Rhonda Thurman Shines Through Hit Piece

Tuesday, August 12, 2014 - by David Tulis

School board dissident Rhonda Thurman shines through a story in the Sunday editions of the Chattanooga Times Free Press that castigates her for representing her north county constituents. The commoners who are supporters of Mrs. Thurman are increasingly skeptical about bureaucracy and the blessings of costly factory schooling, and like her for not pussyfooting with special interests.

 

The story by Kevin Hardy, a writer at the newspaper for about four years, offers basic reporting about Mrs. Thurman. The newspaper is the city’s largest and still most influential media outlet, run by a printer and publisher with at least two newsrooms and a host of magazines and newsprint periodicals. Mr. Hardy’s 3,000-word feature presents Mrs. Thurman as a hard-working outsider on the school board who asks annoying questions and is so routinely dissatisfied she votes “No.” 

Mrs. Thurman lost a write-in campaign for county commission as she sought to fill the seat held by Fred Skillern, a conservative from Soddy-Daisy. She was defeated 1,731 to 3,448 votes. 

How a feature becomes a hit piece
The story is a queer bit of journalism. Mrs. Thurman is ignored during the runup to the balloting Aug. 7. Three days after the primary, Aug. 10, the big story about her appears. Perhaps the editors are being gracious, running a negative story after voting. But the paper saved its ink, declining to serve the public interest prior to the vote. Perhaps it feared that publication prior to the vote would have galvanized voters in her favor.

“NO RETREAT, NO SURRENDER[;] In Rhonda Thurman’s world, as in much of politics today, ideology is everything. Compromise is weakness.” These heads sit on a tiny grid of “nos” too small to read except for the discerning eye wearing reading glasses. The story suggests erroneously that voting “No” is an ideology, when really it isn’t. An ideology may cause a long string of tough questions and no votes, but that in itself is not one. Feminism, gay theory and Marxism are ideologies. They reshape one’s perception of the world and one’s actions according to an intellectual construct or premise; ideology is a form of manmade religion, each with doctrines of salvation, action and predestination. 

Notice, too, “Rhonda Thurman’s world” in the headline — the rest of us are in the real one. Mrs. Thurman is far from being an ideologue, but nonetheless has become, “arguably, one of the most notorious politicians in Hamilton County’s history. But she represents something larger, a political shift toward an America that increasingly embraces the politics of no.” Mrs. Thurman says she represents the taxpayers, but here she is notorious, “generally known and spoken of, usu. unfavorably,” according to Black’s law dictionary. Notorious describes someone who fled the country to avoid paying taxes or who murdered a lover with a maul. 

Bad word choice. Prejudicial. The accusation is sensational, and powerful enough to control how some readers absorb her acquaintance for the rest of the story. In numerous board 8-1 votes, Mrs. Thurman is the dissenter. When she asks questions, colleagues “roll their eyes.” Mrs. Thurman sometimes finds a “sympathizer” on the board, and the tally is 7-2. The “despised and idolized” political figure who helps run Allure beauty salon on Highway 58 is guilty of antics, we are told. She rants. As a former newspaper copy editor, I like colorful language — it helps make the story subject real and robust. But these words make Mrs. Thurman difficult to take seriously. They belittle. 

Presuppositions of the story are unspoken. A main one is the defense of the state-centered status quo through its schooling and student warehousing complex. The story sympathizes with the hidden parties upon whose toes Mrs. Thurman has trod. Her terms on the board offend the idea of bureaucratic and administrative perfection, hiding as it does the inner working of the “gigantic indoctrination and sorting machine” of public school. Public schools are wending their way toward dissolution and a public revolt; the story quietly supports their continued maintenance. No doubt, Mrs. Thurman shares in this idea, being loyal to Hamilton County schools. The story articulates this perspective by lamenting the loss of the spirit of compromise expected from conservatives. “America has traded compromise for stalemate, immoveable grandstanding. *** Political scientists bemoan the slow death of meeting at the middle *** [government is] becoming more polarized. *** She embodies obstruction instead of accomplishment. *** She became a thorn in the side of many administrators *** .” 

What redeems local paper?
The story provides explanation for Mrs. Thurman’s motives. She is “a fiscal hawk. A watchdog.  A no-nonsense conservative. And so long as she’s standing in the right place, she doesn’t mind standing alone.” Her bid for the county commission is described as a “rescue mission” to keep a conservative on the commission. 

The reporting in the newspaper is massaged to make Mrs. Thurman look like a primitive country person with a reactionary attitude and belligerent mien. The story is redeemed by Mrs. Thurman herself, who emerges in the details as a genuine character, a hard-working hairdresser and a nitpicker who reads piles of documents submitted to her by petitioners, contractors and policymakers. 

What makes the piece valuable for the reading public is that despite it being revised to give the perspective of the editors and progressive theory, it does not stifle the witness Mrs. Thurman makes of herself. 

Thurman works long days, and she hasn't taken a vacation in seven years. She's so busy she won't take on new customers.
This is all part of the Thurman persona, all part of the story she sells. The self-made woman forging a living on her feet with her hands, a politician too busy for shenanigans.
Over the years, salesmen and deliverymen have been surprised to find her here.
"You really are a hairdresser?" they ask.
"You think I lie?" Thurman responds.

What saves the hit piece is that the ordinary reader of good sense is able to see her apart from the faux packaging, the misleading ingredients list. The story’s judgment is harsh, but the facts of the case are before the jury, and the reader is the judge. 

Mrs. Thurman is a woman of Christian conviction and determination. She is taking fire from the largest media house in Chattanooga for her virtues, which are the defense of the ordinary taxpayer. In a day when men lack chests, she has one. Her thrift, temperance and common intelligence let her stand before the gaggle of favor seekers and service providers pursuing their livings on the public dole, and offer sales resistance.

— David Tulis hosts Nooganomics.com 1 to 3 p.m. weekdays at Hot News Talk Radio 910 1190 and 1240 AM, a show covering local economy and free markets in Chattanooga and beyond.

Sources: Kevin Hardy, ‘NO RETREAT, NO SURRENDER[;] In Rhonda Thurman’s world, as in much of politics today, ideology is everything. Compromise is weakness,” Chattanooga Times Free Press, Aug. 10, 2014
See John Taylor Gatto, Weapons of Mass Instruction[;] a Schoolteacher’s Journey Through the Dark World of Compulsory Schooling(Gabriola Island, BC, Canada: New Society Publishers, 2010), 2015 pp-


Randy Johnston Has The Necessary Experience And Leadership Skills

I worked in the Assessor's Office from 1974 until retiring in 2013. I served in a management position as director of Commercial and Industrial Property from 1980 until retiring. I essentially answered directly to the assessor during the last 33 years of my 39 year career in that office. I had over 42 years of experience in the appraisal business. Former Chief Deputy and Director ... (click for more)

To The Proponents Of Voucher Bill 1049

So you lucked out on two voucher opponents not being at the committee meeting.  Vouchers are a detriment to every school in Hamilton County and our great state, robbing the school systems of necessary dollars which are already underfunded thanks to lack of BEP funding. There are mandates coming down from the state that we cannot comply with because of that lack of state funding. ... (click for more)

Criminal Defense Attorneys Seek Chest X-Ray, Barrel As Evidence In 34-Year-Old Murder Case

In the 34-year-old unsolved murder case that recently spotlighted Billy Hawk as the prime suspect, criminal defense attorneys are seeking forensic proof, which does not change with time, to prove Hawk’s innocence. During Monday’s discovery motion, filed on behalf of the defense to obtain certain evidence, defense attorney Jim Logan requested the victim’s chest X-ray be submitted ... (click for more)

Brandon Bettis, 25, Arrested For Home Invasion; 2 Other Suspects Being Sought

Brandon Bettis, 25, was arrested after a home invasion early Monday morning, and two other suspects are being sought. Chattanooga Police responded to the 1100 block of Thomas Lane at 6:30 a.m. on the report of a home invasion robbery.  The suspects entered the home of the victims, James Shrum, 47, and Hillary Schooley, 25.   The victims were wakened and threatened ... (click for more)

Red Bank Beats Pigeon Forge For A-AA State Duals Title

FRANKLIN, Tenn. – The Red Bank Lions finally reached the mountain top as far as high school wrestling is concerned. The Lions had finished second to Bradley in the State Duals back in 1995 and it had been 16 years since the Lions had been involved, but they put an exclamation point on a strong dual-meet season by winning the Class A-AA title here at Williamson County Agricultural ... (click for more)

Bradley Whips Soddy Daisy For AAA State Duals Title

FRANKLIN, Tenn. – The Bradley Bears have won more state duals titles than anyone and they added another one after going four years without being in the championship round. It’s been a remarkable season for the Bears, who beat region-rival Soddy Daisy by a 52-21 margin for their latest state title. Saturday night’s   match was never really close as the Bears had a ... (click for more)