Mr. Smartt Is Late To The Dance - And Response (3)

Saturday, April 12, 2014

I keep reading articles, every couple of days, by followers of Mr.  Phil Smartt that parrot what seems to be “facts” as he has relayed them.  Poking your finger in Sabrena’s face at a debate and declaring “you lost,  I won” is not only beneath the dignity of a debate between candidates, but reflects desperation by a man that keeps saying “annexation is a dead issue.”   

Boy, you sure spend a lot of time talking about an issue that is “dead," Mr. Smartt.  Sabrena Turner has carried herself quite well in each debate on issues of better and more schools, to a focus on roads, police protection, concerns for our seniors, and a closer and more frequent involvement between the school board and the county commission.  Annexation?  Seems Mr. Smartt is more focused on “tooting” his own horn than anyone else.  

Now let's see, Mr. Smartt claims to have “stopped annexation in its tracks” with his letter to Mayor Littlefield.  Actually Mayor Littlefield declared in August 2009, and again on Dec. 14, 2009 that “ceding the sewers would not in any way bear on his decision to annex areas of the county within the Urban Growth Plan.” The WWTA Boards decision (not just Mr. Smartt) to cede the county areas effected by annexation threats took place on Dec. 16, 2009, and Mr. Smartt's “poison pill” declaration letter to the mayor is dated Dec. 17, 2009. Two days “after the mayor’s letter refuting claims of how the sewers would “stop the annexations,” and almost four months after the 12 HCRAA lawsuits in August did in fact stop the annexation effort.  Mr. Smartt has discovered his timeline mistake, and just this week writes that he stopped the annexations in August, not December, as he has always claimed,  (How convenient, since the HCRAA actions occurred that month for sure.  

Mr Perkins is hiding in the weeds with scarcely a “peep” about annexation, except to have called it a “silly issue” at the first debate. No wonder, Mr. Perkins told Councilman McGary at the City Council meeting on May 10, 2011 that he would support the City Council when they came to annex Apison.  Chattanooga’s newspaper has time and time again recorded statements by city officials that the “annexations were stopped by the lawsuits," not the so called “threat of ceding sewers.”  

Thanks to everyone who got involved in stopping the tyranny of forced annexation, especially Mike Carter and Bo Watson for their bills in Nashville that will have ended this threat forever, as soon as the governor signs the bill.  Enough of the attacks on Sabrena. Each debate has shown her to be an informed, mature, and passionate advocate of everyone in District 7. 

Trust, check these true timelines and discover for yourself that Sabrena is worthy of your trust and support on May 6.

Bill Reesor

District 7 Resident

* * *

This latest article by Mr. Reesor is too much.  The individual who was shouting “liar” at the East Hamilton debate is now lecturing us on “dignity” and civility.  The only thing factual in his piece is the statement that annexation is a “dead issue.”  Again, thanks to Mike Carter (who worked extensively with Phil Smartt as the WWTA attorney).  

Which begs the question why hasn’t Ms. Turner removed the “ONLY candidate that fought annexation” signs around the district?  She’s wrong on that claim, but more importantly wrong on other pressing issues.

 So let’s do as Mr. Reesor suggests and look at one of the key issues in District 7 - education.  So which candidate is more qualified to address educational concerns of the district?  Phil Smartt or Ms. Turner?  Mr. Smartt served six years on the Board of Education and worked hand in hand with administrators, principals, teachers and parents.  He and his wife Gloria sent all six of their children to public schools and currently have grandchildren attending East Hamilton High School and Westview Elementary.  In addition to time spent on the School Board, he and his wife spent countless hours volunteering, mentoring, and supporting teachers.

 In contrast, Sabrena Turner has no experience working with the Board of Education, other commissioners, principals, teachers, etc.  I don’t doubt her passion and enthusiasm for education in the District.  However, when a political candidate touting public education sends their children to private school, that should raise some eyebrows of voters.  As Mr. Perkins recently pointed out, if your going to “talk the talk” on public school education, you should certainly “walk the walk.”
With 60 percent of the county budget going towards education, we need someone with knowledge and experience.  The choice is easy on education.

Jim Ward
Resident - District 7 

* * *

Perry Perkins published his position against forced annexation on February 6, 2014 here:
http://www.chattanoogan.com/2014/2/6/269077/District-7-County-Commission-Candidate.aspx 

Here are the official minutes of the May 10, 2011 Chattanooga City Council Meeting in which Perry joked about Apison being annexed after a tornado hit his home (with my emphasis): 

"Perry Perkins of 11816 Country Estates Drive, Apison, Tennessee came forward to thank everyone for all the city of Chattanooga has done for them in Apison.  He stated they got hit by the tornado that came through their street and he has neighbors who have lost their homes.  He stated when he looked up and saw Chattanooga police officers driving down their street he thought the mayor had annexed them while the power was out.  He stated luckily that did not happen.  He stated the sheriff has done an outstanding job and will address the County Commission about this on Thursday." 

The full document is found here: http://www.chattanooga.gov/city-council/agendasminutes-by-date/9-city-council/829-minutes-2011

We admire the energy Mr. Reesor has for this primary race and are assured that these oversights were unintentional.  

Dr. Thaddeus Oliver
Manager, Perry Perkins Campaign 

* * * 

Thank you, Dr. Oliver, for verifying Perkins flip flop on the issue of property rights.  Were you counting on people not reading the entire section at this council meeting? 

I think his final statement shows his indifference to the issue. http://www.chattanooga.gov/city-council/agendasminutes-by-date/9-city-council/829-minutes-2011 

"Councilman McGary stated hopefully when we get ready to annex Apison Mr. Perkins will be ready to take us in and will sing our praises. Mr. Perkins responded 'I will.'" 

That doesn't sound like a lot of opposition to me. 

Annexation by ordinance might be a dead issue now but it shows the distrust that people have for overstepping government.  We need candidates whose values do not change when its convenient for their personal gain. 

Thomas Sohgud


Stop Insulting City Residents - And Response

Recently the members of the Hamilton County School Board, Hamilton County commissioners, school administrators and the county mayor met to discuss school funding. According to media reports, one elected official told the group that the cities do not help fund schools. It’s difficult to understand why that comment was made. Cities are made of citizens who pay property taxes twice. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Geno: Our ‘Me’ Culture

By almost every measure, Geno Auriemma is the best basketball coach in America. His University of Connecticut women are riding a record 109-game winning streak that dates to Nov. 17, 2016. Stanford barely beat them in overtime 3 years ago, but, before that, they won 41 straight. That means UConn is 153-1 and, in the current 109 streak, they have double-figure wins over the opponents ... (click for more)

2 Shot On Rawlings Street Friday Night; 1 In Critical Condition

Two people were shot, Friday night, and one is in critical condition. At approximately  9:56 p.m.  Chattanooga Police officers responded to the 2000 block of Rawlings Street on a report of a person shot. Officers arrived on scene and located one victim lying next to a vehicle suffering from a gunshot wound. A second victim arrived at a local hospital suffering from ... (click for more)

Car Crashes Into Motel 6 In Dalton; Driver, 17, Admits To Texting While Driving

The Dalton Police Department and Dalton Fire Department responded Saturday morning to a crash at the Motel 6 at Highway 41 and Tibbs Road. The driver of the 2005 Pontiac Grand Prix involved left the roadway and crashed into the Motel 6 building causing severe damage to one of the rooms. There were no major injuries. Investigators believe texting while driving was a contributing ... (click for more)

South Pittsburg Wins Lookout Valley Invitational

The South Pittsburg Lady Pirates are playing pretty good softball these days and they rewarded themselves by winning the Lookout Valley Invitational Saturday afternoon at Lookout Valley Elementary’s O’Mary-Conard Field. The Lady Pirates won their pool with wins over Grundy County and CSAS on Thursday and Friday before beating Covenant Christian in the second semifinal Saturday ... (click for more)

Bradley Wins Twice In Ooltewah Invitational Baseball

Bradley Central posted two wins Saturday in the Ooltewah Invitational. The Bears (9-2) beat Murfreesboro Central Magnet 10-9 in a six-inning game at the Toby McKenzie Baseball Complex. Later, Bradley defeated Bearden 3-1 in a contest that saw all the scoring come in the first inning. In the first game, Bradley put together three consecutive doubles that produced four of ... (click for more)