Roy Exum: Horse Celebration Appears Doomed

Wednesday, July 31, 2013 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

The 75th Annual Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration is scheduled to begin three weeks from tonight in Shelbyville and it is looking like a ticket will be the worst buy since the Titanic set sail. The eleven-day event is sponsored by the “Dirty Lick” faction of Tennessee Walking Horse industry and the scurrilous group known for its abuse of animals suffered a severe blow in Texas yesterday when a U.S. District Court in Fort Worth upheld federal regulations to prevent the intentional “soring” of the magnificent animals.

While soring has been banned for over 40 years under the federal Horse Protection Act, a Shelbyville-based subsidiary known as “S.H.O.W.”  had sued the U.S. Department of Agriculture in the far-away court under the premise the regulations were “unfair” and in violation of their constitutional rights. But the court ruled the mandatory penalties were indeed constitutional and within the USDA’s statutory authority to protect the animals.

Jonathan Lovvorn, a senior vice president for the Humane Society of the United States, oversees litigation and investigations for the Washington-based advocacy group and immediately called on the USDA to decertify SHOW, which has positioned itself to be responsible for inspections at the National Celebration.

At last year’s Celebration, SHOW reported few violations – publicly citing a 98.1 compliance rate -- but federal inspectors randomly picked 190 horses to be tested and 145 of those animals were found to be positive based on professional swabs taken to an accredited laboratory. True horsemen and women, dedictated to the “sound” horse and natural gait, accuse SHOW of actually protecting the Dirty Lickers and the federal lab findings confirm the sleazy side of the horse industry.

Meanwhile, it has been revealed the Shelbyville show, now suffering badly from the public’s wrath, has lost over $1 million over the past five years. Last year – after scathing video coverage of sadistic Jackie McConnell torturing horses was shown around the world -- losses were $438,356 for the Celebration. SHOW has lost $558,987 since 2009 and ticket sales this summer have plummeted almost as badly as the Dirty Lickers’ image.

The Dirty Lickers, as the Shelbyville crowd is now called, this after repeatedly using soring and torture for decades to make horses kick their front legs high for what is called the “Big Lick,” seem oblivious to the mounting pressure and open scorn being directed from every corner.

Larry Joe Wheelon, a trainer in Maryville who served on the Ethics Committee for the Dirty Lick’s trainers association, will go before the Blount County Grand Jury on felony charges next month and Hall of Fame trainer McConnell has effectively been banned by a state judge for owning or training a horse in his lifetime. Other trainers in Tennessee are believed to be under investigation after the Governor vetoed a despicable “Ag-Gag” effort for the misinformed state legislature.

The Whitfield-Cohen bill to Prevent All Soring Tactics (H.R. 1518) now has 133 co-sponsors as it courses through Congress and, if it passes, with give heightened strength to the Horse Protection Act. Of course, the Shelbyville crowd is earnest trying to stop the bill rather than comply with the laws. In Tennessee horse soring is now a felony but Wheelon is the first trainer to be arrested since the law became effective last July.

Marty Irby, a members of the Executive Committee of the Tennessee Walking Horse Breeder’s and Exhibitor’s Association, called on the registry to support the Whitfield-Cohen bill and, while the membership voted down the measure, his courageous stand warranted front-page coverage on the Nashville Tennessean last week. “I’ve been through pure hell,” he said. “But it’s the greatest gift that God has ever given me in my life. I have been as far from one side to another that a person can come.”

Irby has been banned from the Celebration but knows exactly what takes place: Unscrupulous trainers abuse horses to win. He’s the father to an 8-month-old son and told the Tennessean, “My boy loves walking horses — he watches them go by in the ring — I think 100 years into the future. People think I’m nuts, but I know this can be the biggest breed on Earth one day if we take the right steps right now and not next year. And if we don’t, it will die on the vine.”

Some feel death is imminent and not until the Shelbyville influence can be rooted out and replaced will the Walker ever regain its stature. One judge at this year’s Celebration – Rollie Beard of Lewisburg – has a notorious past of Horse Protection Act violations and the trainer’s association board is a virtual who’s who of past offenders.

The USDA has not responded to Tuesday’s court ruling but Chris Mather, a public relations spokesman for SHOW, said the group was disappointed. “Obviously … we have been committed to reform since our inception and continue to be committed to moving the industry forward through fair and consistent inspections and penalties in the best interest of the welfare of the horse.  We are reviewing all of our options.”

What he failed to say there aren’t many options for the scofflaws left and this year’s Celebration, again with a harsh glare on empty seats and entries plunging, will doubtlessly suffer worse than ever before.

royexum@aol.com


No More Immigrants Till Our Veterans Are Taken Care Of

From the news today, "A 76-year-old veteran committed suicide on Sunday in the parking lot of the Northport Veterans Affairs Medical Center on Long Island, where he had been a patient, according to the Suffolk County Police Department.  "Peter A. Kaisen, of Islip, was pronounced dead after he shot himself outside Building 92, the nursing home at ... (click for more)

Send Your Opinions To Chattanoogan.com

We welcome your opinions at Chattanoogan.com. Email to  news@chattanoogan.com . We require your real first and last name and contact information. There is no word limit, but if your article is too long you may lose your reader. Please focus more on issues than personal attacks. (click for more)

Auto Burglary Thwarted In Bradley County

A man has been arrested in Bradley County, after attempting to steal a vehicle. On Thursday, Deputy Jessica Morgan observed a silver truck in a church parking lot on South Lee Highway. While checking the premises, Dep. Morgan observed a male wearing a black tank top and red shorts exiting the rear window of the cab into the bed of the truck. Once the suspect noticed Dep. Morgan, ... (click for more)

Jury Awards 25 City Police Personnel Total Of $562,000 On Claims That Pay Plan Was Not Followed

A Chancery Court jury on Wednesday gave a verdict totaling $562,000 for 25 city police personnel who filed suit almost five years ago alleging that the city never lived up to terms of a 2010 pay plan. Attorney Stevie Phillips, who tried the case along with Janie Parks Varnell, said, "The jury awarded each officer what we had asked for to the penny." She stated, "These 25 members ... (click for more)

Sale Creek Storms Past Central, 3-0, In Volleyball Action

Despite playing short-handed, Sale Creek’s once-beaten Lady Panthers made short work of Central, 3-0, Thursday night in high school volleyball action at Central High School. The Lady Panthers sprinted to their 11 th win in 12 matches this season by whipping Central 25-21, 25-13, 25-8 in the non-district matchup. “We played well today,” Sale Creek coach Debbie Hill said. ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Central Inducts Five Alums into Hall of Fame Tonight

Five Chattanooga Central High School star student-athletes will be inducted into the Central Sports Hall of Fame tonight prior to the Central-Soddy Daisy football game. The five former student athletes are: Steve Arnold (1972, track and field), Gina Brooks (1985, softball), Steve Carroll (1966, football), Rick Duncan (1971, baseball), Gene Hall (1952, boxing). Gene ... (click for more)