Man Who Planted Drugs On Angela Garmley's Car Given 18-Month Prison Term; Won't Tell Who Told Him To Do It

Friday, December 13, 2013

The Dalton man who planted drugs on the car of Angela Garmley in Murray County was sentenced Friday in Federal Court in Rome, Ga., to serve 18 months in federal prison. He also must provide 100 hours of community service.

Prosecutor Jeff Davis said Clifford J. "CJ" Joyce put the meth on her car "to help out his landlord." Attorney McCracken Poston, who represents Ms. Garmley, said Cochran, a former Murray County magistrate, was the landlord.

Attorney Poston said, "In the sentencing of Capt. Henderson, we learned that not only did Judge Cochran contact multiple officers trying to get them to pull Angie Garmley over, he also told them where the drugs could be found. Today, in the sentencing of Clifford "CJ" Joyce, we heard that he planted the drugs for his landlord. At the time of the framing of Angie Garmley, he was living in a trailer owned by former magistrate Judge Cochran."

Ms. Garmley said the drugs were planted shortly after she spurned the sexual advances of Magistrate Cochran.

Two police officers have already been sentenced by Judge Harold Murphy in Rome in the scandal.

But no charges have been brought against Cochran and he was dismissed as a defendant in a federal lawsuit filed by Ms. Garmley.

Apparently, none of the three who have been sentenced have given a statement against Cochran. Prosecutor Davis said the GBI and the FBI have carried out over 100 interviews in the case. He said Joyce in his interviews gave "repeated lies."

He said Ms. Garmley and a man with her had to spend a night in jail over the set-up. He said Joyce "sought to subvert the criminal justice system for his own purposes."

The prosecutor said the after effects "have been staggering" including the widespread investigation.

He said Joyce had "impeded the investigation by not coming clean."

Joyce, 27, was not charged with obstruction of justice, but a meth charge.

Prosecutor Davis said in calculating the sentence he should not get credit for "acceptance of responsibility."  

Judge Murphy agreed, saying Joyce "has not been straight-forward. There is nothing in the record that shows what really happened."

The judge did not give him a reduction, but the maximum in the range of 12-18 months. He said, "Others acted, but this was the key to the corrupt action of all."

Judge Murphy said, "This strikes at the very heart of fairness and justice in a free society. I can't think of anything more reprehensible."

Scott Forster, attorney for Joyce, said he is a family man with a wife and three children and another one on the way. He said he had held down a job to support his family.

He said that "law enforcement and sworn judges were involved in this case."

United States Attorney Sally Quillian Yates said, “By planting drugs on an innocent woman’s car, Mr. Joyce attempted to use the criminal justice system to serve his own personal agenda. In the end, however, it is Mr. Joyce, and not the Murray County woman, who will be headed to prison.”

Ricky Maxwell, Acting Special Agent in Charge, FBI Atlanta Field Office, stated, “Mr. Joyce’s sentencing today serves to not only hold him accountable for his crime but provides him time to reflect on this terrible deceptive act intended to harm another innocent individual. The FBI will continue to work with its various local, state, and other federal law enforcement partners to identify and investigate any allegations of criminal conduct involving or adversely impacting our criminal justice system.”

“Vindicating an innocent person is as important as convicting the guilty. The GBI will continue to work with our federal law enforcement counterparts to ensure criminal cases are thoroughly investigated so the innocent remain free and the guilty are held accountable,” said Vernon Keenan, GBI Director.

According to United States Attorney Yates, the charges, and other information presented in court: in July 2012, a Murray County citizen met with then-Chief Magistrate Judge Cochran regarding a legal matter. She alleged that during the meeting, Cochran made inappropriate sexual advances towards her.

In an effort to discredit the citizen, Joyce and others participated in a scheme to frame her for drug possession. On or about August 12, 2012, Joyce hid a metal tin containing five packets of methamphetamine under the tire well of the citizen’s car.

Two days later, on August 14, 2012, Murray County Deputy Sheriff Joshua Greeson (who has since been convicted of witness tampering for lying to law enforcement officers) conducted a traffic stop of the citizen’s car. During the traffic stop, Greeson searched the vehicle for drugs. Ultimately, after receiving information from Captain Michael Henderson (who has also been convicted of witness tampering), Greeson found the metal tin of methamphetamine under the tire well. After locating the drugs, Greeson and Henderson arrested the citizen and the driver of the car on narcotics charges. On August 24, 2012, the district attorney dismissed the charges against the citizen.


16,858 Cast Ballots In First 3 Days Of Early Voting In Hamilton County

In the first three days of early voting in Hamilton County, 16,858 have already cast ballots. That includes 1,607 ballots received by mail. There were 5,157 who turned out at early voting sites on Wednesday and 5,083 on Thursday. The total on Friday was 5,011. Sites: Brainerd 1,084, 1080, 1,030 Election Office 1,848, 1,731, 1,698 Collegedale 956, 954, ... (click for more)

Clarence Ross, Leshawn Witherow Shot On Walden Avenue Friday Afternoon

Chattanooga Police are investigating a shooting that happened early Friday afternoon at the 6300 block of Walden Avenue.  Clarence Ross, 41, And Leshawn Witherow, 40, suffered non-life threatening injuries.  Hamilton County EMS transported both victims to a local hospital for treatment.  There is no suspect information at this time.  Investigators with ... (click for more)

Please, No Short Term Vacation Rentals In My Neighborhood

Approval of the short term vacation rental item on the City Council agenda for Tuesday  will be the next step toward commercializing our residential properties and communities to benefit those more interested in making money than preserving an old, well-established, rich community of like-minded families.    Anything requiring a business license is ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Kelly Could Win It

I am neither a sleuth nor an odds maker but I’d say there is about a one-in-three chance that Interim Hamilton County Department of Education Superintendent Kirk Kelly could become the permanent superintendent of our public schools next Thursday. I am assured something squirrelly is happening on our newly-seated school board. It has been seven months since the last superintendent ... (click for more)

Goetz Outlasts Huwe To Win Signal Mountain Pie Run

The annual Signal Mountain Pie Run is one of those races where you don’t have to be the first across the finish line to be the overall winner. It’s a prediction run, so the runner getting nearest his or her predicted time was honored with cash prizes. Gregg Sutton crossed the line next to the old Signal Mountain Junior High with a time of 46 minutes flat, which was exactly ... (click for more)

UTC Defeats VMI, 30-13; Mocs Seniors Gain 34th Career Win

UTC junior running back Richardre Bagley rushed for a career-high 189 yards and two touchdowns to lead the host Mocs to a 30-13 Southern Conference win against VMI at Finley Stadium before 10, 505 fans. Mocs quarterback Alejandro Bennifield threw one touchdown pass and ran for another and Henrique Ribeiro kicked a 30 yard field goal to complete the scoring for the victors. ... (click for more)