Jody Baker: Studies In The Literature Of Sherlock Holmes

Friday, February 7, 2014 - by Jody Baker

Ronald Knox (1888-1957) was a 23 year-old student at Oxford  when he issued a "paper," from which he later gave a lecture, entitled "Studies in the Literature of Sherlock Holmes." It was not Rev.. Knox's intent to launch an intellectual game for the lovers of the Sherlock Holmes tales. The intended purpose was to use the discussion of Sherlock Holmes tales to ridicule some practices among those who were dedicated to "Higher Learning." Knox began his work with this introduction:

"If there is anything pleasant in life, it is doing what we aren't meant to do.  If there is anything pleasant in criticism, it is finding out what we aren't meant to find out.  It is the method by which we treat as significant what the author did not mean to be significant, by which we single out as essential what the author regarded as incidental.  Thus, if one brings out a book on turnips, the modern scholar tries to discover from it whether the author was on good terms with his wife;  if a poet writes on buttercups, every word he says may be used as evidence against him at an inquest of his views on a future existence.  On this fascinating principle, we delight to extort economic evidence from Aristophanes, because Aristophanes knew nothing of economics: we try to extract cryptograms from Shakespeare, because we are inwardly certain that Shakespeare never put them there: we sift and winnow the Gospel of St. Luke, in order to produce a Synoptic problem, because St. Luke, poor man, never knew the Synoptic problem to exist.

"There is, however, a special fascination in applying this method to Sherlock Holmes, because it is, in a sense, Holmes's own method.  'It has long been an axiom of mine,' he says, 'that the little things are infinitely the most important.'  It might be the motto of his life's work. And it is, is it not, as we clergymen say, by the little things, the apparently unimportant things, that we judge of a man's character." 

For a full text of this lecture visit

Sidney Roberts (Cambridge) issued a reply some years following. Then several other essays and booklets followed. But it was in 1934 that Christopher Morley, aided by three-hour lunches lubricated by liquid refreshment, engaged the attention of the literary elite of New York and set the game afoot.  Punctuated by Morley's   *joi de vivre*,  the Grand Game grew and grew and grew into the giant attraction that it is today.

There are two major Societies: (1) The Baker Street Irregulars based here and (2) The Sherlock Holmes Society of London founded in 1951 on the other side of the Big Pond. There are two major encyclopedic annotated works: Baring-Gould's two-volume set and Klinger's multi-volume set. There are the major journals - Baker Street Journal and Sherlock Holmes Journal.

In the Sherlock Holmes Journal (Summer, 2011 ) an article was published which challenges the part that that tradition assigns to Knox's lecture in the birth and growth of the Grand Game. That article, The Ronald Knox Myth, acknowledges that Morley was in Oxford at the time of the lecture, but questions whether Morley heard the lecture or returned home with a copy of it. That author goes on to point out that: "Knox was not the first to peer beneath the surface of the Sherlock Holmes stories. Two other scholars had done so a decade earlier, Arthur Bartlett Maurice in The Bookman in America and Frank Sidgwick in The Cambridge Review in England, in January 1902 .... Sidgwick's was a one-time query about inconsistencies in Hound, but Maurice went on writing about the tales in his periodical for 25 years."

The author of the Journal article seeks to support the claim that Morley did not attend the Knox lecture by bringing forward negative proof: 

"As for Morley bringing Knox's paper to America, we don't even know if Morley heard it while at Oxford as a Rhodes Scholar in 1911. No diaries or appointment books of Morley's for 1911-12 exist, and no contemporary letters of his indicate that he did. And on the sole occasion that he referred to it as having been given at Oxford while he was there, in his 1944 book Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson: A Textbook of Friendship, Morley did not actually say he heard it. If you look up and not only see but observe the reference, one finds the BSI's founder indefinite on that point."

The author of the article has apparently overlooked or disregarded the admonition that: "Absence of proof is not proof of absence." 

So, what if accepted tradition is wrong? What if Morley did not attend the lecture? What if Morley did not bring a paper copy of the lecture with him when he returned home?  SO WHAT?

For years Morley was deeply interested in Sherlock Holmes. Morley was interested in playing the same games that formed the basis of Knox's lecture. A copy of Knox's lecture would have been  available to Morley, an editor at Doubleday.  The probability approaches certainty that Ronald Knox and the thoughts expressed in Knox's paper and repeated in his lecture had a strong and lasting influence upon the formation of The Baker Street Irregulars. If the thrust of the lecture was not the source, it was an influencing factor in the attitude and the atmosphere of the fun, frolic and frivolity with which the meetings were conducted. Little value was assigned by the BSI of the time to deep, ponderous and pedantic scholarship. The BSI followed in the footsteps of Studies in the Literature of Sherlock Holmes.


There are books, upon books and more books. There are writings upon writings and more writings. There have been radio broadcasts over the years. Louis Hector (1934-1936); Orson Welles (1936); Basil Rathbone (1939-1946); Tom Conway (1946-1947); John Stanley (1947-1949); Ben Wright (1950); and John Gielgud (1955) See :

Movies galore: A 1900 silent film; then Alwin Neuß (1908-1914); William Gillette as Sherlock Holmes (1916): Hugo Flink (1917); John Barrymoore, as Sherlock Holmes with William Powell (debut) and Hedda Hopper (1922); Eille Norwood (1921-23); Carlyle Blackwell (1929); Raymond Massey (1931) [For more detail see: of_actors_who_have_played_Sherlock_Holmes and see:

And, more recently Basil Rathbone, of course - and Arthur Wotner ; Peter Cushing; Ronald Howard; and Jeremy Brett.

Newcomers to the movie scene are Benedict Cumberbatch (in Sherlock), Johnny Lee Miller (in Elementary) and Robert Downey, Jr. (in Sherlock Holmes). The very latest seems to be a Sherlock app (whatever, in thunder, that is). See

Little did Ronald Knox and Christopher Morley know what they were setting loose upon the world. It began as a literary trickle, grew to a stream and cascaded to a torrent --- and now a flood of Sherlockiana throughout the world. 

Inspector Baynes

(Jody Baker is a Chattanooga attorney, who specializes in Sherlock Holmes lore. He can be reached at

Climate Change Or Change The Climate

Is it "Climate Change", or "Change the Climate"?  We are being told that we can change the climate. If so, let's all really believe, close our eyes very tightly, click our heels together and from now until eternity, it will be sunny and seventy-five degrees.  Bob Bogart (click for more)

Thankful For Earl Freudenberg

This is certainly a red letter week for Chattanooga's best supporters.  My long time friend Earl Freudenberg was elected to the Tennessee Radio Hall of Fame.  It is an honor he well deserves.  After writing a letter in support of recognition for Bob Elmore's contributions to making Chattanooga great, I read where Earl was selected for this notable honor.  I ... (click for more)

Larry Schumacher Named Chief Executive Officer Of CHI Memorial

The board of directors of CHI Memorial and Catholic Health Initiatives (CHI) have chosen Larry Schumacher as the chief executive officer (CEO) of CHI Memorial effective Jan. 4, 2016 . Mr. Schumacher comes to CHI Memorial from Hospital Sisters Health System (HSHS) based in Springfield, Illinois where he served as system chief operating officer for the past eight years.  ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Under Flood Watch Through Wednesday

With a steady rain set to continue through Wednesday, Chattanooga is under a flood watch. Over four inches of rain are expected in some areas. Here is the advisory from the National Weather Service: ...LOCALIZED FLOODING POSSIBLE ACROSS EAST TENNESSEE AND SOUTHWEST VIRGINIA THROUGH WEDNESDAY MORNING... .THE COMBINATION OF DEEP SUBTROPICAL MOISTURE AND A SLOW MOVING FRONTAL ... (click for more)

No 1 Connecticut Overwhelms Lady Mocs, 79-31

At least 6,104 basketball enthusiasts got to see what the best women’s college basketball team in the country looks like Monday night at McKenzie Arena. The three-time defending national champion Connecticut Huskies won for the fourth time this season and 41 st game in a row with an impressive 79-31 victory over the Chattanooga Lady Mocs before the seventh-largest crowd in ... (click for more)

Mocs Fall 64-54 At ULM

The Chattanooga Mocs (5-2) five-game-in-10-day road show ended Monday night with a 64-54 loss at ULM (3-2). The squad shot a season-low 35.3 percent (18-51) in the loss. "I felt like we had good shots, especially in the first half,” coach Matt McCall said. “We were getting down the lane and guys were just flat out missing layups. Everyone for the most part was getting in the ... (click for more)