Philadelphia Consultant Says Fixes Needed For Fire And Police Pension Fund

Monday, September 9, 2013
Vijay Kapoor gave presentation
Vijay Kapoor gave presentation

A Philadelphia consultant hired by the administration of Mayor Andy Berke on Monday night told members of the new fire and police pension task force that fixes are needed to shore up the plan and protect city and taxpayer interests.

Vijay Kapoor of Public Financial Management (PFM) said at the group's first meeting at the Public Library that the fund is funded at 63 percent, but "to be blunt you want it at 100 percent."

He said, "Chattanooga is not Detroit," but he said he had "serious concerns" about the local plan.

He said PFM helped achieve marked improvements for the Lexington, Ky., fire and police pension fund, but he said it required concessions, including raising the retirement age, having members put in 12 percent of pay instead of 11 percent and reducing cost of living increase benefits. He said both sides hammered out the pact.

Mr. Kapoor said the local plan currently has almost $150 million in unfunded liabilities. He said the city's contribution has grown over 100 percent since 1998 and was $13.3 million this year. 

At the close of the meeting, a number of fire and police officers gave opinions or asked questions. One said it appeared the meeting was "kind of one-sided." Another asked if the pension board and its experts would have a chance to make presentations.

Travis McDonough, the mayor's chief of staff who presided, said the 10 fire and police current and retired officers on the panel represent the pension board. He said PFM is talking closely with pension board officials and using their actuary's latest numbers from January.

He said if there is not a consensus reached by the task force that the PFM recommendations will still go forward to the mayor and the City Council.

Mr. McDonough said this administration will deal with the issue and not pass it along to another administration.

Police Chief Bobby Dodd said the situation is complicated by the fact there are at least six different groups of beneficiaries. He said the effect of changes needs to be considered for all the groups.

Local pension recipients currently get 3 percent cost of living increases Jan. 1 of each year.

It was noted that benefit costs went up significantly after a DROP plan was inserted in 2001. Fire and police members said that plan was the city's idea.

Mr. Kapoor and Mr. McDonough both noted that fire and police do not get Social Security benefits and rely on the pension payments. Mr. McDonough said the plan will be kept strong enough so the city can continue to draw quality candidates.

Mr. Kapoor said the financial rating agencies, including Moody's, have begun taking a closer look at municipal pension fund liabilities. He said Moody's recently lowered the ratings of a number of cities based on that factor.

Mr. Kapoor said he would be contacting members of the group individually for their input. He said he would be seeking input toward reaching an agreement on a new benefit program.

The next meeting is Oct. 7.

Click here to read the presentation.

Police Chief Bobby Dodd, Chief of Staff Travis McDonough and Fire Chief Lamar Flint
Police Chief Bobby Dodd, Chief of Staff Travis McDonough and Fire Chief Lamar Flint

Head-On Crash On Fulbright Road Mars Otherwise Uneventful Memorial Day In Bradley County

A head-on crash marred an otherwise uneventful Memorial Day in Bradley County, Stan Clark of Bradley County EMS said.   Shortly after 11 a.m., Bradley County EMS responded two ambulances and a paramedic supervisor to Fulbright Road off of Blythe Ferry Road for a reported accident with injuries. When EMS units arrived on the scene they found two vehicles that ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Judge Hearing Appeal Of Woman Who Has Been On Death Row Since She Was 20

A Chattanooga judge is hearing the appeal of a Tennessee woman who has been on death row since she was 20. Christa Gail Pike turned to Federal Court after exhausting her appeals to avoid the death penalty in state court for the torture murder of a romantic rival when she was 18. Judge Sandy Mattice is holding evidentiary hearings in Nashville on Tuesday and Wednesday of this ... (click for more)

A Memorial Day Reflection

I wish I could find that combination of words that would capture an inclusive meaning of Memorial Day.  I have attended many Memorial Day programs at the Chattanooga National Cemetery, so many that now they have merged into one memory.  But what stands out is that each year there are more friends and veterans to visit.  Some gave their all many years ago.  And ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Two More Kick Out UAW

Woody Hayes, the great Ohio State football coach, used to teach his players to “paralyze resistance with persistence” but, my word, the likable theory has taken quite a beating in the past two years at the NTN-Bower ball-bearing plant in Hamilton, Ala. The workers there voted to decertify from the United Auto Workers union two years ago but getting the UAW out the door has turned ... (click for more)

Lookouts Memorial Day Game In Mobile Rained Out

The fifth and final game of the five game series between the Chattanooga Lookouts and Mobile BayBears was rained out Monday due to heavy rains.  The Lookouts have Tuesday off before they open a homestand at AT&T Field with five games against the Southern League South Division leading Biloxi Shuckers (Milwaukee) and three games against the SL North Division's second-place ... (click for more)

Golf and Chattanooga Have Lost Another Oehmig

  It was a classic Father’ Day golf picture. No, not Jack and Arnie and their kids relaxing at Augusta National with the Dogwoods blooming. But the Oehmig men – Lew, the family patriarch, with his youngest son, King, and his then two grade school age sons Henry and John, all crowded into, what else, a golf cart and donning that Oehmig glasses look – round, turtle shell-colored ... (click for more)