Lawsuit Filed Seeking Information On Legal Ruling On Aetna Mountain TIF

Friday, February 1, 2013

A Chancery Court lawsuit has been filed against the City Industrial Development Board (Bond Board) seeking information on a legal opinion involving tax increment financing (TIF) for a major project on Aetna Mountain.

The lawsuit was filed by retired planner Helen Burns Sharp, who has been closely following the TIF application and who opposed it at several public meetings.

The City Council, County Commission and Bond Board approved a $9 million TIF for the Black Creek group that plans a major residential development with a town center on the huge tract above Cummings Cove in Lookout Valley.

The funds were designated for construction of an improved road up the mountain along with a main sewer line.

The Bond Board approved the TIF with the stipulation that a legal opinion be issued stating that the Black Creek group request met state requirements for TIFs.

TIFs allow a developer to issue bonds that are later paid off through a portion of the taxes generated by the project. The Black Creek group said if the project fails to generate the taxes, then it would be required to repay the funds.

The suit, filed by attorney John Konvalinka, says Ms. Sharp on Nov. 6 asked for public records related to the legal opinion. It says Ms. Sharp was provided a copy of a letter dated Oct. 31, 2012, from George H. Masterson of Bass, Berry & Sims, an attorney for the Black Creek group.

The complaint says a second request for records was sent Dec. 5, 2012, to City Attorney Mike McMahan. The suit says there was no response to this request.

The suit says Ms. Sharp then sent letters to individual members of the Bond Board asking if they had gotten any correspondence about the Black Creek TIF.

On Dec. 12, 2012, Ms. Sharp was provided a second letter from the firm of Bass, Berry & Sims, it was stated.  

She said she was told by City Attorney McMahan that any other documents related to the TIF were subject to attorney-client privilege.

Another request for records relating to the TIF was sent Jan. 9. The suit says there has been no response to this request.

Attorney Konvalinka said all of the requested records fall under the Tennessee Open Records Act.

He said the city "has willfully refused to disclose the public records requested by Petitioner, even though Respondent knows that the records contained therein are public."


Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: BAGGETT, EMILY MICHELLE 14431 DAYTON PIKE SALE CREEK, 37373 22 Hamilton County PROMOTING MANUFACTURING METHAMPHETAMINE PROMOTING MANUFACTURING METHAMPHETAMINE BUTLER, NATASHA COLLEEN 816 ROANOKE AVENUE CHATTANOOGA, 37404 30 Chattanooga VANDALISM/MALICIOUS MISCHIEF CAMPBELL, CHRISTOPHER ... (click for more)

Appeals Court Rules Against WWTA In Lawsuit Brought By Apartment Complex Over $8 Monthly Charges To Units

The Tennessee Court of Appeals has ruled in favor of an apartment complex that sued the Hamilton County Water and Wastewater Authority (WWTA) over an $8 monthly charge per apartment unit for preparing private service laterals. The court overturned a granting of summary judgment in favor of WWTA by former Judge Jackie Bolton. The appeals court said American Heritage Apartments, ... (click for more)

It's Time To Insure Tennessee - And Response

Tennessee has a problem.  What is the value of saving the lives of 1,000 Tennesseans each year? That is exactly what can be expected if 176,000 Tennesseans gain health insurance through Insure Tennessee. A New England Journal of Medicine study showed that expansion of Medicaid was associated with a 6% reduction in yearly mortality for people in the 34-65 age group. Statistically, ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: What About The Ashes?

I attended my fifth funeral in the month of January the other day and, while I wish a lot of my friends would hang around a little longer, I was amused by the conversation in the pew before the service began. The question was “ … then what do you do with the ashes?” More and more people are being cremated and asking their loved ones to scatter their ashes -- more properly called ... (click for more)

Baylor, Father Ryan Advance to D-II Wrestling Finals

FRANKLIN - Two old rivals meet for the TSSAA D-II state duals title Saturday night as defending state champion Baylor (24-1) take on Father Ryan (22-3) at 8 p.m. EST here at the Williamson County Ag & Expo Center. All three division championships will be held at the same time - D-II, D-I A-AA and D-I AAA. Baylor’s lone dual loss is to Archer (Ga.) and Ryan’s losses ... (click for more)

Cleveland Slips By Walker Valley In Battle Of Top District Teams

The Cleveland Blue Raiders defeated Walker Valley 49-41 Friday night at Cleveland Middle School in a battle between two Bradley County high schools to stay in a tight race at the top of the District 5-AAA standings.   The Blue Raiders jumped out to a quick 7-0 lead over the Mustangs and stayed slightly ahead for the rest of the game. Cleveland fended off a strong ... (click for more)