Attorneys Spar Over Videos In Lawsuit Over Barnes, Hennen Train Deaths

Thursday, March 21, 2013

Two videos are at the center of a $25 million lawsuit filed earlier by the mother of 19-year-old Hannah Barnes, who died when she and Michael Hennen were run over by a train Aug. 22, 2011. One video is being supplied with tight security over its use and the other has apparently been taped over.

Attorneys reached agreement over video taken from the front of the Norfolk Southern train as it approached a crossing at McDonald Farm in Sale Creek where the tragic deaths occurred.

However, all involved are under strict orders that the footage be used only for trial purposes and not wind up on You Tube as one attorney warned has happened in similar cases. Such release, it was stated, would be "not only illegal, but highly prejudicial and cause emotional pain and suffering to friends and family of the victims."

The video is from the "Rail View System" and securing it required paying a licensing fee for software use to the Science Application International Corporation (SAIC).

In court documents, it was claimed that the conductor said he saw a man asleep on the tracks just prior to the incident.

Lisa Barnes was asked in one document how she obtained information that her daughter was awakened by the train, and she said the conductor said he saw "legs up in the air" at the rural crossing.

Lisa Barnes said during an interview with attorneys that she believes the Hennen family "destroyed" the other video - which allegedly showed Michael Hennen and Ms. Barnes at the bar area of Hennen's Restaurant in the early morning hours prior to their driving up to McDonald Farm.

Jonathan Maley, a Hennen's manager, said in an interview with attorneys that he checked out the restaurant videos after learning of the couple's death.

He said the video showed Michael Hennen behind the bar drinking from a styrofoam cup and Ms. Barnes "kind of at the end of the bar."

Hennen's officials said the restaurant video "loops" every 48 hours and begins taping over.

According to court documents, the video of Michael Hennen and Ms. Barnes had apparently been erased by the time that Tracy Miller of DB Technologies was called to examine the video system.

Tim Hennen, father of Michael Hennen, said there had not been a request from anyone that the video be preserved.

Attorney Mark Warren, who filed the lawsuit, said "a major issue in the case is who provided the alcohol to Hannah Barnes that contributed to her death."

He said Ms. Barnes, who was 19 and not of age to drink, had a blood-alcohol level of .07, which is just below the drunk level of .08. He said Michael Hennen, who was 27, had a blood-alcohol level of .086. Defense attorneys Al Henry and Robert Carden disputed the blood-alcohol level readings.

Attorney Warren said he wants to interview all those at a party earlier that night at Hennen's Restaurant for the birthday of Michael Hennen's mother, Corinne McDonald Hennen. Ms. Barnes and Michael Hennen were there. He listed as guests Frank McDonald, Fletcher Bright, Jean Ann Gardner, Paul Brock, Susan Brock, Kate Frazier, Mike Akin, Meg Akin, Bob Hurdle, Mary Hurdle, Paul Neely, Sherry Pollock, Steve Persinger, Karen Persinger, Andy Stockett, Karen Stockett, Henry Glascock, Heather Glascock, Ken Hays and Jamie Hennen.

He also wants to interview all 15 members of the Hennen's Restaurant staff on duty that night.

Defense attorneys said some of the requests by the plaintiff's attorney have been "annoying, oppressive, embarrassing and unduly burdensome and/or excessive."


Chattanooga's Mark West Speaks At "Audit The IRS" Rally In Washington

Chattanooga Tea Party President Mark West was one of the speakers at the "Audit The IRS" rally. He said, " Over 15,000 patriots from across our great nation came together in Washington, D.C., to decry the willful and deliberate targeting of American citizens and conservative groups by the Internal Revenue Service.  Many liberty-loving Americans, from key Senators, Congressman ... (click for more)

County Says Unincorporated Voters Would Have To Approve Distilleries

The Legislature passed a bill to allow distilleries in Hamilton County, but due to action by the County Commission on Wednesday it does not apply to the unincorporated areas. Commissioner Jim Fields said voters in those areas could vote to opt in for distilleries. However, distilleries would not be allowed out in the county until there is such a vote. The bill was passed ... (click for more)

Our Criminal Justice System Is Broken

Today’s news that after a man was shot while coming to the aid of a friend, four were arrested (including two 13-year-olds) for robbery and attempted murder, followed by additional news that one of those arrested had previously pled guilty to aggravated burglary and was given a three-year suspended sentence, is further indication that our system of criminal justice is absolutely ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: On Being Ugly: The New Cool

In a recent issue of Sports Illustrated, two full pages were devoted to mug shots of the Boston Bruins and the Chicago Blackhawks. The two hockey teams are now playing in the finals for the Stanley Cup and every single player on either page looked like a terrorist. Not one was without ratty hair and scruffy beards ruled the day. On another page was an advertisement for some cologne ... (click for more)

Tennessee Beats Georgia, 5-4, In Stump On Sports Baseball Classic

The 12 th Stump on Sports Tennessee-Georgia Baseball Classic was dominated by strong pitching and Wednesday’s game at Ridgeland High’s Jay Smith Field came down to a one-on-one duel between hard-throwing right-hander Colton Jumper and slugger Bryce Bailey. Jumper got the edge, striking out Bailey for the game’s final out and Tennessee strolled away with a 5-4 victory, its ... (click for more)

UTC Gridiron Opener -70 Days and Counting

Ten weeks from tonight it’s “Thursday Night Football at Finley” as the University of Tennessee at Chattanooga hosts UT Martin in the college football season opener for both schools. Led by three All-Americans, the Mocs (6-5 in 2012) have 10 starters back on each side if the ball plus the kicker and anticipation is high for a run at the Southern Conference title and a spot in ... (click for more)