to the time The Pet Shop cleaned its facility for the day.

The suit was filed by Chattanooga attorneys Andrew Pippenger and Benjamin Reese.

Defendants also include McKamey Director Karen Walsh and employees Marvin Nicholson and Paula Hurn.

The suit asks $5 million compensatory damages and $5 million punitive damages.

Judge Curtis Collier is to preside over the trial.

 

 


Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report - And Mug Shots

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: ANDERSON, MICHAEL LEBRONE     2512 TUNNEL BLVD CHATTANOOGA, 37406     65     Chattanooga          AGGRAVATED BURGLARY (OCCUPIED HABITATION)     ROBBERY (ATTEMPT)     BURGLARY     BURGLARY ... (click for more)

Man Arrested After Attacking Woman Who Gave Him A Ride

A Chattanooga man was arrested after police said he hitchhiked a ride with a woman then started attacking her. According to police, the woman was leaving a party in East Chattanooga on Aug. 1, when Shungthun Martez "Smurf" Fugh, 29, asked her for a ride. The woman told police they were near an alley on East 18th Street when the man started going through her belongings inside ... (click for more)

Black Creek TIF Decision-Who Guards The Hen House?

Citizens of Chattanooga were invited to give public comment before their own Industrial Development Board Aug. 15. They arrived to find foxes guarding their hen house.  Many thought the meeting was their opportunity to seek redress in the ill-conceived Black Creek Tax Increment Financing plan. However, they learned it was a sham orchestrated by both the past and present ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Coaches Vs. ‘Top 25’ Foes

The long-accepted measuring stick for a college football coach has been his win-loss record, with an after-glance at his win-loss record within his conference. But in Wednesday’s editions of the Wall Street Journal, writer David Everson, with the help of Stats LLC, used a much-tougher litmus test when he revealed the records of 65 major-college coaches against opponents that were ... (click for more)

McCallie's JaVaughn Craig Still Improving At Quarterback

(This is the 14th in a series of preseason stories on new high school football coaches, or veteran coaches at a different school, and top players in the Chattanooga area) JaVaughn Craig was the starting quarterback for McCallie all season a year ago, but it wasn’t originally planned like that. Craig was a wide receiver when he resumed his football career ... (click for more)

Hixson Beats Silverdale For Second Volleyball Win

There's something about that second set that gives the Hixson Lady Wildcats trouble. Hixson lost the second set in Monday's volleyball opener against Sale Creek.  They did the same thing against the Silverdale Seahawks on Tuesday, but just like Monday's match, the Lady Wildcats came out on top, 3-1. Hixson won the first set with ease, 25-11.  Silverdale evened the  ... (click for more)