Alexander, Issa Investigating Extent Of Obamacare Launch Problems

Thursday, October 10, 2013

The senior Republican on the Senate health committee and the chairman of the House Oversight Committee on Thursday called on the Obama administration to provide details on the technical problems that have prevented many Americans from enrolling in the federal government’s health insurance exchange, and to explain whether individuals will still suffer tax penalties for not purchasing insurance.

Senator Lamar Alexander (R-Tn.), the ranking member of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, and Rep. Darrell Issa (R-Ca.), the chairman of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, sent a letter to Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius requesting information “to help us evaluate the extent of the problems with ObamaCare’s rollout and for us to better determine whether any corrective legislative actions are necessary.”

Senator Alexander and Rep. Issa wrote: “HHS launched healthcare.gov on Oct. 1, as required by law.  From day one, however, healthcare.gov has been plagued by what Administration officials initially referred to as technical glitches.  After six days the Administration finally admitted the glitches were ‘design and software problems that have kept customers from applying online for coverage.’  News reports detailed stories of people waiting as long as 36 hours to enroll for insurance, many waiting for hours only to give up. As many as 99 of every 100 applications are not able to be processed, and experts are concerned that ‘federal officials could face a situation in January in which relatively large numbers of people believe they have coverage starting that month, but whose enrollment applications have not been processed.

“Among the many problems that have been identified in the media: many tens of thousands of people have started the application process but been unable to create accounts;  the system that determines whether people are eligible for federal subsidies or Medicaid has made inaccurate determinations; the exchange will not be able to communicate with state Medicaid agencies until November; drop down tools and identity checking systems have not properly functioned; the website bottlenecks at the account creation stage; insurers are receiving incomplete or corrupted applications; and insufficient capacity has been allocated for the website. The website was shut down for periods on October 5th, October 6th, and on October 8th in order for HHS to attempt to make changes.

Senator Alexander and Rep. Issa asked for information including how many people have successfully enrolled in the exchange; details on all technical problems preventing enrollment and the anticipated cost of fixing those problems;  whether HHS decided to go live with healthcare.gov knowing there were problems with transmitting data to insurers; and whether individuals who attempted to enroll in insurance through the federal exchange but who were ultimately unsuccessful due to the system’s failures still face a tax penalty if they do not enroll for 2014.

“According to some reports,” they wrote, “the administration was repeatedly warned that the federal exchange had significant problems.  Insurers complained that during tests of the exchange there were difficulties with transmissions to insurers, with insurers not receiving all necessary data about individuals enrolling in plans during tests.  Did HHS go live with healthcare.gov knowing there were problems with transmitting data to insurers? If those problems were resolved during testing, how were they resolved?”

The text of the letter is below:

October 10, 2013

The Honorable Kathleen Sebelius

Secretary

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

330 Independence Avenue, SW

Washington, DC 20201

Dear Secretary Sebelius:

We are writing to seek information about the federal health insurance exchanges established by the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).  We are concerned by recent comments to the media that the system suffers from architectural problems that need design changes.  We seek information about these problems as well as whether you still expect individuals to suffer a tax penalty if they do not purchase government-approved health insurance.

ObamaCare requires millions of individuals to enroll in government-mandated insurance or else face a tax penalty.  The law required an online exchange be available by October 1, 2013, for individuals to compare plans and rates.  For the 36 states that are not operating their own exchange websites, HHS established healthcare.gov for individuals to shop for insurance that would meet the law’s mandated insurance coverage requirements.  A Government Accountability Office report from June detailed that HHS spent almost $394 million over three years in contracts to establish the exchange and its related functions.[1]

Two top HHS officials, Marilyn Tavenner, the Administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), and Gary Cohen, the Director for the Center for Consumer Information and Insurance Oversight, provided testimony to the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform within the past few months suggesting that HHS would be ready for implementation on October 1, 2013.  On July 17, 2013, Ms. Tavenner testified that she was “feeling pretty comfortable about the ability [of CMS] to be ready on October 1st.”[2]  She further stated that “I want to assure you that [on] October 1, 2013, the health insurance marketplace will be open for business.  Consumers will be able to log onto healthcare.gov, fill out an application and find out what coverage and benefits they qualify for.”[3]  At a hearing on May 21, 2013, Mr. Cohen testified “I think we are very much on schedule; we are moving forward.  We are going to be ready October 1st for open enrollment to begin.”[4]  Mr. Cohen also testified that there would not be “any problems with [the] massive amount of data sharing.”[5]

HHS launched healthcare.gov on October 1, 2013, as required by law.  From day one, however, healthcare.gov has been plagued by what Administration officials initially referred to as technical glitches.  After six days the Administration finally admitted the glitches were “design and software problems that have kept customers from applying online for coverage.”[6]  News reports detailed stories of people waiting as long as 36 hours to enroll for insurance, many waiting for hours only to give up.[7]  As many as 99 of every 100 applications are not able to be processed, and experts are concerned that “federal officials could face a situation in January in which relatively large numbers of people believe they have coverage starting that month, but whose enrollment applications have not been processed.” [8] 

Among the many problems that have been identified in the media: many tens of thousands of people have started the application process but been unable to create accounts;[9] the system that determines whether people are eligible for federal subsidies or Medicaid has made inaccurate determinations;[10] the exchange will not be able to communicate with state Medicaid agencies until November;[11] drop down tools and identity checking systems have not properly functioned;[12] the website bottlenecks at the account creation stage;[13] insurers are receiving incomplete or corrupted applications;[14] and insufficient capacity has been allocated for the website.[15]  The website was shut down for periods on October 5th, October 6th, and on October 8th in order for HHS to attempt to make changes.

To help us evaluate the extent of the problems with ObamaCare’s rollout and for us to better determine whether any corrective legislative actions are necessary, please provide the Committees with the following information by October 24, 2013:

1.      As of October 9, 2013, at midnight, how many people had successfully enrolled for insurance through the federal exchange?  How many people attempted to submit applications?  

2.      Please describe, in detail, all technical problems (including software and design defects) that are preventing people from successfully creating accounts, applying for insurance, and enrolling in plans.  Please describe in detail the administration’s plans to address those problems and what has already been done to fix them.  Please include which contractors were involved in the design and operation of those aspects of the exchange and which contractors are involved in correcting the problems.

3.      How much has it already cost and will it cost to address the technical problems with the exchange?  Does HHS need additional appropriations to solve the technical problems and if not, how will HHS pay for the changes?  Please list specific appropriations accounts used. 

4.      According to several news reports,[16] the system that determines when people are eligible for subsidies to buy insurance or Medicaid appears to be malfunctioning, and thus many people may not be eligible for plans in which they are enrolled.  What is your timeline for determining when people may have received inaccurate information about eligibility and for notifying affected individuals?  How will individuals be notified?

5.      According to a USA Today interview with HHS’s Chief Technology Officer Todd Park, the Administration has said it hopes as many as 7 million people will eventually sign up for health insurance through the federal exchange.  Yet, the administration only designed healthcare.gov to handle 50,000 to 60,000 simultaneous users. 

a.       Why did the Administration build the site to accommodate so few people at a time when it expected many more to apply for insurance? 

b.      How much load testing of the exchange was done?  What is the maximum number of simultaneous users the exchange was tested to accommodate?

6.      According to some reports,[17] the Administration was repeatedly warned that the federal exchange had significant problems.  Insurers complained that during tests of the exchange there were difficulties with transmissions to insurers, with insurers not receiving all necessary data about individuals enrolling in plans during tests. 

a.       Did HHS go live with healthcare.gov knowing there were problems with transmitting data to insurers?

b.      If those problems were resolved during testing, how were they resolved?

7.      For the first five days of open enrollment, the administration insisted enrollment problems were a matter of unexpected volume.  In an on the record interview with USA Today published October 6, Todd Park said “These bugs were functions of volume[.]  Take away the volume and it works.”  On the same day, the Administration admitted to The Wall Street Journal that capacity was not the only problem, but the exchange suffered from design problems as well.

a.       When did HHS first learn of the design and software problems with the exchange?

b.      Please provide all documents, including emails, referring or relating to the design, software, and capacity problems with the exchange.

8.      Will individuals who attempted to enroll in insurance through the federal exchange but who ultimately were unsuccessful due to the system’s failures still face a tax penalty if they do not enroll for 2014?  What about individuals who believe they successfully enrolled but later find out they were ineligible?

9.      Please provide all documents referring or relating to the testing of the exchange and the federal data hub, including but not limited to contractual terms, reports or other data that were submitted by contractors, internal testing, internal emails, memos, power point presentations, and any communications from third parties such as insurers or other stakeholders on the performance of the exchange.

The Committee on Oversight and Government Reform is the principal oversight committee of the House of Representatives and may at “any time” investigate “any matter” as set forth in House Rule X.  An attachment to this letter provides additional information about responding to the Committee’s request. 

In preparing your answers to these questions, please answer each question individually and include the text of each question in your response.  When producing documents to the Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, please deliver production sets to the Majority Staff in Room 2157 of the Rayburn House Office Building and the Minority Staff in Room 2471 of the Rayburn House Office Building.  The Committee prefers to receive documents in electronic format.

If you have any questions about this request, please have your staff contact Stacy Cline of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee Staff or Brian Blase of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Staff.  Thank you for your attention to this matter.    

Sincerely,

            Sen. Lamar Alexander                                    Rep. Darrell Issa                                            

            Ranking Member                                            Chairman

            Senate Health, Education, Labor                    House Committee on Oversight

            and Pensions Committee                                and Government Reform


Enclosure

cc:        The Honorable Tom Harkin, Chairman, Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions 

The Honorable Elijah Cummings, Ranking Minority Member, Committee on Oversight and Government Reform

[1] John E. Dicken, Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act: Status of CMS Efforts to Establish Federally Facilitated Health Insurance Exchanges, GAO Report to Congressional Requesters (June 2013).

[2] Evaluating Privacy, Security, and Fraud Concerns with ObamaCare’s Information Sharing Apparatus, Joint Hearing Before the H. Comm. on Oversight and Government Reform, Subcomm. on Energy Policy, Health Care, and Entitlements, and H. Comm. On Homeland Security Sucbomm. on Cybersecurity, Infrastructure Protection, and Security Technologies, 113th Cong. 20-21 (2013) 

[3] Id.

[4] Examining The Concerns About the ObamaCare Outreach Campaign, Hearing Before the H. Comm. on Oversight and Government Reform, Subcomm. on Energy Policy, Health Care, and Entitlements, and Subcomm. on Economic Growth, Job Creation and Regulatory Affairs, 113th Cong. 20-21 (2013) 

[5] Id.

[6] Christopher Weaver, et al., Software, Design Defects Cripple Health-Care Website, Wall St. J. (Oct. 6, 2013).

[7] Sarah Kliff, For Some Shoppers, Buying Obamacare is Turning Into a Marathon, Wash. Post Wonkblog (Oct. 4, 2013).

[8] Dan Mangan, 99% of Obamacare Applications Hit a Wall, CNBC (Oct. 4, 2013).

[9] Supra note 6.

[10] Id.

[11] Phil Galewitz, Federal Insurance Marketplace Can’t Yet ‘Talk’ to State Medicaid Agencies, Wash. Post (Oct. 4, 2013).

[12] Supra note 6.

[13] Michael D. Shear, et al., Health Exchange Delays Tied to Software Crash in Early Rush, N.Y. Times (Oct. 7, 2013).

[14] See, e.g., Drew Armstrong, et al., Insurers Getting Faulty Data from U.S. Health Exchanges, Bloomberg (Oct.8, 2013).

[15] Tim Mullaney, Obama Adviser: Demand Overwhelmed HealthCare.gov, USA Today (Oct. 6, 2013).

[16] Supra notes 6 and 11.

[17]See, e.g., Juliet Eilperin, et al., Many Remain Locked Out of Federal Health-Care Web Site, Wash. Post (Oct. 8, 2013). 


NAACP's Mapp Says IDB Should Not Be "Rubber Stamp"; Questions Deals For Black Creek, VW

Longtime Chattanooga NAACP leader James Mapp said Thursday that industrial development boards "should not be rubber stamps." He questioned deals through the City IDB for the Black Creek group and Volkswagen. Mr. Mapp said, "Throughout our nation's history, the lack of representative government has always been a point of contention for Americans, and a chief cornerstone of ... (click for more)

Man, 34, Dies Shortly After Being Arrested In Crossville

A 34-year-old arrestee died at Crossville on Sunday. Sheriff Butch Burgess said Rustin Grayson was brought to the Cumberland County Justice Center intake for processing after being arrested by the Crossville Police Department. Jail staff advised that when Crossville Police arrived at intake Grayson was unable to get out of the patrol vehicle without assistance. The Crossville ... (click for more)

Curtis Adams: Beck, Mackey Should Be Considered For County Commission Leadership

Just think about this;  a person highly qualified applying for a job.  As he is just about finished filling out his papers for his interview, he sees at the bottom there is a place for him to check Democrat or Republican.  He would think, “if I mark the wrong one I may not get the job.” Being a real leader requires honesty, integrity, and, most importantly, fairness. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Mark’s 50th Anniversary Toast

In the new book that celebrates the first 50 years of baseball’s Southern League, its splendid author Mark McCarter recalls that very early in his career as a sports writer, he was riding with his boss somewhere and mentioned that if the legendary Allan Morris ever needed help covering the Chattanooga Lookouts that he’d love to help. Today, as he looks back, he ruefully adds, “I ... (click for more)

Jones, Vols Meet The Press A Day Before Fall Football Begins

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. -- What did  Butch Jones  have to say about Tennessee’s 2014 football team on the eve of the Vols' first practice? Find out in this transcript of Thursday’s press conference:  HEAD COACH BUTCH JONES (Opening Statement) "It's great to see everyone, and I hope everyone had a great summer. We will hold an open practice on Saturday ... (click for more)

Jane Webb Is A Fun-Loving Runner At Heart

Jane Webb isn’t one of those people who started running when she was a kid, but she loves the benefits since she restarted her running career about four years ago. She’s all about being active and doing things that are good for you,   but long-distance running never really captured her attention and she’s found that she can receive the same payoff by covering ... (click for more)