Federal Judge May Give Madame 2nd Chance

Wednesday, April 16, 2014 - by Hollie Webb

In the case of a Union City, Tn.,  woman who pleaded guilty to interstate transport of an individual for the purpose of prostitution, Federal Judge Sandy Mattice decided to delay her sentence for six weeks to see if she had changed her life.

This came after defense attorney Myrlene Marsa argued that Tatiana Valencia Wallace had not been involved in coercion of any form. She argued her client had not been any kind of "leader" at all.

Attorney Marsa said the defendant's role was more like that of a broker working with independent contractors.

She said her client never forced anything, but instead set up meetings for individuals who contacted her first. She said any woman involved in prostitution set up through Ms. Wallace "had the right to turn work down."

Ms. Wallace was arrested in a sting operation conducted by Chattanooga Detective Zach Fuller. Her business name was advertised in multiple states as "Dreamgirl Companions."

However, prosecutor Jay Woods said, "The fact of the matter is the defendant recruited, advertised, and provided services that without her would not have taken place."

Attorney Marsa said her client offered an opportunity but did not manage or supervise. She said the defendant had previously been a part of an escort service that had been more forceful and had wanted to get away. She said, "She wanted to offer people a way to do this if they were going to do this that was humane and not coercive."

Judge Mattice said, "I find that Ms. Wallace was at least an organizer in this."

However, he said, "The term human trafficking, to me, implies some element of coercion. I don't think that's what Ms. Wallace was doing."

Prosecutor Woods told the court, "All kinds of crime follows prostitution," saying the defense was trying to minimize the defendant's role.

Judge Mattice said, "There are a lot of people out there who believe prostitution should be legalized. Just like some people believe marijuana should be legalized." He gave the example of Nevada, a state that has legalized prostitution.

He continued, "If it is coercive, then the protection of the public plays a big role. But if there's not coercion involved, I don't know that there's anything to protect the public from. It's a voluntary transaction between two consenting adults."

Attorney Marsa told the court that since the defendant has been on probation, she has been working two legal jobs as well as making plans to complete her degree. She also said Ms. Wallace complied with police, even providing extra information.

She said, "She's done everything in her power to cooperate."

Judge Mattice decided to revisit the case in six weeks after getting information from the defendant's probation officer. He said, "Maybe it can become a home confinement if I can become satisfied that she has in fact turned her life around."

 However, he warned her, "You are now on law enforcement's radar screen, you are not realistically going to be able to go back into this business."

 

 


Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report - And Mug Shots

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: ALLEN, NATASHA A     4238 CRESTVIEW APT B RED BANK, 37415     32     East Ridge          DOMESTIC ASSAULT BAGGETT, ROBERT NATHANIEL     9136 OLD HIXSON PIKE SODDY DAISY, 37379     34     Hamilton ... (click for more)

Christopher Harp Arrested For Stealing Fuel From Hamilton County Gas Pumps

The Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office, with the cooperation of the leadership of the Sequoyah Volunteer Fire Department/Marine Rescue has been investigating fuel expense overages related to fuel obtained from the Hamilton County Government gas pumps.  The investigation determined on Aug. 2, Christopher M. Harp, who is a former member of the Sequoyah Volunteer Fire Department/Marine ... (click for more)

Black Creek TIF Decision-Who Guards The Hen House? - And Response

Citizens of Chattanooga were invited to give public comment before their own Industrial Development Board Aug. 15. They arrived to find foxes guarding their hen house.  Many thought the meeting was their opportunity to seek redress in the ill-conceived Black Creek Tax Increment Financing plan. However, they learned it was a sham orchestrated by both the past and present ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Let’s ‘Pay It Forward’

At 7 a.m. on Wednesday morning, this at a Starbucks coffee store located at 2186 Tyrone Blvd. in St. Petersburg, Fla.,  an unidentified woman who was first in line at the drive-through window, politely told the drive-through window clerk she would like to “pay it forward.” The clerk checked the next order – it was a caramel macchiato – and the first customer paid for both her ... (click for more)

McCallie Blanks Cleveland 44-0 In Season Opener

Ralph Potter has probably never been happier to get an ice-water bath following a football win than he was Thursday night at Finley Stadium. With McCallie hosting Cleveland in the season-opener for both teams, what had been billed as a close game between two pretty good teams turned into a romp as the Blue Tornado put 22 points on the board in both halves en route to a 44-0 victory. ... (click for more)

McCallie's 97-Yard Drive Proof Of Dominant 44-0 Win In Opener

With the game in hand, McCallie’s offense unleashed an impressive third-quarter drive that exemplified Cleveland’s inability to handle the Blue Tornado offense Thursday night at Finley Stadium. The Blue Raiders’ only real scoring threat ended at McCallie’s 3 on successive incomplete passes by quarterback Austin Massey to intended receivers Eric Goodwin and Rod Dennard. McCallie ... (click for more)