An Irresponsible Hixson Development - And Response (2)

Thursday, January 3, 2013

The way city officials are evaluating and supporting Scenic City Land Company’s proposed Boy Scout Road development in Hixson is very troubling.  In spite of the proposal’s numerous inconsistencies, flaws, and use of soon-to-be outdated water retention methods, it seems as if the request for re-zoning and development will be allowed.  

Duane Horton of SCLC has been introducing and reintroducing changes to his plan for months.  It isn’t apparent that anyone (including Mr. Horton) is exactly sure what is being proposed at this time.  At every city and community meeting I have been to, there are additions and changes to SCLC’s proposal.  I’m not sure if this is due to lack of preparation or an attempt to bait-and-switch.  Regardless, SCLC appears unprepared, unprofessional, and haphazardly dealing with a permitting process that is in place to protect people and environment. 

Equally as troubling is that our elected officials would vote on an application they had not read. On (Dec. 10, 2012) the Chattanooga-Hamilton County Regional Planning Commission approved the SCLC rezoning applications that they received minutes prior to voting.  Indeed, the plan SCLC presented had elements in it that had not been seen by the public or the Planning Commission. At a recent community meeting moderated by Councilwoman Pam Ladd, (Dec. 17,  2012) it was revealed that neither SCLC or the RPA had considered TWRA’s State Wildlife Action Plan which lists a significant portion of the proposed development as high priority forest block. 

Mr. Horton has repeatedly boasted that this development will contain surface water runoff controls to maintain 1 inch of rainwater on site for 72 hours and that this will "exceed any project that he knows of".  What he isn’t boasting about is that these controls will not meet the impending federal runoff reduction requirement to retain 1 inch rainfall on site indefinitely – nor will do his controls meet the RPA’s recommendation of holding 1.6 inches of water for 72 hours. 

Regardless, any statement about the effectiveness of SCLC’s runoff controls is premature given that neither a hydrology or soils study, nor a grading plan have been done on the site (despite the RPA's recommendation). The extent of runoff during construction and operational phases of this proposed development cannot be accurately predicted without such studies.  

Mr. Horton and his cohorts continually refer to this as a responsible development.  The responsible thing to do would be to improve and use the more than 600,000 square feet of unused developments in Hixon.  Indeed, a responsible company would help keep our scenic city’s land from such development. 

Sean Richards

* * * 

It is truly sad that developers are not interested in using derelict properties in various areas of Chattanooga. I guess they just aren't attracted to ready failed locations that may not be up to code, aren't worth renovating, might contain asbestos or chemicals that involve expensive removal, aren't the "right" size property, don't have access to enough utility and sewer, 
poor access, not enough parking, local restrictions, etc.? 

I've seen these evil stepchild properties. It's like trying to adopt out a mangy three legged dog that is blind in one eye and has an ear missing. Junior questions, "Daddy, what is wrong with our doggy?"

I'm dreaming that a consortium of investors and owners will come along someday and perform some basic cleanup and prep to give the derelict areas a fighting chance. Perhaps the group might include volunteers that are ready to add their elbow grease to the effort to rid our city of these eyesores. Any takers?

Ted Ladd

* * *

Regarding the comments by Sean Richards, I do know of a scenario where a developer was stopped. It was in South Pittsburg, the plan was to build a hazardous waste incinerator, and Nickajack Port Authority had the up or down vote to decide the fate of the project.  

Granted, on the  day of the vote, there was a large crowd on hand at the meeting place. Streets on two sides of the building were standing room only, the meeting space was shoulder to shoulder, and the yard out front was the same. I feel certain that every person living in that town today was there or knows several people who were. My guess is there were around 2,000 people standing at attention as the vote was counted.  

The count was against and the two reps of the developer left with two Tennessee Highway Patrolmen escorting them from the scene. Though I did not feel bad for her at the time, I do recall the young lady of that pair trembling as they left. 

That is one of the more pronounced versions of democracy at  work I have seen. It is what needs to happen in a community when opposition to a proposed project is near unanimous  and the outcome is pretty much assured to be a done deal by the elected body. 

If local governance was truly participatory, we would have city council meetings at Finley Stadium, not the smallish meeting room it is in near to City Hall. If the folks of Hixson are really serious about this, the subject will be  plain as Christmas coming for all in Chattanooga. 

Knowledge and power will go well past the rain shadow around that hilltop soon to be removed. 

Prentice Hicks
Lookout Valley




Is Poverty Inherited?

Is poverty inherited was meant and is meant as query to all of us.  The school system is a mess. Yes, a mess. Teachers in most of the schools in both the inner city and the fringes deal with behavior problems of some magnitude. The obvious solutionm rid the troublesome student and all will be well. That argument accomplishes little. Lil Joey in the back of the classroom ... (click for more)

Another Teacher Leaves Classroom Chaos

We should thank Ms. Cheryl Roddy for sharing the reason for her resignation as a substitute teacher with Roy Exum. He includes her letter in his recent article entitled "Why Our Schools Stink." All should read it, because it summarizes what has happened in many failing schools. It is little wonder that young adults flout the law when they reach the age of 20 and 30. By then, they ... (click for more)

Lawsuit Says Girl Received Severe Traumatic Brain Injury In Woodmore Bus Wreck

A new lawsuit in the tragic Woodmore Elementary School bus wreck said one girl on the bus suffered a severe traumatic brain injury. Attorneys Joseph Fried and Michael Goldberg of Fried Rogers Goldberg LLC filed a lawsuit in Hamilton County Circuit Court on behalf of the minor daughter of Shanquatta Byrd. The bus driver, Johnthony Walker, was transporting 37 students from ... (click for more)

Officer Who Was Shot Returned Fire; Is Recovering Well; Shooter Still On Loose

Chattanooga Police Chief Fred Fletcher said Monday morning that the officer who was shot three times on Thursday is recovering well.   Chief Fletcher said the officer was wearing a bullet-proof vest and one bullet hit the vest, which protected him during the shooting.  The officer was able to return fire, although Chief Fletcher would not comment on how many bullets ... (click for more)

Mississippi State Quarterback Nick Tiano To Play At UTC

Former Baylor School quarterback Nick Tiano announced Monday that he is transferring from Mississippi State to UTC. He tweeted, "I'm very excited to announce that I am going back home to play for The University of Tennessee at Chattanooga! # GoMoc" Tiano had announced five days ago that he was leaving the Bulldogs after his freshman year. Tiano appeared in four ... (click for more)

Jones Will "Thoroughly Examine Everything In UT Program"

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. – Tennessee football coach  and seniors Joshua Dobbs and LaTroy Lewis met with reporters on Monday in their first press conference for the Music City Bowl in Nashville. Unranked Tennessee (8-4) will play Nebraska (9-3) in the Dec. 30 at Nissan Stadium. The game will feature a 3:30 p.m. ET kickoff on ESPN. The Cornhuskers are No. 21 in the ... (click for more)