Closing Argument On Retention Election 2014

Wednesday, August 6, 2014

A number of lawyers and judges are seemingly fearful of partisan campaigns when it comes to whether voters choose to replace or retain our justices.  Perhaps those same lawyers and judges feel that politics or campaign finance interests would sway the opinions of future justices.  Ironically, those same lawyers and judges don’t have that identical concern for the existing justices even after they accepted over $1,000,000 and will be subject to retention again at a later point if retained this year.  

A number of lawyers and judges have said that the election to replace is nothing more than a power grab by the lieutenant governor, thus creating the farce that one branch can magically control another, which is not true in reality.  The branches are independent and have their own powers pursuant to the Constitution.   

Consider that the lieutenant governor is actually doing the judicial branch a favor, and more importantly, the voters too.  How?  A Tennessee Supreme Court determined by the voters under a partisan campaign is a court more powerful among the branches than it would be otherwise.  The reason: political legitimacy to govern autonomously is derived from the sovereign.  Public officials obtain power when voters elect them to do the business of government.  As for empowering the voter, it is through the vigorous public debate associated with partisan campaigns that the voters become aware of their voting rights, gain knowledge about the candidates, and partake as citizens in the formation of their government through the democratic process.  

The Tennessee Supreme Court is not just a court that opines on cases (which by the way can often be appealed to the United States Supreme Court as a court of last resort unless it is an independent and adequate state issue).  These justices oversee the Administrative Office of the Courts.  The AOC presides over numerous state government functions impacting the judicial branch, including the administration of the lower courts, the regulation of the practice of law, the victim’s fund, and many other programs.  As with any government branch, the elected public officials with oversight should be accountable to the voters.  Apparently this only happens for the justices when a partisan campaign is launched during a retention election year.  

I may be a lawyer, but I am a Tennessean first.  I will be voting to replace the justices because I believe that no justice should contest having to plea their case in a partisan race – that’s how we hold our elected public officials accountable as voters. 

Pursuant to Article VI, Section 3 of the Tennessee Constitution, “judges of the supreme court shall be elected by the qualified voters of the state.”   

James H. Dunn
Attorney at Law



Fruit Basket Turnover

I have been teaching for 21 years now, so I’ve been through my share of school leaders. Every one of them taught me something important. Whether it was Don Bishop from Red Bank High School who, after almost 30 years at Red Bank, taught me to invest in the longevity of my career, Wade Kelly who taught me to thoroughly weigh options before making a decision, Gail Chuy who taught me ... (click for more)

Domestic Violence And Lost Focus - And Response

As a past victim of domestic violence, I am acutely aware of how serious this problem is. I am sorry that the Stone family has to have their personal drama played out to the world at 5:00, 5:30, and 6:00 every evening.   While the public is being entertained by the drama of all this, the real problems in this city are not getting the attention they deserve.  The shootings ... (click for more)

CBL & Associates Stockholder Accuses Chattanooga-Based Mall Owner Of Security Fraud

A stockholder of CBL & Associates is suing the Chattanooga-based mall owner in Chattanooga Federal Court, claiming its officials artificially inflated the value of the company's stock. Tommy French, of Baton Rouge, La., brought the action against CBL, President Stephen Lebovitz and Vice President Farzana Mitchell. He claims that CBL officials made false and misleading ... (click for more)

Carmody Found Guilty Of First-Degree Felony Murder; Sentenced To Life In Prison

Patrick Carmody was sentenced to life in prison after being found guilty of first-degree felony murder and especially aggravated robbery in Judge Barry Steelman’s courtroom on Friday. He was charged with the slaying of 21-year-old Chance LeCroy on Sept. 9, 2010. The state’s account of the incident claimed that Carmody, Ronald Pittman, and Billy Bob Partin traveled ... (click for more)

Baylor Beats GPS Again For Second Straight D-II Title

MURFREESBORO – Baylor coach Kelli Smith was feeling no pain here at the Starplex Field No. 3 Friday afternoon after her team had beaten GPS by a 9-1 final for its second-straight D-II state softball crown, but that wasn’t the case late Thursday night. Smith, who now has two state titles as a Baylor player and eight as their coach, spent more than three hours in the local emergency ... (click for more)

Meigs Bounces Back, Beats Silverdale, 8-5, For State Class A Softball Title

MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – Either Meigs County or Silverdale was going home with a state championship trophy on Friday. Pushed to the limit by the spunky Lady Seahawks in a 6-0 loss – all six runs were unearned – the Lady Tigers responded in the Class A championship game with an 8-5 victory and claimed the school’s first state softball title. “I’m on top of the world,” Meigs ... (click for more)