Roy Exum: The Canons Of Journalism

Monday, March 24, 2014 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

Certain members of the Chattanooga Times Free Press seem to have over-stepped the basic “canons of journalism” Thursday night when they played outside the established rules and later published the identities of several people who took part in a “call in” session in Chattanooga’s Violence Reduction Initiative. I can say that because, quite frankly, I’ve done it myself a time or two down through the years.

I have great respect for Alison Gerber and her editorial staff. She has some solid professionals who are good reporters and fine writers. When the newspaper doubled its daily price to a dollar the other day, I didn’t even blink because I don’t care what they charge; I’ll skip lunch before I go without the newspaper each day. And despite last week’s slip, I still trust what I read each day.

After all, it was the Times Free Press that introduced us to the desperately-needed initiative with a sterling eight-page section that was devoid of all advertising. It was a forceful and very needed voice in stopping the shooting and saving young people’s lives. If I dare say, it became the biggest factor that sold our community on the High Point method that will hopefully rid us of senseless shootings and the polarizing black-on-black crime now in our neighborhoods.

I suspect that because of the newspaper’s committed stance, its reporters were given “inside information” that wasn’t shared with other media outlets and last Thursday night, when some criminal types were called to a meeting where trust, reconciliation and possible redemption were paramount, the newspaper’s representatives sadly violated a common ethics principle known as the “limitation of harm” rule.

According to Wikipedia, “limitation of harm” is where a committed journalist may “withhold certain details from reports such as the names of minor children, crime victims' names or information not materially related to particular news reports release of which might, for example, harm someone's reputation.”

Imagine a woman who has been raped – the Times Free Press wouldn’t dare hold her up to public ridicule but will most certainly identify the alleged attacker. News reporters all over the country protected the kids who were abused by a (very few) Catholic priests and there are many other examples where mere decency has trumped total exposure in the media business that I can recall.

Consider this -- at Thursday’s call-in, there was not one crime committed, nor was there any arrest. Both sides made it clear there should be and would be anonymity but the newspaper’s editors erred by ordering the reporters to provide identities – and allowed them to be published – in a manner that very definitely flies in the very face of the “limitation of harm” rules that newspaper reporters have embraced for over 200 years.

According to the Society of Professional Journalists' Code of Ethics, there are eight areas of the Harm Limitation Principle that should be on display in every newsroom:

-- “Show compassion for those who may be affected adversely by news coverage. Use special sensitivity when dealing with children and inexperienced sources or subjects.

-- “Be sensitive when seeking or using interviews or photographs of those affected by tragedy or grief.

-- “Recognize that gathering and reporting information may cause harm or discomfort. Pursuit of the news is not a license for arrogance.

-- “Recognize that private people have a greater right to control information about themselves than do public officials and others who seek power, influence or attention. Only an overriding public need can justify intrusion into anyone's privacy.

-- “Show good taste. Avoid pandering to lurid curiosity.

-- “Be cautious about identifying juvenile suspects or victims of sex crimes.

-- “Be judicious about naming criminal suspects before the formal filing of charges.

-- “Balance a criminal suspect's fair trial rights with the public's right to be informed.”

* * *

Do any of those sound like they might fit? Again, the 13 people who were summoned to the non-threatening Olivet Baptist Church were not arrested or detained. A mighty effort to ask their help in confronting bloodshed most certainly should overcome “lurid curiosity” and the only “overriding public need” was reflected in the faces of those who vow to help change the lives of those they stood beside to share pizza and concern.

The newspaper’s Gerber loyally defended her actions, stating that “to rely on the mayor’s office and report only (its message) would be poor journalism,” but Alison is known and respected among her peers as being thoughtful and fair. It is believed, without pale, that she embraces the part of the creed that demands, “Professional integrity is the cornerstone of a journalist's credibility.”

So what happens now? Andy Berke and his Violence Reduction Initiative crowd have been stung indeed by this unexpected turn but nobody predicted this would be easy. We all know any path to success will most definitely be a rocky one and there will be disappointment on both sides. Yet the first step in reconciliation is, according to the High Point model, forgiveness.

Paul Smith, the mayor’s noble “superintendent,” needs to bear an olive branch and go before the newspaper editors because the most important cog in the VRI is working together. The newspaper editors, facing harsh disdain, need to promise they will take their own gunslingers out of the equation. Yes, report the news fully and factually but do so with integrity. That is all any of newspaper critics ask.

Most importantly, let’s move on. Both the Mayor’s office and the newspaper’s leaders know we have a real chance at something special.

royexum@aol.com



Who Does Chattanooga Belong To, Anyway?

Last week I read two opinions that were based on good premises, but still contained irritating statements.  Under the title Downtown Needs Cleaned Up (August 24, 2016) was the argument, "Why invite tourists to come visit Chattanooga when our streets are a stinking bio-hazard?"  And a second to the motion, "Make downtown look good for the tourists."  Another ... (click for more)

Jonathan Welch Is To Be Commended For His Leadership On The School Board

Dr. Jonathan Welch has faithfully served the Hamilton County Board of Education, representing District 2, for the last four years. He ends his time on the school board as chairman, a role he stewarded well during a tumultuous time in our school system as we prepared to search for a new superintendent.  Jonathan has served our school system and represented ... (click for more)

Residential Project At 1st And Cherry To Finish Out Units On Hill Above Market Street

More residential units are planned downtown near the riverfront on a steep lot at First and Cherry streets. The River City Company is currently seeking requests for proposals from developers for the steep 95-foot-by-65-foot lot behind the First and Market condos. River City officials said, "We are excited about how this parcel will put a finishing touch on this well established ... (click for more)

TBI Adds Jereme Little To Top 10 Most Wanted; Was Set Free By Judge Stern And Then Higher Court Overruled Her

The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation has added to its ‘Top 10 Most Wanted’ list Jereme Dannuel Little, who was freed by order of Criminal Court Judge Rebecca Stern, whose decision was recently reversed. Little is wanted by the Chattanooga Police Department and the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation for especially aggravated kidnapping. The TBI said, "Little has a history of ... (click for more)

Potent Baylor Continues Unbeaten Volleyball Onslaught

(Story will be updated) Another one bites the dust. Baylor’s Lady Red Raiders knocked off visiting East Hamilton, 3-0, on Monday and extended their season-opening winning streak to 15 consecutive matches. Coach Sarah Lail’s squad blistered the Lady Hurricanes by set scores of 25-10, 25-8, 25-14. “It’s definitely a great feeling,” Lail said of the impressive winning ... (click for more)

Mocs Volleyball Sweeps Chattanooga Classic

The Chattanooga Mocs volleyball team completed their fourth 3-0 sweep of the weekend on Sunday afternoon against California State at Fullerton as part of the Chattanooga Classic – presented by Hampton Inn & Suites - held in Maclellan Gym. The Mocs came out swinging by winning the first set 25-11 and then went on to win 25-18 and 25-17 in sets two and three, respectively. ... (click for more)