Warren Luetke Says He Never Saw Fishing Boat Before Collision That Killed 2 Men

Friday, May 16, 2014 - by Hollie Webb

As the criminally negligent homicide trial of Captain Warren Luetke continued into Friday afternoon, Luetke himself testified as a witness, saying, "The only possible explanation is that they were in the blind spot before I took control."

Luetke said that he never once saw the boat or its three passengers who were struck by his towboat, causing the drowning deaths of two men. 

Right before Luetke testified, defense attorney Sam Hudson made a motion for an acquittal.

 

Attorney Hudson said, "Even viewing the state's evidence at its strongest, they have only proven there was a blind spot...That is all they established is that there was a calculated blind spot at one point, and they thought that was improper." 

However, prosecutor Lance Pope said "Mr. Luetke's failure to observe those people in the navigable channel" was evidence of negligence. Judge Barry Steelman ruled to continue the trial and let the jury decide.

Prior to Luetke's testimony, his second-in-command at the time time of the incident was also called in as a witness.

Will Stevens, now the current captain of the Bearcat, said on that day, he saw people standing in a boat, pointing at men swimming in the water. 

He said, "I just got a bad feeling in my gut that something wasn't right." Mr. Stevens had been involved in a similar accident the year before. Luetke said during his testimony this made him very "cautious."

He said he warned Luetke, but he did not see any sign that there had been a collision. Mr. Stevens told the jury he also had not felt or heard anything to indicate a collision. When inspecting the front of the barges, he said he found a gas can. However, it was noted that this is not uncommon for barges. 

Attorney Hudson said, "Pushing barges down the river collects debris. You've found parts of docks. That doesn't mean you've hit a dock. You've found propane tanks. That doesn't mean you ran over somebody grilling."

He also noted that Mr. Stevens had been in control of the boat before the defendant's shift began. Attorney Hudson pointed out he also had not posted a supplementary lookout on the head of the boat. 

Attorney Hudson said, "You felt you were justified in serving as your own lookout down this particular stretch of the river."

He asked, "He exercised his duties in a professional manner based on your experience as a towboat captain, do you agree?" Mr. Stevens said yes. 

Several other witnesses were also called by the defense, including a friend of the fishing boat survivor David Christopher "Chris" Wilkey.

John Jones was a former coworker of Timothy Spidle, one of the crew members who drowned. Through Mr. Spidle, he met Chris Wilkey. He said, "Tim would come over and Chris would come with him." 

He said that Chris Wilkey did not drink but that he smoked marijuana nearly everyday. He called Mr. Wilkey a "pot head." He said on the day of the collision, Mr. Spidle had been drinking but did not seem intoxicated. However, he said Richard Wilkey was "drunk and passed out."

Another witness, Robert Christoffel, said he had worked on boats for over 30 years. He examined the fishing boat and said, "In my opinion the boat should never have been out on the water." 

He said he observed "lack of maintenance, corroded wires," saying, "I'm surprised the engine was even still running...With a good battery, the engine still would not run."

Closing arguments for the trial will start early Monday morning, after which the jury will start to deliberate.



Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: ALFARO, GUILLERMO ANTONIO  714 ELY RD HIXSON, 37343  Age at Arrest: 44 years old Arresting Agency: Tenn Highway Patrol DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE --- APPLEBETJR, PERCY  1706 BRADT ST CHATTANOOGA, 37406  Age at Arrest: 62 years old Arresting Agency: Chattanooga CRIMINAL TRESPASSING ... (click for more)

Copies Of Remaining Chattanooga Photo Books Available At Zarzour's Restaurant; By Mail

Remaining copies of the Chattanooga Photo books are available at Zarzours Restaurant on Rossville Avenue off Main Street. It is near Fire Hall #1. They include the Remarkable Stokes Collection, Railroads In and Around Chattanooga, and Paul Hiener's Historic Chattanooga.  All were published by Chattanoogan.com.  and printed by College Press at Collegedale. The ... (click for more)

The Growing Monopoly

Over the last decade, five tech giants have risen to the top, and created, discovered and invented services and products that have made these companies worth billions today. Those five, of course, are Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Microsoft, and Google. Each of these companies are responsible for several products and services that we use in our everyday lives. They have devoured the ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Those We All Ignore

I was in the midst of my “morning readings” the other day when a number leapt off my computer screen. Hark, heralded angels, did you know in the state of Iowa there are two (2) inpatient psychiatry beds for every 100,000 people? I’m not the best with percentages but there are some people in Iowa who aren’t getting the help they need. There are roughly 3.2 million people living in ... (click for more)

Stoker Beats Ensign At End To Win Wauhatchie

Rodney Stoker is hard to beat and it doesn’t matter if it’s on a road or a slick trail on the side of Lookout Mountain. The 41-year-old Stoker won the Sports Barn Turkey Trot 8K on Thanksgiving and he made his return to the 33 rd annual Wauhatchie Trail Run on Saturday a successful one as he caught 10-time winner Tim Ensign in the final quarter mile to win the challenging and ... (click for more)

Commerce Wins Bradley Invitational With Four Champs

CLEVELAND, Tenn. – The host Bradley Bears were the two-time defending champs in their own Bradley Invitational this weekend at Jim Smiddy Arena, but they weren’t able to make it a three-peat. The Commerce Tigers, a powerhouse Class A team from Georgia, had a slim three-point lead going into Saturday afternoon’s medal rounds, but after winning all four of their championship matches ... (click for more)