Our Courts Shouldn't Be Controlled By The Highest Bidder

Tuesday, August 5, 2014

I have been a lawyer in Tennessee for over 35 years. Over that time, I have tried cases and argued cases on appeal, for defendants in civil litigation as well as for plaintiffs in civil litigation. Over that time, I have never had to fear whether a judge sitting on my case had benefited from a fundraiser by my adversary. Now, there are those who want to change the system so that we will have to worry about those types of things. 

I know of a case in Kentucky where the individual defendants hosted a fundraiser for one of the appellate judges who was to decide the case, while it was pending. That is an unacceptable situation. 

The United States Supreme Court has dealt with this in a case from West Virginia where a party spent over $3 million to place a selected individual on the Supreme Court in an effort to affect the outcome of that party's case. The United States Supreme Court found that situation to be unacceptable.

Regardless of political affiliation no one should have to be concerned that a judge hearing their case has received greater financial benefit and support from the opposing party or lawyer. Therefore, I urge those of you who are Tennessee residents to vote to retain our sitting Supreme Court and appellate court judges, mainly to rebuke those who feel that our courts should be controlled by the highest bidder. 

Bill Colvin



Send Your Opinions To Chattanoogan.com

We welcome your opinions at Chattanoogan.com. Email to news@chattanoogan.com . We require your real first and last name and contact information. There is no word limit, but if your article is too long you may lose your reader. Please focus more on issues than personal attacks. (click for more)

Muslim Credo Impels Attacks, Hammond Says; Sheriff Using U.S. Intel

The Muslim attacker in Chattanooga was living out the tenets of a totalitarian faith, and the sheriff’ department’s U.S.-supplied surveillance data did not have him “on the radar screen,” Hamilton County Sheriff Jim Hammond says in an interview.  Muslim religious and political creeds dictate world domination in which acts of terror and jihad are religiously sanctioned, ... (click for more)

Trustee To Be Appointed To Oversee Hutcheson Medical Center Bankruptcy With Focus On Sale Of Fort Oglethorpe Hospital

A trustee will be appointed to oversee the bankruptcy case of Hutcheson Medical Center with a focus on getting the financially-strapped Fort Oglethorpe hospital sold. The U.S. Trustee's Office had filed a motion asking that the bankruptcy be dissolved due to the debt rising to $6.3 million since the bankruptcy was filed last November. However, all parties finally agreed it was ... (click for more)

Civic, Political Leader Mai Bell Hurley Dies At 87

Civic and political leader Mai Bell Hurley has died at age 87. She was the first woman to serve on the Chattanooga City Council. Ms. Hurley was also a longtime advocate for the arts and a leader in United Way. She was a leader in Chattanooga Venture that led to the redevelopment of downtown and the riverfront.  She most recently served on the Library Board. ... (click for more)

Wrestling Session Sparks Lady 'Canes To Volleyball Win

All season long, East Hamilton volleyball coach Kristy Lenoir has been less than pleased with her team’s lack of emotion on the court. So, to change that Lenoir spent her allotted practice time putting the Lady Hurricanes through one-on-one wrestling matches. Yep, wrestling. “I’ve never had a practice like that one,” Lenoir said Thursday. “We’ve lacked emotion and a desire ... (click for more)

Chattanooga Football Opener: UTC vs. Jax State – Saturday at Finley Stadium; 6 p.m.

Saturday at Finley Stadium at 6 p.m.  it’s No.8 Chattanooga vs. No.7 Jacksonville (Ala.) State in arguably the most anticipated and talked about game in Chattanooga football history. An important region rivalry as a pair of top 10 FCS schools meet for the 39th time in the season opener for both schools. “This should be a great game between two of the best teams in ... (click for more)