This Benefits Ordinance Is Too Costly - And Response (3)

Monday, November 4, 2013

City Council members,  

In July 2010 every city employee with less than 25 years of continued employment, lost all privileges to the new wellness center and the benefits of the city insurance plan at age 65.  

The reason:   The “benefits” are just too costly to the city.  

Now all by some miraculous means the mayor and some City Council members believe that the city can just absorb the oblivious additional cost to cover a group of people that are significant others,  in relationships with city employees.

The proposed city ordinance (Domestic Partners Healthcare, Medical Benefits) states the additional cost to implement this benefit "based on initial research" will be "less than 1 percent of the total city budget." One percent seems like a small number, so let's do the math as Mrs. Scott suggested. The annual budget for the city of Chattanooga is over $200 million.  If this ordinance passes, the city will need to find an additional $2 million for the budget year 2015 alone to fund this benefit.  This amount will surely increase each year as health care cost also increases.  

This decision is being made during the same time period that a committee is deciding on ways to cut the retirement pensions of  the very people that provide a safe place for us all to live, work and play, fire and police officers. 

The reason again:  the “pension” is just too costly to the city.

If the city cannot pay for benefits and pensions for its employees, how can you even consider to pay for benefits for  partners in a relationship with a city employee?

Vote "NO" for this ordinance, it is the only fair and right thing to do.

Freeman Cooper

Retired City Employee 

* * * 

I'd like to respond to Freeman Cooper's Opinion letter in today's Chattanoogan. I don't know where you got  your numbers on benefits for domestic partners for Chattanooga city employees, (perhaps from the ridiculous statements made by former Council Member Debra Scott) but Knoxville Mayor Madeline Rogero instated comparable benefits for Knoxville city employees this year. 

 As most know, the city of Knoxville is much larger and has a significantly larger operational budget that the city of Chattanooga, and according to the Knoxville News Sentinel, the extended benefits cost $60,000 of the $13 million Knoxville city benefits package. I see no reason Chattanooga's price tag for the same benefits should be much more and I'll remind Mr. Freeman, that less than 1 percent may mean, far less the rounded up numbers that he suggests. 

I'd also like to, respectfully, remind Mr. Cooper, that many of the people that would benefit from these benefits, are the family and loved ones of the same firemen, policemen (not to mention road repair crews, garbage collectors, city clerical workers, and many others) that he lovingly refers to in his letter. 

This, is the fair and right thing to do. 

David Tester

* * *

Freeman Cooper's logic is as faulty as that of John Pierce. They both commented that they had read (I think incorrectly) that the cost of the ordinance would be less than one percent of Chattanooga's total budget. Nonetheless, they both used one percent in their respective calculations, thereby achieving the doomsday predictions which they wanted. 

Less than means less than, not exactly, John, we know that much on Signal Mountain. And the recent estimate by the city is not more than $168,000. No drop in the bucket, admittedly, but about $2,000,000 less than your figure, John.

Don Strickland

Signal Mountain

* * *


The travesty about this debate, is that we seem to think its a money issue. Well, it shouldn't be. Love the sinner, Jesus says. Well I do, I'm a sinner too. 

     God's Holy and perfect Word is very clear. A man laying with another man and a woman laying with another woman is unnatural and evil in His sight. These laws are written along with having sex with animals & family members........ It's wrong.

     Like Judas, wanting to make a buck. It was reported yesterday that allowing this insurance for Chattanooga would aid in drawing businesses and residents here. You can't serve both God and money (Scripture).

    Just because downtown smells like the sewer doesn't mean we have to live like we're actually in one. 

    I don't want to be like the rest of the world. Instead we are called to come out and be separate. Serve the only true God of Abraham Isaac and Jacob.  

Michael Burns





During A Martin Luther King, Jr. March Is Not A Time To Campaign

It truly amazing what Martin Luther King, Jr. accomplished at just 39 years of age. He changed an entire country. Dr. King was not in elected office or in any position of power. Yet, he accomplished more than any politician.  To me the Martin Luther King, Jr.'s vision was an expectation of life centered in education, hard work, and accomplishment that in time would evolve ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: What Else $3 Can Mean

Orchard Knob Middle School, located on North Highland Park Avenue in Chattanooga, led every other secondary school in the state of Tennessee last year with 6.8 percent of its students expelled. So as people are working feverishly to keep the school from being taken over by the state’s Department of Education, allow me to pose a question. Last Friday during the last period of ... (click for more)

Haslam Unveils Comprehensive Tax Cut And Transportation Proposal Including Higher Gas Tax And Vehicle Registration Fee

Joined by mayors from across the state and leaders in the manufacturing and trucking industries, Governor Bill Haslam on Wednesday announced "a comprehensive and strategic plan to cut taxes on food and manufacturing while updating how the state provides Tennesseans the safe and reliable transportation network needed to support future job growth." The IMPROVE Act, “Improving ... (click for more)

Big Woody's Tree Service Employee Killed In Fall On Signal Mountain

Recovery efforts are underway for a man who fell 150 feet off a bluff, while trimming trees on Signal Mountain. At  11:22 a.m. , a 911 call was made by an employee of Big Woody's Tree Service reporting a man in his early 30s had fallen off a bluff the mountain while trimming trees on private property.  The man fell 150 feet. Walden's Ridge Emergency Services ... (click for more)

Tyner Outshoots Brainerd In Big 6-AA Battle

Brainerd’s Jackson-High Gymnasium was filled to capacity long before the girls game had ended Tuesday night, but the overflow crowd had come to see the second meeting between Tyner and Brainerd and a battle for first place in District 6-AA. Both are ranked in the latest state Class AA poll with Tyner listed sixth and Brainerd ninth.  Brainerd had won all four meetings ... (click for more)

No. 3 Cleveland Sneaks Past Walker Valley 59-51

CLEVELAND, Tenn. – State-ranked Cleveland blew most of a 13-point second-half lead, but got clutch field goals from Deontae Davis and KK Curry down the stretch and managed to stay unbeaten in District 5-3A high school basketball action with a hard-fought 59-51 victory over rival Walker Valley on Tuesday night. Walker Valley’s girls defeated the Lady Blue Raiders 43-39 in overtime. ... (click for more)