Lepard Sues EPB On Alleged Overcharges To City; Says Lawsuit Filed To Aid City In Recovering Money

Friday, September 5, 2014

Chattanooga area businessman Don Lepard has filed a whistle blower lawsuit "on behalf of the city of Chattanooga and the city's taxpayers" against EPB. The lawsuit was filed on July 3 in the Circuit Court of Hamilton County. The lawsuit has been "under seal" since July 3, and the confidentiality seal was lifted Friday by the court.

The lawsuit claims the EPB overcharged the city of Chattanooga for energy charges on its monthly billing for the municipal lighting system due to the bills reflecting energy charges for lights that did not exist for at least 20 years. The overcharges are said to be $5.9 million for a 20-year period. The filing also states that due to the "false claims" made by the EPB, "plaintiffs are entitled to a civil penalty of not less than $2,500 and not more than $10,000 for each false claim. Over a period of 20 years, defendant has presented false claims in monthly billings, representing at least 240 false claims."

The lawsuit could result in damages of more than $10 million, Mr. Lepard, who heads Global Green Lighting, said.

Harold DePriest, president and CEO of EPB, said "It's notable that the City of Chattanooga declined to participate in Don Lepard's lawsuit. Like the city, EPB remains committed to working together in good faith to find a fair solution for both citizens and our customers. Because this involves pending litigation, we can't comment on Lepard's claims."

Global Green Lighting officials said, "As is its right, the city of Chattanooga has declined to lead in prosecuting the case against the utility but pledged its support to Lepard and his legal team. Mr. Lepard filed the suit personally and not on behalf of his company."

City officials denied they have pledged support for the suit.

"The lawsuit is a simple, straight-forward way for citizens to hold public entities accountable for wasted tax dollars," said Mr. Lepard. "I simply want the issue of street light billing to be vetted once and for all by an independent court. I strongly believe the city and its taxpayers will benefit financially from a judge and jury gathering and hearing all the evidence."

A statement from Global Green Lighting says, "The discovery of the overcharges was made by Mr. Lepard when his company, Global Green Lighting, deployed for the first time ever a new lighting system with a wireless monitoring and control system containing a utility-grade residential meter for the city of Chattanooga. In order to measure the energy savings, it was necessary to create a detailed profile of the lights that came down off the poles as the new LED lights were installed.

"The misclassification discrepancy was discovered when Mr. Lepard attempted to reconcile the city's monthly billing to the lights that had actually been removed from the poles and benchmarked into a spreadsheet. Mr. Lepard was taking inventory of each light that was taken down. In the course of that inventory, Mr. Lepard discovered the information that led to the allegations of overcharging by EPB. In an effort to measure the performance of the new lighting technology, Mr. Lepard found that the EPB was billing the city for more costly lights while less costly lights were actually on the poles.
 
"For example, Mr. Lepard found that the EPB had billed the city for more than 6,000 mercury vapor lights each month for years although there is no documentation to suggest these antiquated, more expensive lights even exist in the municipal lighting system.
 

"Mr. Lepard made the EPB and the city aware of the overcharges. After months of trying to work with the EPB and the city to unravel the confusion that was effecting the city's ability to properly evaluate the performance of the new GGL lighting and control system, Mr. Lepard gladly accepted the offer made by the city council to have the Office of Internal Audit (OIA) evaluate the projected future operating costs of the existing lighting infrastructure owned by the EPB and the new lighting system that the city would own and pay GGL separately to maintain and operate as a third party vender.

"It was the OIA's April 25,·report that made public for the first time the concerns of overcharges. In September 2013, Mr. Lepard shared his findings with the EPB and the city. The EPB began reclassifying the lights on its billing in 2013 in significant numbers. There is no indication that the city was made aware at that time of EPB's reclassifying the lights on the city's bill.

"Since April, the EPB has released two audit reports that do not deny the overcharges but instead offer three different theories on how the utility underbilled the city in asserting that it is entitled to an offset of the energy overcharges. Mr. Lepard says none of the theories has merit."

"Even if the EPB's claimed underbillings are factually accurate, which is in dispute, we have not been able to identify a proper basis for the EPB to go back and retroactively amend the bills," said Mr. Lepard.

Click here to read the overview prepared by Mr. Lepard.

Click here to read the response from City Attorney Wade Hinton.



Former Police Detective Nabbed In TBI Theft, Misconduct Investigation

Special agents from the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation have obtained indictments for a former police department investigator accused of theft and misconduct while on duty. After receiving information from the Morristown Police Department, 3 rd  District Attorney General Dan Armstrong requested TBI special agents investigate Michael Nelson Hurt on Feb. 2. During the ... (click for more)

David Jolley, Jr. Arrested In Bradley County On Burglary Charges

Bradley County patrol deputies and detectives have arrested a suspect who has been linked to two home burglaries and damage to a third. Residents of Grays Ferry Road in rural northern Bradley County discovered forced entry to their homes when they returned on Wednesday. Crime scene investigators developed a solid lead on a possible suspect, who lives less than a mile away. ... (click for more)

Police Need To Stop The Road Cowboys - And Response (2)

Where is our highway patrol?  If they were known to regularly patrol our interstate highways through our city I don't think it would take long before the "truckers" were aware of it.  There are places in our country where this is the case.   When I have traveled Interstates 24 and 75 I may see the occasional car pulled over but rarely if ever is it an 18-wheeler. ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Never Disturb The Dead

I’ve got too many things in my life that scare me so I’ve always been real leery of “unnecessary fear.” A guy named Terry wanted to teach me how to catch a live rattlesnake one time but had a tough time telling me what exactly to do with the angry serpent when the time came to let it go. I have the same view of these paranormal societies where otherwise sane people go around looking ... (click for more)

Jeff Parker Uses Running As Great Source Of Quiet Time

A lot of people run for the social aspect while others run because they’re competitive and just want to see how fast they can cover the distance, especially in a race. Jeff Parker doesn’t fit into either category. He’s been running for more than 30 years and he’s quick to say that he enjoys it more now than ever, but his sole purpose is for time alone when he can meditate ... (click for more)

Chattanooga FC Playing For Division Championship Saturday

The Chattanooga Football Club final home game will be played this Saturday.    With a 4-2 win over the Knoxville Force, Chattanooga controls its own destiny for a 1st place division finish when it faces off against that Nashville FC this Saturday, July 4 at Finley Stadium.  A win secures the division championship for the CFC with a home-field advantage for the ... (click for more)