Supreme Court Rules Time-Share Salesperson Excluded From Unemployment Benefits

Monday, December 23, 2013

The Tennessee Supreme Court ruled on Monday that a Gatlinburg-area time-share salesperson is not entitled to unemployment benefits.

The salesperson had worked for several years selling time shares at Westgate Smoky Mountains under an independent contractor agreement. In 2009, Westgate terminated that business relationship and the salesperson filed a claim for unemployment compensation.

The Department of Labor considered whether the salesperson was subject to a law that excludes qualified real estate agents from receiving unemployment benefits. The Department concluded that time-share salespeople do not fall under the real estate agent exclusion and granted the benefits.

Westgate sought review from the Appeals Tribunal, which agreed the benefits should be paid, although for somewhat different reasons. Westgate advanced the matter to the Board of Review, which upheld the award of benefits.

Westgate then took the matter to the Chancery Court, which concluded that a time-share salesperson does fall under the real estate agent exclusion and therefore would not qualify for unemployment compensation. The salesperson took the case to the Court of Appeals, which reversed the trial court’s decision and granted the unemployment pay.

Today, the Supreme Court reversed the Court of Appeals and ruled that a time-share salesperson is a licensed real estate agent.  The Court also ruled that the salesperson met the exclusion for qualified real estate agents and was not entitled to unemployment benefits.

To read the unanimous Opinion in Westgate Smoky Mountains at Gatlinburg v. Burns Phillips, Commissioner, Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development, authored by Justice Janice M. Holder, visit the Opinions section of TNCourts.gov


STEP-UP Chattanooga Recruiting Businesses For Summer 2017

Public Education Foundation is recruiting Chattanooga area businesses to hire Hamilton County Department of Education high school students for paid summer internships through its STEP-UP Chattanooga initiative. Launched in January 2016, this internship program for high school sophomores, juniors and seniors is designed to address the challenges faced by both businesses and students ... (click for more)

Local Graphic Design Firm Wins Four National Awards

Greg Callaham Graphic Design has won four American Graphic Design Awards.  Graphic Design USA , a national trade publication, conferred four 2016 awards to Callaham's design work for Village VW, CHI Memorial Hospital, and Center MedSpa. "I’m grateful to the AGDA for the opportunity to shine the national spotlight on clients such as these who are willing to go the extra ... (click for more)

Governor Haslam, Commissioner Boyd Announce Partnership With Volkswagen To Establish $1 Million Science Lab Program

Governor Bill Haslam and Economic and Community Development Commissioner Randy Boyd along with Volkswagen Group of America, Chattanooga Operations (Volkswagen Chattanooga) officials announced on Tuesday the establishment of a $1 million program that will allow all Hamilton County middle and high schools to apply for funds to create a science lab in their school. Named the Volkswagen ... (click for more)

McReynolds, Brooks Arrested After Police Chase Ends In Crash On Monroe Street; Accord Had Been Stolen From Dealership

Marquis McReynolds, 25, and Jermichael Brooks, 23, were arrested after a police chase on Monday.   A task force including the ATF, FBI, and Chattanooga Police Department officers pursued a stolen vehicle. That pursuit resulted in a traffic crash and the arrest of two convicted felons.   The pursuit began at 5200 Highway 58 just after 7 p.m. after police ... (click for more)

City Officials Should Tour Our Roads - And Response (2)

As we near the election in March, now would be a good time for our city officials who are up for re-election to spend a little time exploring their realm.   I would invite them to take a scenic tour starting at Lake Resort Drive paying attention to the portion of the road which was recently repaired which now appears to be sliding back towards the lake again.  Follow ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Our Puzzling Women

After Rhonda Thurman left the “Enlightment” meeting of the Hamilton Country School Board Saturday afternoon, she must have been catching up on the news when she posted this message on her Facebook page: “I am really trying to understand. I am a woman and I cannot think of one "RIGHT" I do not have. Can someone enlighten me?” Not one person enlightened Rhonda because nobody could ... (click for more)