Our Courts Shouldn't Be Controlled By The Highest Bidder

Tuesday, August 5, 2014

I have been a lawyer in Tennessee for over 35 years. Over that time, I have tried cases and argued cases on appeal, for defendants in civil litigation as well as for plaintiffs in civil litigation. Over that time, I have never had to fear whether a judge sitting on my case had benefited from a fundraiser by my adversary. Now, there are those who want to change the system so that we will have to worry about those types of things. 

I know of a case in Kentucky where the individual defendants hosted a fundraiser for one of the appellate judges who was to decide the case, while it was pending. That is an unacceptable situation. 

The United States Supreme Court has dealt with this in a case from West Virginia where a party spent over $3 million to place a selected individual on the Supreme Court in an effort to affect the outcome of that party's case. The United States Supreme Court found that situation to be unacceptable.

Regardless of political affiliation no one should have to be concerned that a judge hearing their case has received greater financial benefit and support from the opposing party or lawyer. Therefore, I urge those of you who are Tennessee residents to vote to retain our sitting Supreme Court and appellate court judges, mainly to rebuke those who feel that our courts should be controlled by the highest bidder. 

Bill Colvin

The Peasants Want Our City Back - And Response (2)

Re: Roy Exum: We Want Our City Back  When local government makes decisions that defy common logic, it frustrates we the peasants that do not have a meaningful voice in how our money is spent.  Roy Exum articulated to the very core of how we the peasants are marginalized by local government, completely ignored.  I am amazed at how regular ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: We Want Our City Back

Late Saturday morning, there was a driving rain as I took my khakis to be hemmed by Bruce Baird, who owns a wonderful menswear store on Broad Street, and it was glaringly obvious that what the crazies among us have done with a looney bike-lane scheme is ridiculous. There are concrete barriers, reducing Broad Street to two lanes of traffic, which I believe will impede downtown businesses ... (click for more)

Baylor Student, 16, Dies After Cardiac Incident At Pool

A 16-year-old Baylor School student died after a cardiac incident at a pool on Monday afternoon. Sumner Smith died in the incident on campus. The student was taken by ambulance to Erlanger. Baylor's Barbara Kennedy said it happened during a routine swim practice. He was found unresponsive in the pool. Counselors were being provided on the Baylor campus on Tuesday. ... (click for more)

Bradley County Commission Decides Not To Provide Animal Pickup Service

Bradley County Commissioners on Monday finally put animal control to rest. It was not easy and it was not without confusion, but in the end, the county will not provide animal pickup service. Confusion began when commissioners were asked to approve the agenda, which included two options for animal control pick up. Item “D” provided for the SPCA of Bradley County to pick ... (click for more)

Lady 'Canes Beat Bradley, Set Up Showdown With Ooltewah

CLEVELAND, Tenn. – East Hamilton and Bradley Central had played four times before their District 5-3A volleyball tournament opener on Monday. The two teams split the series. Monday’s match was clearly more important than the previous four, since the winner advanced in the district tourney and the loser went home. The No. 4 seed Lady Hurricanes (21-15) rallied impressively ... (click for more)

CSAS Advances In 5-A Volleyball With Win Over Copper Basin

Samantha Green didn't have any idea what her team's overall record was, but all that matters is that her CSAS Lady Patriots won their opening-round match of the District 5-A tournament on Monday at Silverdale and will face top-seeded Grace on Tuesday in the semifinals. The Lady Patriots beat the Copper Basin Lady Cougars on Monday, needing less than an hour to advance as CSAS ... (click for more)