Roy Exum: Coaches Vs. ‘Top 25’ Foes

Thursday, August 21, 2014 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

The long-accepted measuring stick for a college football coach has been his win-loss record, with an after-glance at his win-loss record within his conference. But in Wednesday’s editions of the Wall Street Journal, writer David Everson, with the help of Stats LLC, used a much-tougher litmus test when he revealed the records of 65 major-college coaches against opponents that were ranked in the Associated Press Top 25 at the time they played.

With the start of the 2014 season one week from tonight, forget about “Cupcake U.” for a moment and let’s see what has happened when our top college coaches have faced the best teams in the country. Some of the results are telling, indeed:

THE SOUTHEASTERN CONFERENCE

ALABAMA – Entering his eighth season, Nick Saban is 28-12 against the Top 25 and since he got his first head coaching job at Toledo in 1990, he is 50-35 against the best.

ARKANSAS – Entering his second season, Bert Bielema is 0-6 against the Top 25 and since he got his first head coaching job at Wisconsin in 2006, he is 10-20 against the best.

AUBURN – Entering his second season, Gus Malzahn is 5-2 against the Top 25 and since he got his first head coaching job at Arkansas State, he is 5-3 against the best.

FLORIDA – Entering his fourth season, Will Muschamp is 4-11 against the Top 25. He began his head coaching career at Florida in 2011.

GEORGIA – Entering his 14th season, Mark Richt is 34-31 against the Top 25. He began his head coaching career at Georgia in 2001.

KENTUCKY – Entering his second season, Mark Stoops is 0-5 against the Top 25. He began his head coaching career at Kentucky in 2013. 

LSU – Entering his 10th season, Les Miles is 40-31 against the Top 25 and since he got his first head coaching job at Oklahoma State in 2001, he is 37-19 against the best.

OLE MISS – Entering his third season, Hugh Freeze is 2-7 against the Top 25 and since he got his first head coaching job at Lambuth in 2008, he is 2-8 against the best.

MISS. STATE – Entering his sixth season, Dan Mullen is 2-21 against the Top 25. He began his head coaching career at MSU in 2009.

MISSOURI – Entering his 14th season, Gary Pinkel is 15-34 against the Top 25 and since he got his first head coaching job at Toledo in 1991, he is 15-37 against the best.

SOUTH CAROLINA – Entering his 10th season, Steve Spurrier is 18-23 against the Top 25 and since he got his first head coaching job at Duke in 1987, he is 62-52-1 against the best. (Spurrier was a head coach in the USFL for two years before Duke and then coached in the NFL for two seasons after 12 years at Florida. He accepted the USC job in 2005.)

TENNESSEE – Entering his second season, Butch Jones is 1-6 against the Top 25 and since he got his first head coaching job at Central Michigan in 2007, he is 1-11 against the best.

TEXAS A&M – Entering his third season at Texas A&M, Kevin Sumlin is 5-6 against the Top 25 and since he got his first head coaching job at Houston in 2008, he is 8-7 against the best.

VANDERBILT – Entering his first season as a head coach, Derek Mason has never faced a Top 25 foe.

OTHER COACHES OF NOTE

OKLAHOMA – Entering his 16th season, Bob Stoops , has the most victories of the 65 teams listed. His record against the Top 25 is 50-23. Alabama’s Saban, with a higher winning percentage (.700 versus .685) has played far less games.

STANFORD – Entering his fourth season, David Shaw has the best record of all coaches at 14-4 against the Top 25 (.778). Stanford is his first experience as a head coach. (WSJ writer Everson pointed out two of Shaw’s four losses were in overtime.)

OHIO STATE – Entering his third season, Urban Meyer is 5-2 against the Top 25 and since beginning his head coaching career at Bowling Green in 2001, he is 25-12 against the best.

FLORIDA STATE – Entering his sixth season, Jimbo Fisher is 9-5 against the Top 25. He began his career as a head coach at FSU in 2010.

NOTRE DAME – Entering his fifth season, Brian Kelly is 7-7 against the Top 25 and since he got his first head coaching job at Grand Valley State in 1991, he is 15-11 against the best.

GEORGIA TECH – Entering his seventh season, Paul Johnson is 7-12 against the Top 25 and since beginning his head coaching career at Georgia Southern in 1997, he is 7-20 against the best.

CLEMSON – Entering his seventh season, Dabo Swinney is 9-13 against the Top 25. He began his head coaching career at Clemson in 2008.

LOUISVILLE – Entering his second season, Bobby Petrino is 4-5 against the Top 25 and since beginning his career at Louisville in 2003, he is 14-17 against the best.

VIRGINIA TECH – Entering his 28th season, Frank Beamer is 43-50-1 against the Top 25 and since beginning his career at Murray State in 1981, he is 43-50-1 against the best.

royexum@aol.com



Thanks To Those Who Made East Ridge Stadium Possible - And Response

I would like to express my personal appreciation, and that of our entire city, to the Hamilton County School Board for its decision to fund new seating at Raymond James Stadium at East Ridge High School.   Because the former stadium was condemned in August and razed in December of last year, it would have been easy to simply let this subject fade away.   However, ... (click for more)

A Change For Walker County - And Response (2)

Everyone elected to public office deserves a chance to fulfill the office they are elected to.  A reasonable amount of time should be expected to accomplish these goals as well.  In Walker County we have had the same sole commissioner for 16 years. Whether you believe she has done a good job or not, 16 years as a government servant should be long enough for any one ... (click for more)

Settlement May Be Close In Government's $1.8 Billion Case Against Cleveland, Tn.-Based Life Care Centers Of America

A settlement may be close in the federal government's massive False Claims Act case against Cleveland, Tn.-based Life Care Centers of America. Attorneys have asked Chattanooga Federal Judge Sandy Mattice to put a 30-day hold on depositions, saying a settlement is in the works. Judge Mattice granted the motion. The government says claims in the case amount to $1.8 billion. ... (click for more)

Erlanger Projecting $15.2 Million Profit In Aggressive "Growth Budget"

Erlanger Health Systems is projecting a $15.2 million profit in an aggressive "growth budget" for the upcoming fiscal year. President Kevin Spiegel, who has led the public hospital to a succession of profitable years, said the projections are based on a TennCare waiver being renewed once again. He said if it is not renewed, then the hospital will have to completely rework the ... (click for more)

Germany's Sebastian Kienle Wins Ironman 70.3 Race

It’s hard to not be impressed with the fitness level of folks who commit themselves to training and participating in Ironman-distance triathlons and that was surely the case in downtown Chattanooga Sunday morning. There are three words to describe these folks and that’s fit, fast and friendly.  And most of them cross the finish line with a smile on their face and a spring ... (click for more)

Spring Fling State Soccer Brackets Set

Notre Dame and McCallie are the only area teams to compete in this week's Spring Fling Soccer competitions in Murfreesboro.   In Class A/AA, Notre Dame will play Tuesday at 6:30 in the quarterfinals.  The will face off with CAK. Winners will advance to the semifinals on Wednesday.  The Class A/AA state championship game is set for Friday at 4 p.m.   Notre ... (click for more)