Appeals Court Upholds $680,000 Verdict For Former City Police Officer, Plus $100,000 In Legal Bills Against City

Sunday, January 05, 2014

A federal appeals court has upheld a $680,000 verdict for former Chattanooga Police Officer Mikel Hoback.

The appeals court said, "The jury had a chance to hear Hoback's explanations for his disability requests and weigh his credibility accordingly, and the City has offered no reason to overturn the jury's decision. Because a panel opinion of this court would serve no jurisprudential purpose, we adopt the reasoning of the district court and affirm on the basis of its opinion in all other respects." 

The city has also been ordered to pay almost $100,000 to his attorneys, Phil and David Lawrence and Mike Richardson. David Lawrence filed for $2,065, Phil Lawrence for $70,938 and Mike Richardson for $26,964. The total attorney fee award was $99,967.

The suit was filed in  2010 and tried in 2011.

It says Mr. Hoback returned to the city police department after combat service in Iraq from 2004-2005. It says he suffered from Post Traumatic Stress Syndrome, but had no limitations on his police service.

However, after then-Chief Freeman Cooper would no longer allow him to serve after learning that he had a "mental disorder," the suit said.

The complaint said a VA physician had ordered him involuntarily committed, saying he had suicidal tendencies. It was claimed that the physician misunderstood his condition and that he had only gone in concerning an issue about his medication for PTSS.   


Chattanooga Railroad Series: Chickamauga And Durham Railroad (To Wallaceville)

A railroad once ran from Chickamauga, Ga., to a coal mining community called Durham on Lookout Mountain. The building of a railroad across a series of hills to the foot of the mountain and then ascending the mountain itself was a prodigious task. It was accomplished using convicts supplied by the state, who were armed only with picks, hammers and spikes, and blasting powder. ... (click for more)

Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report - And Mug Shots

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: BALLARD, RODNEY EDWARD     3407 MYRA AVENUE CHATTANOOGA, 37412     49     East Ridge          DOMESTIC AGGRAVATED ASSAULT BETHUNE, RICHARD GUINN     137 WINDY LANE MENLO, 30731     51     Chattanooga ... (click for more)

When The City Was Silent - And Response

I don't know how to say this without getting my head handed back to me on a platter as is often the usual case. But at least I no longer receive the hateful (even threatening) emails and insults I became accustomed to. So I'll just bite and say it: I honestly don't see anything expressed by the NSM that hasn't been said locally on some level at one time or another, and ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: VW-UAW Fiasco Begins

One pundit who is awaiting the opening volleys of “The Volkswagen Hearings” is calling today’s start of the labor union fiasco at the Hamilton County Courthouse as fascism at its finest. That’s what you call it, he wrote in a fiery way, when the union, the employer and the president of the United States all line up on the same side. “And this push to eviscerate the legal rights ... (click for more)

Injury Ends Playing Career Of Bradley Central's Chelsie Summars

Bradley Central girls basketball star Chelsie Summars, who underwent two serious operations on her right knee that wiped out her sophomore season, has suffered a third injury that will end her playing career, Bearettes coach Jason Reuter said via text. Summars, who helped the Bearettes win district, region and sectional titles en route to the 2013-14 Class AAA state tournament, ... (click for more)

Lenoir, Kelly Sisters Of Milligan College Earn All-AAC Tennis Honors

Three former Arts & Sciences tennis players have been named to the 2014 Appalachian Athletic Conference All-Conference squad. Jackson Lenoir, Ahmee Kelly and Kayla Kelly, who attend Milligan College, were selected to the men’s and women’s all-conference teams. Lenoir, now a sophomore, helped Milligan win the 2013 league championship and reach the 2014 semifinals. The ... (click for more)