Haslam Decision A Great Disappointment - And Response

Thursday, March 28, 2013

Governor Haslam has now declined the federal government’s offer of $12 billion that would provide health care coverage for approximately 200,000 lower-income Tennesseans who now are without any coverage.  Instead, the Governor says he is working towards a different way—the “Tennessee Plan”—to provide this health care support for our neediest neighbors. 

This decision is a great disappointment to a broad coalition of business, labor, religious, advocacy, and community groups that supported acceptance of the federal funds. Now, having made this decision to reject readily available federal tax dollars already paid by Tennesseans, the Governor has an enormous responsibility. First, he must provide details of how his “Tennessee Plan” would actually work—there are only the vaguest generalities in his rejection statement. Second, he must do whatever it takes to actually get the federal support he just rejected. This means working hard to hammer out an agreement with the federal government and it means working even harder to build the political support across Tennessee that will be needed to win approval by the Tennessee Legislature.  Nothing less is acceptable, given the enormous stakes involved.

As the Governor faces up to the challenge he has created for himself, he would do well to ponder what has happened to us as a caring and compassionate society. True, after a natural disaster, Tennesseans still rush forward to help those who suffered physical or material damage. But what about the hundreds of thousands of our Tennessee neighbors whose lives are ruined every day—year after year—by limited or no access to reliable health care? Do we even care about them, or do we cross to the other side of the road and simply look away?

How do we explain the enthusiastic applause by Tennessee legislators when the Governor announced his rejection of the federal support? Don’t they have any conception of the human lives and suffering that are at stake in this decision? Or do they simply not care what happens to the least among us?

And what about Governor Haslam? 

Frank Meeuwis
Madison, Tn. 

* * * 

After reading this morning about Governor Haslam’s total lack of humanity in his decision on TennCare, I had intended to write a lengthy piece about why his idea is such a disaster but then encountered this from Belen Fernandez, author of The Imperial Messenger: Thomas Friedman at Work and contributing editor at Jacobin Magazine, in her opinion column today on Al Jazeera Online:   

"The neoliberal experiment in the U.S. has helped mold a society disconnected from the human condition, where oppression of the individual has aimed to thwart popular solidarity that might threaten the experiment. What should be a universal right to health care, for example, is instead wielded punitively against the population, and, as acclaimed journalist and radio host Doug Henwood points out, 'Obamacare' will presumably result in a situation in which 'scores of millions are thrown onto the private individual insurance market and forced to pay $1,000 a month for crappy coverage.'" 

I find it nearly impossible to put it better.  TennCare, initiated by Democratic governor Ned McWherter, was intended as a show-piece of the Democratic Party’s program of pushing PPP’s, public-private partnerships.  These PPP’s were inflicted on the nation as a major facet of the agenda of the Clinton administration back in the 1990’s.   

Like every other neoliberal plan to destroy the gains of the New Deal and the Golden Age of Capitalism to which it led, TennCare has proven to be a miserable failure.  And now Governor Haslam’s answer to its critics is to do more of the same.  In addition to this obvious assault on common sense from that perspective, this plan ignores the fact that these companies were major players in the various debacles which brought down the economy at the end of 2007 and gave us the still continuing Great Recession. 

But what else can we expect of a man who bashed one of our state’s chief employers and producers of wealth?  I refer, of course, to Haslam’s response to Volkswagen’s impending institution of a workers’ council and likely corresponding invitation to the United Auto Workers to form a local at the plant.  That is exactly the war Volkswagen handles its labor relations in Germany and Haslam & Co. have no business messing with VW’s business. 

Of course, they already have done so with their law allowing workers to carry arsenals to their places of employment in their vehicles.  This in of the explicit testimony of numerous incidents of workplace multiple shootings and desires of companies such as VW to avoid those kinds of insanity which don’t happen  because (1) gun ownership is not as widespread both because of laws and differing temperaments, and (2) guns don’t kill people but Americans with guns kill a lot of people. 

Chuck Hamilton


Roy Exum: Our Insult To Israel

I am deeply saddened that over two dozen members of Congress – all Democrats – will be boycotting a speech by Benjamin Netanyahu, the Prime Minister of Israel, when he speaks in Washington tonight. I am also offended that the President of the United States will not receive Netanyahu prior to the speech – a customary gesture on such occasions – because he claims it is too close to ... (click for more)

Remembering Dr. Jack Willke - And Response

When I first became active as a Right-to-Life leader in 1975, Dr. Jack Willke (and his wife, Barbara) were the preeminent leaders at the National level.  Rarely did you see one without the other. They literally wrote the book used by Pro-Life activists everywhere, The Handbook on Abortion . I carried it everywhere and studied it over and over. Their books sold ... (click for more)

2 Hit While Walking On Birmingham Highway; 1 Dies At The Hospital

Two pedestrians were struck by a single vehicle on Highway 11 (Birmingham Highway) in Lookout Valley on Tuesday night. One of those who was struck died after being taken to a local hospital. Police said the other person who was hit was responsive. The incident happened shortly after 7 p.m. at 261 Birmingham Hwy. which is in the area of the Lookout Valley Cracker ... (click for more)

Henry Hopes To Bring E-Filing To Clerk's Office This Year; Saving Almost $222,000 On Personnel

Circuit Court Clerk Larry Henry said he hopes to bring E-Filing of documents and other court papers to the clerk’s office this year.   He said at first it appeared it might take much longer, but that progress is being made to the online program. Mr. Henry told members of the Pachyderm Club that attorneys, litigants and members of the public would be able to go online to ... (click for more)

Double Overtime Thriller: Central Boys Going To State

For all the folks who came to Chattanooga State Tuesday night for the Class AA sectional battle between Livingston Academy and Region 3-AA champ Central, they got their money's worth and more. And they even got some free basketball to boot. Needing a couple of overtimes, the Purple Pounders will be heading to Murfreesboro and MTSU's Murphy Center next week for the TSSAA State ... (click for more)

Blackman Blazes A Trail To State By Bashing Bradley, 55-35

(Story will be updated) MUFREESBORO, Tenn. – The Class AAA state champions are still alive and well. Blackman raced past outmanned Bradley Central, 55-35, Tuesday night in a Class AAA sectional victory that blazed a path right to the boys state tournament at nearby Middle Tennessee State University starting on March 11. The Blaze (24-5) will be making their fourth ... (click for more)