Randy Smith: Who Is To Blame In The “Johnny Football” Controversy?

Wednesday, August 7, 2013 - by Randy Smith
Randy Smith
Randy Smith

“Now men……here at “The Rock”, we have just one rule. And that’s to obey all rules.”-Deputy Barney Fife.

While college football fans, particularly Texas A&M fans wait for the NCAA hammer to drop on Heisman Trophy winner Johnny Manziel, we all must ask, “who can we blame for this?” Manziel is facing suspension for part or all of the 2013 season for getting paid for signing autographs in January.  I’ve narrowed it down to three.

First, let’s blame the broker; you know the guy who has stated he paid Manziel $7500 for signing mini-footballs and helmets during the BCS National Championship festivities in January. He reportedly has video of the Heisman winner signing, though there was no evidence of a cash exchange. The broker stated he was videoing the signing for proof the autographs were real. He also said he was no longer interested in selling the video, after ESPN declined to buy it. He did allow an ESPN reporter to see it but so far, no one else has witnessed it.

Secondly, let’s blame Johnny Manziel. He understood the NCAA rules completely. He knew it was wrong to take any money but he allegedly did it anyway. Now he has put his career and the entire Texas A&M season in jeopardy for a mere $7500. I overheard someone say this week, “Johnny Manziel could be the stupidest football player in the country.” I disagree; he’s not stupid. He lacks good moral fiber and character.

Finally, let’s blame the NCAA. It’s been dozens of years since a push began to allow amateur athletes to share in the tremendous profits being made by selling jerseys and autographs among other things. However, nothing has been done. Texas A&M has made a lot of money selling his jersey, so why shouldn’t he get a cut? I‘m sure “Johnny Football” himself would agree. There is absolutely nothing at all fair about that rule. Yet, it’s still there and the NCAA continues to enforce it.

There it is. All the blame for a potential lost season for Manziel and his Aggie teammates placed on two individuals and the NCAA. Guys like the broker who paid the money will always be there; bending and breaking rules simply to put money in his bank account. There will always be athletes like Manziel who is tempted by these jackals to have some extra spending money in his pocket. $7500 really isn’t a lot of money by today’s standards but it’s a lot when you’re a young man with few real expenses.

There is absolutely no way to enforce this rule. There are too many brokers and too many athletes to keep an eye on all of them, so only the high profile, Heisman Trophy winners and big-time college football players on nationally prominent teams will be caught. (Remember Ohio State?) With that stated, the NCAA should change or modify that rule right away.

I strongly feel if Johnny Manziel is guilty he should be punished. As unfair as the NCAA rule is, it was wrong to knowingly break it. And speaking of unfair……..the people who are affected the most by this are Manziel’s Aggie teammates. Texas A&M goes from a top-five program with “Johnny Football” to a non-top 25 team without him. That big offensive lineman who never gets recognized or asked for an autograph was counting on Manziel to be there to help him get a championship ring and make some super memories. Oh well.



Randy Smith has been covering sports in Tennessee for the last 43 years. After leaving WRCB-TV in 2009, he has continued his broadcasting career as a free-lance play-by-play announcer. He is also an author and is a media concepts teacher at Brainerd High School in Chattanooga. He is also the Head Softball Coach at Brainerd. Randy Smith's career has included a 17-year stint as scoreboard host and pre-game talk show host on the widely regarded "Vol Network". He has also done play by play of more than 500 college football, basketball, baseball and softball games on ESPN, ESPN2, Fox Sports, CSS and Tennessee Pay Per View telecasts. He was selected as "Tennessee's Best Sports Talk Show Host" in 1998 by the Associated Press. He has won other major awards including, "Best Sports Story" in Tennessee and his "Friday Night Football" shows on WRCB-TV twice won "Best Sports Talk Show In Tennessee" awards. He has also been the host of "Inside Lee University Basketball" on CSS for the past 11 years. He was the first television broadcaster to ever be elected to the "Greater Chattanooga Area Sports Hall of Fame", in 2003. Randy and his wife, Shelia, reside in Hixson. They have two married children (Christi and Chris Perry; Davey and Alison Smith). They also have three grandchildren (Coleman, Boone, and DellaMae).

Randy Smith: SEC Picks Week 13

Where has this college football season gone? It was only yesterday that I was counting the days, hours and minutes down to the first kickoff. Now, after Saturday's games, the regular season ends and we look forward to the league championship games, bowl games and the college football playoff. The regular season will likely go out with a bang, so here goes... Alabama @ Auburn: ... (click for more)

JOHN HUNT: Giving Thanks On Another Beautiful Day

Well, here we are again.   Where has that last year gone in such a hurry? As has been the case in recent years, I’m following in Roy Exum’s footsteps with my many reasons to be thankful. Among other things, I AM THANKFUL that I woke up today without a hangover.   It’s been almost 22 years since and I hope I never forget just how bad that last one was. ... (click for more)

City Council To Consider Policy That Job Applicants Would Not Have To Reveal Criminal Records

The City Council on Tuesday night will consider a policy that city job applicants would not have to reveal their criminal past. Councilman Yusuf Hakeem cited problems those with felony records have in securing employment. The policy would go into effect by the first of the year. The resolution says: WHEREAS, the City of Chattanooga (the "City") is committed ... (click for more)

City Considering Measure That Would Require City Employees To Be Tennessee Residents

The City Council is considering an ordinance that would require city employees to be residents of the state of Tennessee. Currently, the city has employees who live in North Georgia and North Alabama  and that is allowed.  If the ordinance is approved by the City Council, it still would need to be okayed by a majority of city voters in an election. The measure ... (click for more)

An Extra Helping Of Gratitude

After being thankful for the grace of God, my family and good health, this year I have an extra helping of gratitude to live in a special place called Chattanooga.   We endured the trauma of terrorism on July 16 and emerged more united and stronger than ever before.  We claim our heritage and celebrate our diversity like no other city in America.  We honor our ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Cometh ‘The Black Dog’

I am one of 350 million people in the world who suffers from clinical depression. The doctors trace it back to my first decade of the 21 st century when constant surgeries and infections knocked me loopy but the more I have found, I believe I am more like Sir Winston Churchill, Abraham Lincoln and pro football star Terry Bradshaw – I think I have had it all my life. Today it ... (click for more)