Supreme Court Rules Defendant Criminally Responsible For Accomplice’s Murder Attempts

Tuesday, October 8, 2013

The Tennessee Supreme Court has upheld a Sevier County man’s two attempted first-degree murder convictions for his role in an attack on several people in a cabin.

In January 2008, Kevin Anthony Dickson, Jr. became angry after purchasing cocaine that he felt was of very poor quality. Dickson enlisted the help of two other men to confront the drug dealers at a Sevierville cabin where the purchase had been made. Dickson borrowed a handgun, purchased ammunition for the gun, and gave it to one of the men, whose name is Johnny Ramirez. Dickson then drove all three men to the cabin. Dickson kicked open the front door of the cabin and demanded drugs as well as the return of his money.

During the intrusion, Ramirez shot two unarmed victims. A trial judge found Dickson guilty of two charges of attempted first-degree murder based on a criminal responsibility theory in the shooting of the two victims by Ramirez. The trial judge imposed a sentence of 25 years for each attempted first-degree murder charge and imposed consecutive sentencing, for an effective sentence of 50 years.

On appeal, the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed one attempted first-degree murder conviction, but reduced the other to attempted second-degree murder. The Court of Criminal Appeals concluded that Ramirez shot one victim as he was attempting to flee, but shot another victim quickly without premeditation, which would only support a conviction for attempted second-degree murder.

The Tennessee Supreme Court partially affirmed and partially reversed the Court of Criminal Appeals. The Supreme Court reasoned that Dickson was criminally responsible for the conduct of Ramirez, as Dickson solicited Ramirez’s help and armed him with a loaded handgun. The Supreme Court also reasoned that there was sufficient evidence of premeditation on the part of Ramirez in the shooting of both unarmed victims. Thus, the Supreme Court approved of the trial court’s finding of two convictions of attempted first-degree murder.

The Supreme Court also determined that the trial judge properly sentenced Dickson consecutively, based on his extensive criminal history.

To read the unanimous Opinion in State of Tennessee v. Kevin Anthony Dickson, Jr., authored by Justice Sharon G. Lee, visit the Opinions section of TNCourts.gov


Applications Now Available For Industrial Hemp Production

The Tennessee Department of Agriculture is now accepting applications from farmers and producers interested in growing industrial hemp. In 2013, the Tennessee General Assembly enacted Public Chapter 916 tasking the department with development of a licensing and inspection program for the production of industrial hemp in Tennessee. As provided in Sec. 7606 of the 2014 Farm Bill, ... (click for more)

Chambliss' Tom Greenholtz Elected Fellow Of American Bar Foundation

Chambliss, Bahner & Stophel, P.C. announced that litigation attorney Tom Greenholtz has been named a member of The Fellows of the American Bar Foundation. The Foundation is an honorary organization of attorneys, judges, and law professors who have demonstrated outstanding achievements and dedication to the welfare of their communities and to the highest principles of the legal ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Gets Bursts Of Snow, But Little Accumulation Expected

Chattanooga got some bursts of snow on Monday night, but little accumulation was expected. However, the Marion County Schools were called off for Tuesday due to the weather. Here is the latest forecast: A DUSTING OF LIGHT SNOW ACCUMULATION POSSIBLE OVERNIGHT... TEMPERATURES CONTINUE TO TUMBLE AS COLD AIR MOVED INTO THE REGION THIS AFTERNOON. AN UPPER LEVEL DISTURBANCE WILL ... (click for more)

Body Found On South Highland Park Avenue

The Chattanooga Police Department is investigating the death of a white woman, found at 2106 S.   Highland Park Ave.  The person’s identity and cause of death are unknown at this time. Chattanooga Police ask anyone with information regarding this crime to call  423 698-2525. The investigation is ongoing and more information will be released when available. (click for more)

We Need The Chattanooga History Center

Having been on several of Dr. Daryl Black's walking tours, I can say that they weren't just informative, but a treat. The downtown, Fort Wood and Ninth Street of yesteryear were brought dramatically to life. We stood on the ground where Sherman had his headquarters (near the Ice Cream Show) and the corner where Bessie Smith sang as a young girl. And we also stood beneath the ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Big (Un)Easy: Mardi Gras

Not since Hurricane Katrina has New Orleans had a bigger problem. When over a million visitors flood the city for the annual Mardi Gras bash over the next three weeks, there will be signs all around town and into the French Quarter that blare, “CAUTION: Walk In Large Groups. We (heart symbol) love NOPD. We Just Need More Of Them.” In other words, it appears things are quite unsettled ... (click for more)