The Financial Implication Of Violence In Chattanooga - And Response (2)

Sunday, June 30, 2013

It appears that not a day goes by that a shooting hasn’t happened in the black community in Chattanooga.  Just the other day, four black men were shot in Alton Park, and the week before that four were shot in East Chattanooga.  As a life-long resident in these areas, I wonder if the community leaders have a clue about what’s happening or care about violence that seems to be as common as the lack of education that is perhaps the cause.  Is there anyone listening to our misery?  Or is my voice a voice crying in the wilderness?

I know the cost of this violence in human terms, which has racked up scores of victims losing life and limbs, but has anyone thought about the financial cost when a shooting victim goes to the emergency room of a local hospital?  For example, the cost of the four men shot on Fagan Street has to be in excesses of $100,000 or more. 

I know the black leaders (religious, political, educational, civic) are clueless of a solution to the problem, and the citizens they represent are hopeless.  However, since money talks, maybe the good white people in Chattanooga when considering the financial implications of this black on black violence will do something.  Because when you realize that it’s your tax dollars that is paying for this senseless violence, hopefully you will have a call to action, and blacks in Chattanooga will get some peace.

Clifford Eberhardt 

* * * 

Mr. Eberhardt,
I can guarantee you that the rest of Chattanooga is “listening.” But I’m not sure that “the good white people in Chattanooga” can just swoop in and solve the problem of black on black violence in the inner city. The problems are rooted deep in cultural habits, parenting missteps, poor personal choices and (maybe) expecting the solution to come from the outside instead of from within. 

On Dec. 10, 2008, the Times Free Press published an article entitled “Chattanooga: Local crime concentrated in inner city, report shows.” 

Crime in [Hamilton County] disproportionately is concentrated in five subregions in Chattanooga – South Chattanooga, downtown, Bushtown/Highland Park, Amnicola/East Chattanooga and Ridgedale/Oak Grove/Clifton Hills…. Those five subregions make up slightly more than 14 percent of the county’s population but account for nearly 50 percent of robbery complaints and more than 45 percent of drugs and narcotics violations, the report shows. 

In the article, David Eichenthal, president and CEO of the Ochs Center, noted that these five subregions ranked in the top five in the county for low school attendance and in the top six for births to single mothers. Obviously there is a link between a life of violence and ditching school. Obviously there is a link between a community of violence and babies born to a single parent, babies born to a teenager, babies born to women who have chosen to give their bodies to boys – or to men who are tied to crime or drugs or immaturity. 

According to Chattanooga youth development organization On Point, “Local research conducted through the Chattanooga Health Council confirms national research that risk behaviors are linked. Sexual activity among teens has been scientifically linked to poor academic performance, violence, substance abuse, increased truancy; kids involved in one of these behaviors tend to be involved in others as well.” 

I completely understand that single mothers trying their best to raise their children have to work to put food on the table. It is not realistic to think that the single mothers of downtown Chattanooga today can be home when their children leave for school every morning or when their children get in from school every afternoon. That makes it difficult to monitor whom their preteens and teens are spending time with and whether or not they are getting tangled up in a life of crime. 

But the younger generation can make the change for themselves. They can protect themselves from the same struggles of their parents. There are so many non-profits already in place - put there by the thousands of Chattanoogans outside the region who really care - that can partner mentors and teens to help them make positive choices, to help them band together and say “no” to the temptations of the flesh and therefore guarantee themselves a brighter future than what they see in their communities now. It is possible to choose abstinence. It is possible to wake up on time in the morning and get to school. Self control is difficult. Going against the grain is difficult. But it is not impossible. 

On Point has curriculum that can empower teens, increase their sense of self worth, sharpen their critical thinking skills and develop a vision for their future.  The Bethlehem Center in Alton Park offers character development, leadership development and literacy training with a special focus on at-risk males.  Chattanooga Sports Ministries offers activities to keep children occupied and fit instead of in trouble, specifically soccer programs in Alton Park, East Lake and East Chattanooga. House of Refuge in St. Elmo helps area men overcome addiction. The Oak Project mentors single mothers and their children.  First Things First offers resources and seminars for parenting and marriage help. 

What if the younger generation of these violent subregions of Hamilton County would decide for themselves that they want better. What if they flood the dozens of organizations already in place to help them make a change? Pledge to educate themselves on how to avoid a life of crime and single parenting then find the organizations and mentors already in place near them to make that happen? Then hopefully the rest of Chattanooga will stand up and provide the funding and volunteer hours that are required to keep up the positive change. Unless the vision comes from the masses within, I am not so sure that more programs, more police presence, more anything will really make a difference. 

Camille Platt
East Brainerd 

* * * 

Why did the mayor dismantle the gang task force and the program "The Future Is Ours" as soon as he got into office?   It is my disappointed belief that he did it as he didn't want the "gang" term to hurt tourism in our area.  Typical political reaction: putting money over the good of the people.  

Chattanooga definitely has a gang problem.  Perhaps once a tourist gets shot downtown, the mayor will realize that stopping/preventing gang violence is more important in the long run for both tourists and residents. 

Now they're wondering how to stop gang violence?  Good luck with that, those programs were a great preventative deterrent to a problem that isn't going away on its own. 

Netta Dean


Why Aren't Commissioners Part-Time Employees?

Five years ago in an online piece by David Carroll, dated Aug 26 and 27, 2010, Thomas Kranz, CFO for the Hamilton County Schools, was addressing the issue of a retirement plan for Hamilton County School Board members.  In his remarks, Mr. Kranz noted that sometime earlier than 2010, Hamilton County commissioners established their own retirement plan funded by the Hamilton ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Barners Trounce Who?

There is a website known as Grammarly that just completed a profound study. An automated proof-reading company (who I hope never finds out about me) collected 100 comments that each included over 50 words from the comment blogs of the nation’s preseason Top 25 college football teams. Then they fed them into the company’s huge algorithm computer and checked each fan base for punctuation, ... (click for more)

Hutcheson Medical Center May Get Bankruptcy Trustee Who Would Focus On Sale Of Fort Oglethorpe Hospital

Hutcheson Medical Center may be headed for appointment of a bankruptcy trustee, who would focus on the sale of the financially-strapped Fort Oglethorpe hospital. An attorney told a bankruptcy court judge in Rome, Ga., on Wednesday afternoon that a buyer is discussing paying over $20 million for all the assets of the community hospital. Attorney Rob Williamson ... (click for more)

Hutcheson Medical Center Unsecured Creditors Committee Asks Trustee Be Appointed For Fort Oglethorpe Hospital; Asks Bankruptcy Not Be Dismissed

The Unsecured Creditors Committee of Hutcheson Medical Center is opposing a motion by U.S. Trustee Guy Gebhardt for a bankruptcy judge to dismiss the bankruptcy for the financially-ailing Fort Oglethorpe hospital.   Instead, the group is asking Judge Paul Bonapfel to appoint a trustee to oversee the Hutcheson finances. In a 16-page motion, the committee said if the bankruptcy ... (click for more)

East Ridge Football: Home Side Stands Are Closed ... Four Home Games Will Be Played on Campus

The home side football stands and press box at East Ridge High School are closed permanently due to safety issues, but for the 66 teenagers who wear the orange, white and gray for the Pioneers on Friday nights it’s a small distraction and the season continues. “Playing this Friday’s game against Signal Mountain at Baylor (7:30 p.m.) is a small distraction for us, but we know ... (click for more)

Signal Mountain Sweeps Red Bank In Volleyball

Signal Mountain coach Jennifer Redman was not a very happy young lady last week when Notre Dame came up and took a 3-1 volleyball win in the Lady Eagles' gym. She knows she has an experienced team with more than her share of talent, but they just hadn't been playing like it to start the season. The veteran coach was somewhat happier Wednesday night after her team took a non-district ... (click for more)