VW Deals Done In The Dark

Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Another deal in the dark with our city and county government. It’s all fun in back rooms with fat cigars. 

A $52 million commitment to financially encumber the city and county taxpayers for decades did not materialize overnight.  Both the city and county governments have been in closed door negotiations with VW and bartered a deal in the dark. To keep the public out of the records, the Chattanooga Chamber of Commerce, who deems themselves not subject to open records, acts as the brokers of the deal for $1.2 million annually of tax dollars.  Everyone get some of the public cash from the deals in the back room.

Why do the citizens learn the details of a $52 million commitment of their money after the deal is done?  There should have been public hearings prior to making these commitments of taxpayer dollars. 

The Black Creek TIF for $9 million for the golf course road was also a deal in the dark. The public must be included. As the attorney said of the Black Creek TIF, "It's just us girls."   So, the girls are very busy these days.

Just when were government officials going to share how much they obligated us to financially?  A $52 million commitment did not just materialize. 

City residents have a right to participate in this decision, because we are rendered paying the city and county share of the bond issue payments, double.  The city currently has about half a billion in long and short term bond debt obligation, with the EPB bonds that are guarded by city of Chattanooga taxpayers, not the rate payers.   The public needs to be involved, these elected officials do not get a blank check.

The city claims that job growth has and will result in increased revenue for the city. 

A review of historic sales tax revenue for the city pre VW 2008 and prior, and post VW 2011 to present shows the only measurable increase in sales tax revenue is from ending the shared sales agreement with Hamilton County.  There are no spikes or any measurable indicators of a revenue spikes. Why?- because a large group of the employees do not reside in the city where the tax obligation to pay the bond issues is the most apparent. After all, city residents, pay county taxes. 

A review of city property tax revenue from 2008 to present, indicates that the only measurable increase in property tax revenue has occurred through annexation. 

It is the city residents that get the bad deal in the gifting of tax dollars to VW, we not only pay double for the bond issue payments with county taxes, but we are required to provide services to VW and their suppliers that are property tax exempt under PILOT incentives. So, the city residents will be required to provide police and fire protection, infrastructure with no additional revenue.  The fact is the windfall from gifting these rich corporation our dollars are just not materializing in the city revenue. 

The increases in city revenue are from the windfall from cutting Hamilton County out of a share of sales tax and city footprint growth through annexation. 

The gifting of our taxpayers to corporations places their tax burden on those that reside in Chattanooga, we fund their services with not additional revenue.  The working poor and middle class in Chattanooga are the hardest hit financially paying for services, bond issues for VW

The data speaks volumes to me that the notion of trickle down from the rich corporation to the people is not materializing.   

Enough time has elapsed to evaluate if the prior $40 million is returning to the city and county in revenue.  That is the conservation we should be having in the city.

We need to determine if our community should invest another $52 million. In other words, is the investment returning with interest, or trickling down in returned revenue to our city government. I cannot find it, so perhaps the city can show us where the cash return is.  Show us the cash.

Stop the deals in the dark, it’s not your money. 

April Eidson


An Alternative To Economic Development

If local and state politicians are truly interested in improving the lives of the poor they should take a look at the recent study by Steven Horwitz of the Mercatus Center at George Mason University. Breaking Down the Barriers:  Three Ways State and Local Governments Can Improve the Lives of the Poor.  The study takes a look at the regressive effects of occupational ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: My Garden In August 2015

Those in the know tell me the month of August is National Peach Month, so as I take a stroll through garden, I am paying particular attention to the poppy and the gladiolus because they are the “birth flowers" of this month. But as we dole out our months Orchids and Onions, let’s substitute a peach and a pit, that hard seed you find when you bite into a peach. A PEACH to the ... (click for more)

Abdulazeez Apparently Went Target Shooting In River Gorge Area Prior To Rampage That Killed 5

A 24-year-old Hixson man who went on a rampage and killed five military personnel at Chattanooga apparently went target shooting in the Tennessee River Gorge area just beforehand. A Chattanoogan said he was canoeing the day before the shooting and heard Mohammad Abdulazeez shooting in the woods in a remote area. The man, who said he thought he was being shot at, looked ... (click for more)

Columnist Says Navy To Bring Charges Against Commander Of Chattanooga Naval Center Who Fired At Shooter

The Navy plans to bring charges against Lt. Cmdr. Timothy White, who fired shots at a Hixson man who on July 16 rammed through a gate at the facility on Amnicola Highway and killed four Marines and a sailor, columnist Allen West wrote. He said he received a text message confirming the charges are imminent against the Chattanoogan, who is the father of six and who has acknowledged ... (click for more)

CFC Hosts Indiana, Officials Hoping For 9,999+

 The Chattanooga Football Club is set to host the NPSL national semifinal match Saturday night at Finley Stadium.  CFC will take on the Indiana Fire who won the Midwest Region championship.   The game is set to kickoff at 7:30 p.m. Saturday.   Last year, Chattanooga hosted Sacramento in a national semifinal game and drew more almost 9,000 fans.  Chattanooga ... (click for more)

Orange Grove's Gonzales Takes Gold In World Special Olympics

Debra Gonzales, a resident at Orange Grove Center, is a world champion. The cute 21-year-old, who moved to Chattanooga two years ago, took first place in the shot put at the 2015 Special Olympics World Games in Los Angeles after entering the event on a whim.  Debra’s winning throw of 4.49 meters bested a 4.30 heave by Darinka Pasapera of Peru while Grace Dindillo of Papua, ... (click for more)