Attorney Says Statement By Former SAU Student Was Lapse In Judgment, Not Serious Threat

Friday, January 31, 2014

The attorney for James Michael Gaines said his statement at Chattanooga State that caused a lockdown at Southern Adventist University in Collegedale was a lapse in judgment, not a serious threat.

Attorney Lee Davis said, "Jimmy Gaines was enrolling in classes with Kesha Caldwell at Chattanooga State.  Jimmy was frustrated that his transcript was being held up at Southern Adventist University despite Jimmy having written a check to clear up a financial aid bill with the college.  When Kesha Caldwell told him that the enrollment deadline was near an end asked him whether he had done everything he could to get his transcript sent over from Southern Adventist University; he said, 'I have done everything I could except put a gun to their head.

'  This statement is a colloquialism.  It is an idiomatic expression that anyone who has ever dealt with a college bureaucracy or government agency can understand. It is not a threat against anyone and of course it was not a threat against Southern Adventist University.

"Perhaps it was stupid to say this, but this brief lapse of judgement was never intended as a threat to Southern Adventist University, Chattanooga State or anyone.  It was simply an unthinking expression made at the time to convey that Jimmy had exhausted every conceivable avenue to get his transcript to Chattanooga State.  There are far too many examples of violence in and around schools, and we all understand that any real threat needs to be fully investigated.  But we also know from experience that people say stupid things that sometimes can be misunderstood.  And that is what we have here, Lt. Robert Starnes of the Hamilton County Sheriff's Department misunderstood the frustrations of a young man trying to register for classes and because of that, Jimmy Gaines spent a night at the county jail and now is faced with a criminal charge.  We expect that a reviewing prosecutor will see this for what it is.

"The simple truth is that Jimmy was signing up for classes at Chatt State and was frustrated that Southern Adventist University has not released his transcript despite his having paid his bill. In frustration at their holding his transcript back, he made a stupid comment at Chattanooga State.  It was a joke and one that he immediately apologized for.  The clerk at Chatt State took it for a joke and reported it as such.

"How can we all know that this was not a serious threat?  Chatt State never locked down their campus and that was where Jimmy was at the time of the statement.  From there he went to the Taco Bell and then to work at the YMCA where he was arrested. He was taken to the Collegedale Police Department interrogated by local police, the Sheriff's department and the FBI. Despite his assurances that his short statement to Chatt State was a joke and again that he was terribly sorry, he was arrested and held overnight at the county jail. He was allowed to make bond the following day."



Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: ADAMS, JAMYRA DESHAE  3307 TAYLOR STREET CHATTANOOGA, 37406  Age at Arrest: 24 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County DOMESTIC ASSAULT --- ATCHLEY, GEORGE FRANKLIN  11127 OLD HOTWATER ROAD SODDY DAISY, 37379  Age at Arrest: 57 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County AGGRAVATED ... (click for more)

School Board Approves Hiring 2 Contract Drivers Who Failed To Disclose Prior Criminal Records

The County School Board voted Thursday night to hire two contract school bus drivers, though they failed to disclose past convictions. Karitsa Jones and Kathy Lennon abstained. Officials said one conviction was 19 years ago and the other 29 years back. Rhonda Thurman said some individuals honestly believe a conviction is off their record based on something they were told. ... (click for more)

September Is Prostate Cancer Awareness Month

The calendar fills up quickly in September as families return to a packed routine after quieter summer days. Unfortunately, your health might take a backseat to your busy schedule. So make a note on your calendar that September is Prostate Cancer Awareness Month, and remind yourself—or the men in your life—about the importance of a healthy prostate.   Prostate cancer is ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: I Am Very Privileged

A “California Kook” who teaches sociology at San Diego State told her students she would give each extra credit if they would participate in a “White Privilege Checklist” the other day. Understand, there is no pass or fail but, the more of the 20 statements you agree with, reveals you are “more guilty” of being white and therefore more “privileged” than those who are not. I had ... (click for more)

Unbeaten Baylor Rolls Past Cleveland For 30th win

The Baylor Lady Red Raiders have produced more than their share of outstanding volleyball teams in head coach Sarah Lail’s tenure, but this year’s team may be the best ever. There are no real superstars like in years past, but they have a talented group of young ladies who can beat you from any number of spots on the court. Facing one of its biggest tests of the season on ... (click for more)

Vols. UMass Matchup Pits 1998 National Champions

Tennessee takes on UMass on Saturday at Neyland Stadium. The game will feature a noon ET kickoff on SEC Network.     Tennessee (2-1) is coming off a 26-20 road loss to Florida on Sept. 16. Junior running back John Kelly set career highs with 141 rushing yards and 96 receiving yards and played a major role in the Vols' second half rally before the Gators ... (click for more)