Roy Exum: We Need Gwen Tidwell

Tuesday, July 15, 2014 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

Of all the political races that will be decided in Hamilton County on Aug. 7, the one that concerns me most is the office of Criminal Court clerk. Two people who I consider as friends, incumbent Gwen Tidwell and challenger Vince Dean, are vying for votes in what is expected to be a tight race and, as is my custom whenever friends are involved, I hope both do well.

Technically that is impossible, of course, but allow me to let you in on another secret – there is no way this race should be close. When I remove friendship and admiration of both from the equation, it is easy to see that Gwen Tidwell is head-and-shoulders above any possible challenger – not just Vince – and she should be elected in a demonstrable landslide to begin her fifth consecutive term in office.

Her qualifications are a given and the fact she has a law degree and once was a practicing attorney assures such excellence. Hers is an administrative post – the clerk makes no policy – and a growing list of endorsements from over 75 trial lawyers who depend on her office every day is a well-deserved tribute. Her staff adores her – this from a co-worker whose name must be anonymous for obvious reasons – and a long list of ringing endorsements from politicians starting with former Deputy Governor Claude Ramsey can’t be ignored.

Her detractors point to some $50 million in uncollected court fees and jail costs but they never “finish the sentence.” It is true there is a huge amount that has not been collected but she can also show she has taken in – drum roll – over $70 million. Another truth is that Tidwell’s office has the highest collection percentage among criminal courts in the state – more than Nashville, Memphis and Knoxville. Let’s squelch that misperception right now

Don’t you see? The $50 million in uncollected fees is meant to be a political ruse. Everybody knows a repeat offender, one in and out of jail regularly, has no way of getting a job and paying court and jail fees. Gwen can garnish bank accounts, payroll, and prison commissary accounts but thank God she is the type of court clerk who will not decimate some guy’s total savings because it would accomplish little more than driving him back to crime. That’s what makes Gwen Tidwell such a joy.

Vince Dean neither has the experience nor the credentials that Gwen Tidwell has used over the past 20 years in office. His biggest asset is that he is a Republican in a super-majority state while Gwen is a Democrat. The antidote is that anyone who votes for a party rather than a person is making a profound mistake. Tidwell’s office is not political at all, instead offering a service. There will be some hard-line Republicans who will vote for Dean while hard-line Democrats will vote for Tidwell but wisest voters will ignore the party in every contest and instead pick the person best qualified.

There is no room to doubt that Gwen Tidwell is the best qualified of the two. Vince served as a policeman for 27 years before serving admirably in the state legislature. He is a nice guy who was a city councilman in East Ridge before retiring as the town mayor.

Vince is well-respected in the legislature but hardly has the background or the expertise to run the Criminal Court clerk’s office. This isn’t meant as criticism, not at all, but voters should be assured political party has nothing to do with the mammoth task of overseeing the Criminal and General Sessions Courts.

Some believe anyone running with a (D) behind their name is “doomed” in the conservative South but in Gwen Tidwell’s case it hardly stands for “dumb.” She is a great servant to the people and a great favorite at the Justice Building. If Hamilton County voters believe they should fix “something that isn’t broken,” I believe our local courts will suffer as a result. I have a list of about 80 lawyers who will readily agree.

Let’s keep Gwen Tidwell right where she belongs. We need people like her more than ever before.

royexum@aol.com



HCDE Shell Game

Being eighty one I have seen and participated in many things in my life. I remember the carnivals coming to town with their games and trying to win a prize. One of those games was the shell and pea game. The man would show the pea and seemingly placing it under a nut shell. He then would move the three shells around and when he stopped asked which shell the pea was under. Unless ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Best Speech This Year

Just 24 hours after Donovan Livingston gave The Student’s Speech at Harvard University’s Graduate School of Education convocation on Wednesday, it had been viewed over 3 million times and shared 75,000 times on Facebook. It is already considered, far and away, as the freshest view on race and education in ages and its viral journey is burning across the Internet. His talk was ... (click for more)

Child Bitten By Dog In Bradley County

The Bradley County Sheriff’s Office is investigating a child who was bitten by a dog. While saturating an area in Bradley County, a deputy observed a vehicle traveling on the roadway with a child not restrained and sitting in a passenger’s lap inside the vehicle. Once the deputy approached the vehicle, he noticed a child bleeding which was the result of a dog bite. ... (click for more)

Chicago Fire Wins Steinbrecher Cup 2-1 In Overtime

It took 120 minutes to decide who is the best US amatuer soccer team Saturday night at Finley Stadium as the Chattanooga Football Club took on the Chicago Fire of the PDL.   The Fire would score first but Chattanooga tied the match early in the second half.  Luke Winter scored the equalizer in the 47th minute off a Jon Finlay cross.   The game would remain tied ... (click for more)

Harrison Sparks Lookouts To 3-2 Win Over Smokies

For the second straight night Travis Harrison delivered in the clutch for the Chattanooga Lookouts. Tonight the third baseman drove in all three runs in the team's 3-2 win over the Tennessee Smokies before a crowd of 4,765 at AT&T Field. Harrison kicked off his night in the third inning with an RBI single to bring home Zack Granite who reached on a walk. Chattanooga ... (click for more)