Divided We Fall: What The Teachers' Union Fails To Learn - And Response

Monday, February 18, 2013

The Tennessee teachers’ union replaced Jerry Winters with Jim Wrye as manager of their government relations. In the process they bypassed a highly intelligent African-American woman with considerable experience in the Tennessee General Assembly. Not one media outlet reported this fact, despite the readily accessible information. 

In Nashville, one of the worst-kept secrets is that Wrye is a former Alabama Democratic Party leader. Tommy Stevenson of the Tuscaloosa News called Wrye an “all-around cheerleader for the state Democratic Party.”

Wrye was also a staff member for Alabama Gov. Don Siegelman. Why would the teachers’ union in Tennessee bring in a partisan from Alabama with no obvious connection to the state? 

Wrye also worked for the Alabama union. In a press report it is claimed that Wrye was a leader in the “successful fight to stop charter schools in the state.” Obviously Mr. Wyre is unaware the charter schools battle has already been fought in Tennessee. We are educating children in our state in charter schools supported by many legislators and the governor.

“I’ve told legislators that for TEA today, it is not about ‘R’ or ‘D.’ It is about who will stand up for our public schools,” said Wrye. The problem with Wrye’s comments is that they are focused on an approach that is “top down,” not “bottom up.” The teachers’ union dictates what the best interest of public education is and too many journalists decide what is best for public education based upon what the union tells them. 

Most of the supposed “war on teachers” promoted by the union was caused by two issues: 1.) Race to the Top, which ushered in many of the reforms teachers opposed; and, 2.) The attempt by legislators to remove “special privileges” granted almost exclusively to the teachers’ union.

In Tennessee, Wrye’s selection seems surprising for a union with rapidly declining membership and in a state with a supermajority of Republican legislators. It certainly bodes well for continued partisanship from the union. 

However, Democrats have more to fear from a biased partisan union. It is never good for any political party to be dominated by one interest group.

Despite political differences, both Republicans and Democrats love our state and our children. By working together in a non-partisan manner we can solve any educational challenges. It is time we stand together for integrity in the political and public school systems. Teachers deserve to belong to an education organization with integrity — one that helps educators not only to have more but to be more. 

J.C. Bowman 

* * *  

If there is an alleged “war on teachers,” who are their enemy?  Republican voters?  Take a look at your deeply red state.   Public school teachers are public servants.   If I felt I was at war with those I allegedly served; with those who’s tax dollars fed my children, I believe I’d reexamine my priorities.  

Tennessee public schools are collectively ranked 21 out of 50 and they ranked second to last in ACT scores in 2011.  Voters expect more for their children and one would think public educators would share their desire for academic excellence.    

The function of public education is to prepare kids for lives as productive adults.  It’s not to provide employment for substandard teachers or to indoctrinate children into Liberal ideology.   As a voter, I want my schools to prepare kids for success.   If that puts me at odds with a teacher, the teacher needs to find a different line of work. 

Jeff Young
Chattanooga


David Carroll: Cracking The Middle School Code

I was recently asked to speak to Ooltewah Elementary fifth graders, as they marked the end of their elementary years.  Now it’s off to the next step.  I believe middle school is the time in which kids either head in the right direction, or the wrong one.  Rather than make them endure a speech by a guy who last wandered the halls in the prehistoric era, I enlisted ... (click for more)

Approve The Humane Educational Society's Increased Budget - And Response

I am a Chattanooga resident and animal lover in Hamilton County. The requested increase for the Humane Educational Society’s budget should be approved.   If we cannot take care of those who have no voice, who will? HES team members and volunteers are very dedicated to making Hamilton County a better place to live, for everyone.   Commissioners, please help them by ... (click for more)

Board Of Regents Board Meets Wednesday To Approve New Chattanooga State President

The Tennessee Board of Regents will convene a special called meeting at  9:30 a.m. CDT next Wednesday to receive recommendations for presidential vacancies at community colleges, including Chattanooga State, and the director position at the Tennessee College of Applied Technology – Covington/Ripley.  The finalists to replace longtime leader Jim Catanzaro are: ... (click for more)

New CARTA Service To Enterprise South Industrial Park Has "Medium" Success So Far

CARTA officials said its new bus service from downtown to the Enterprise South Industrial Park is meeting with "medium" success thus far. Lisa Maragnano, executive director, said there have been 313 riders on the routes that began at the first of the month. That includes 241 getting aboard downtown in the early morning and 72 riding from Enterprise South in the afternoon. ... (click for more)

Signal Mountain Girls Win Second Straight A-AA Track Title

MURFREESBORO – The Signal Mountain Eagles won last year’s Class A-AA state track title by a scant six points, but it wasn’t nearly that close this year. With Camryn Bowman and McKenzie Ethridge both winning two events, the Eagles had a one-point lead following the field events, but ending up scoring 96 points and winning by 24 over runner-up East Nashville. While Signal Mountain ... (click for more)

Baylor To Face GPS Again For D-II State Softball Title

MURFREESBORO – It will be another Baylor-GPS battle for the championship in Division II softball as Baylor advanced with a 10-3 win over St. Benedict while GPS later beat the Lady Eagles by a 2-0 final for the right to face the Lady Red Raiders again. This year’s D-II tournament was similar to last year as Baylor beat GPS on the first day before the Bruisers came back and beat ... (click for more)