Man Accused Of Attacking Woman With A Rock Found Guilty

Wednesday, March 5, 2014 - by Hollie Webb

A Chattanooga man accused of attacking a woman with a rock in order to steal her purse was found guilty of aggravated robbery after a two-day trial.

According to Prosecutor Jason Demastus, Amy Andrews was walking from her home on 18th Street to her car in the driveway when Alfonzo Rounsaville struck her on the head with a large rock back in November 2012. 

Attorney Demastus said to the jury, "Reeling from the strike, she finds the defendant in her driveway attempting to steal her purse."

Ms. Andrews testified that she was hit multiple times after that. She said she lost her balance after the first hit and finally yelled for the man to take the purse; he grabbed it and ran away. 

After this, she said a neighbor saw their struggle and ran to help her. The neighbor then called 911 and waited with Ms. Andrews until police arrived. The 911 tape was played for the jury.

Another neighbor saw a man running through the area while carrying a purse and alerted authorities. 

Because Ms. Andrews' phone was in the stolen purse, she was able to use an app on her iPad called "Find my iPhone" to GPS locate the bag. Approximately 20 minutes after the incident, police apprehended Rounsaville.

Police showed a photo ID of Rounsaville to the victim to ask if it was the same man. Attorney Dupree pointed out that Ms. Andrews did not identify the defendant in person immediately after the attack. 

He told the jury, "Please don't confuse what you hear the state wants to prove with what you hear on the witness stand."

He said Rounsaville lived near 18th Street and therefore had a reason to be walking around the area. He said Rounsaville had been misidentified on a racial basis. However, Ms. Andrews was adamant the man sitting in court was the same man who struck her. 

Ms. Andrews also told the jury that after the attack, she had gone to an ENT doctor as well as an eye doctor. She said she began to have what her doctor called "floaters" in her field of vision after the incident. Her doctor told her it was because of the impact trauma.

Attorney Dupree disagreed and said floaters were a common problem, saying that even he had them. He asked Ms. Andrews where his came from since he had not had any head trauma. 

Now that Rounsaville has been convicted, a sentencing hearing will be held in the near future.


Garage Destroyed By Fire In Harrison Area Monday Morning

Fire destroyed a garage in the Harrison area Monday morning. An off-duty Hamilton County Sheriff’s officer called dispatch a t  8:45 a.m. ,  reporting a garage fire at 6435 Hunter Road.  The Highway 58 Volunteer Fire Department responded reported heavy fire pouring out from the back of the extended garage and through the roof. Firefighters worked quickly ... (click for more)

Jered Shoemate, 33, Arrested During Superbowl Weekend RIID Saturation

While working the Superbowl Weekend RIID Saturation on Sunday night, Hamilton County Sheriff's Office deputies observed a Nissan Maxima driving near the 2800 block of McCallie Avenue after which it proceeded to enter the Brainerd Tunnel the wrong way. Deputies immediately tried to stop the vehicle. The driver did not comply and a pursuit ensued, which continued down Brainerd Road ... (click for more)

The City Failed To Watch The Chattanooga History Museum Dollars - And Response

The tell tale signs of the History Museum's folly have been evident for years. When I was a former member of City Council I interviewed Dr. Daryl Black, Ph.D. to determine if I should argue for or against the annual funding of his organization. His interview, the multi-year history of administrative non-performance (despite consistent repetitive funding), and a review of the organizational ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Greenholtz: A No-Brainer

I am going to make this as simple as I possibly can. There are three fine lawyers now running for Criminal Court Judge and anywhere you go there will be people who like and admire Tom Greenholtz, Boyd Patterson and Mike Little. But when we select a judge, it should never be based on popularity. That’s why Gov. Haslam picked Greenholtz over both Little and Patterson this summer to ... (click for more)

Red Bank Beats Pigeon Forge For A-AA State Duals Title

FRANKLIN, Tenn. – The Red Bank Lions finally reached the mountain top as far as high school wrestling is concerned. The Lions had finished second to Bradley in the State Duals back in 1995 and it had been 16 years since the Lions had been involved, but they put an exclamation point on a strong dual-meet season by winning the Class A-AA title here at Williamson County Agricultural ... (click for more)

Bradley Whips Soddy Daisy For AAA State Duals Title

FRANKLIN, Tenn. – The Bradley Bears have won more state duals titles than anyone and they added another one after going four years without being in the championship round. It’s been a remarkable season for the Bears, who beat region-rival Soddy Daisy by a 52-21 margin for their latest state title. Saturday night’s   match was never really close as the Bears had a ... (click for more)