Roy Exum: Two ‘Participation’ Rings

Monday, May 15, 2017 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

For many years the lofty goal of earning a national championship ring was the biggest prize in college sports but then came the softening of America. Suddenly the “Most Valuable Player” trophy was cheapened by the “Participation Trophy,” which was given to every player on the team so no one would get their feelings hurt. To athletic purists Participation Trophies were meaningless, almost as bad as giving every player a varsity letter instead of requiring an athlete to play a certain number of minutes during a season to earn the distinction.

In the South it was a huge thing to be “a ring toter,” as in carrying a national championship symbol on your finger as you hold your girlfriend’s hand.  Some girls would pry the heavy rings off their BF’s hand, then, using candle wax to narrow the finger size, the girls would declare “ownership.” It was a pretty big ritual.

Now comes word that every player on last fall’s disappointing Tennessee team has just been given two rings. The first was for winning “The Battle of Bristol,” where the Vols spanked Virginia Tech at the Bristol Motor Speedway, 45-21. In fairness, the rings were supplied by event organizers, who were just as shocked that the Vols had to eek one against Appalachian State (20-13) the week before.

Tennessee would lose in another overtime to Texas A&M (42-38) and was predictably smashed by Alabama 49-20.  But the reason UT had a 4-4 record in the SEC was because a couple of underdogs were “bigger dogs” when the Vols visited. Losses to South Carolina and to Vanderbilt scuttled a big bowl game so UT ended up in the Franklin American Mortgage Music City Bowl against a lackluster Nebraska.

Head coach Butch Jones immediately ordered 165 “Music City Bowl Champions” to commemorate the 38-24 victory and, after the Knoxville News-Sentinel requested a full financial disclosure via the Open Records Act, UT paid $37,193 for the rings. Tennessee also wanted extra Battle of Bristol rings and paid $2,600 for those.

Speaking of the Music City Bowl, the University of Tennessee spent over $1 million in Nashville and UT’s share of the SEC bowl income will be $1.3 million.

* * *

CBS Sports takes all of the college football coaches in the Power Five football conferences, adds Notre Dame coach Brian Kelly and ranks all 65 on one list after spring practice every spring. This year’s list has just been announced. Here they are in order, and the number following the name of the coach’s school is last year’s coach ranking:

1. NICK SABAN, Alabama (1).

2. URBAN MEYER, Ohio State (2)

3. DABO SWEENEY, Clemson (8)

4. JIMBO FISHER, Florida State (6)

5. JIM HARBAUGH, Michigan (10)

6. CHRIS PETERSEN, Washington (14)

7. BOBBY STOOPES, Oklahoma (4)

8. DAVID SHAW, Stanford (9)

9. BILL SNYDER, Kansas State (17)

10. GARY PATTERSON, Texas Christian (3)

11. MARK DANTONIO, Michigan State (5)

12. MIKE GUNDY, Oklahoma State (20)

13. BOBBY PETRINO, Louisville (25)

14. KYLE WHITTINGHAM, Utah (23)

15. MARK RICHT, Miami (18)

16. PAT FITZGERALD, Northwestern (34)

17. DAVID CUTCLIFFE, Duke (15)

18. JAMES FRANKLIN, Penn State (41)

19. GUS MALZAHN, Auburn (13)

20. KIRK FERENTZ, Iowa (19)

21. DAN MULLEN, Mississippi State (31)

22. BRIAN KELLY, Notre Dame (12)

23. JIM McELWAIN, Florida (27)

24. PAUL JOHNSON, Georgia Tech (27)

25. MIKE LEACH, Washington State (30)

26. LARRY FEDORA, North Carolina (35)

27. BERT BIELEMA, Arkansas (22)

28. ROM HERMAN, Texas (NR)

29. PAUL CHRYST, Wisconsin (38)

30. MIKE McINTYRE, Colorado (58)

31. WILLIE TAGGART, Oregon (NR)

32. BRONCO MENDENHALL, Virginia (26)

33. HUGH FREEZE, Ole Miss (21)

34. JUSTIN FUENTE, Va. Tech (38)

35. P.J. FLECK, Minnesota (NR)

36. DANA HOLGORSEN, West Virginia (42)

37. WILL MUSCHAMP, South Carolina (44)

38. MIKE RILEY, Nebraska (43)

39. MATT RHULE, Baylor (NR)

40. KEVIN SMLIN, Texas A&M (43)

41. GARY ANDERSON, Oregon State (NR)

42. TODD GRAHAM, Arizona (36)

43. PAR NANDUZZI, Pittsburgh (40)

44. RICH RODRIGUES, Arizona (NR)

45. CLAY HEKTON, Southern Cal (51)

46. DAVE CLAWSON, Wake Forest (59)

47. JEFF BROHM, Purdue ((NR)

48. ED ORGERON, La. State. (NR)

49. JIM MORA, UCLA (29)

50. STEVE ADDAZIO. Boston College (54)

51. DINO BABERS, Syracuse (45)

52. BUTCH JONES, Tennessee (33) – The individual memo from CBS reads: “A Champion of Life, but not a champion of our rankings. Still, in my opinion, this is a pretty steep drop considering all the injuries Tennessee dealt with last year. Raised expectations will do that, though.”

53. DEREK MASON, Vanderbilt (57)

54. KIRBY SMART, Georgia (46)

55. D.J. DURKIN, Markland (60)

56. MARK STOOPS, Kentucky (56)

57. KLIFF KINGSBURY, Texas Tech (47)

58. LOVIE SMITH, U. of Illinois (49)

59. DAVE DOEREN, N. C. State (62)

60. DAVID BEATY, Kansas (50)

61. MATT CAMPBELL, Iowa State (55)

62. BARRY ODOM, Missouri (62)

63. TOM ALLEN, Indiana (NR)

64. JUSTIN WILCOS, California (NR)

65. CHRIS ASH, Rutgers (64)

Royexum@aol.com



Roy Exum: Why I Am Thankful

You would think that after 40 years of publishing an annual list of things for which I am thankful, I’d be getting to the bottom of it, but it seems the older I get I have found I appreciate so much more around me. I take absolute delight in planting a flower, feeding the birds and throwing a ball for my dog. I find that the more people who I come to know the more who I come to ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Thanksgiving Eve

I don’t know who was the first to do the Famous Pregnant Turkey prank but I’ll bet you a handful of giblets there will be a lot of copycats who try it today. The trick is finding a Cornish hen that is small enough to stuff inside the larger turkey. Then you skillfully pack the bird with some of that sausage-sage dressing and put your Thanksgiving dinner in the oven. When all ... (click for more)

Hixson Burglary Suspect Tries To Swim Away; Deputies Catch Him In Borrowed Boat

A Hixson burglary suspect on Wednesday tried to swim away from deputies, but to no avail.   The proprietor of Chattanooga Fish and Fun was notified when his camera system was triggered by an individual attempting to break into his business. The owner immediately contacted the Sheriff's Office and drove to the business location.   As deputies arrived on scene, ... (click for more)

5 Disinherited Adopted Children Of Dr. J. Don Brock May Share In Rich Estate After All

Five disinherited adopted children of the late Chattanooga businessman J. Don Brock may share in his large estate after all. After losing at the trial court and appeals court level, the plaintiffs won a victory at the Tennessee Supreme Court. Justice Cornelia Clark ruled in favor of the adopted children and remanded the case to the trial court for settlement of the estate. ... (click for more)

Rodney Stoker Wins Turkey Trot 8K Again

It has been about 15 years since Rodney Stoker captured first place overall in the annual Sports Barn Turkey Trot, but he’s been doing some serious training in recent weeks and it paid off Thursday morning as the 41-year-old former UTC standout was victorious with a time of 27 minutes, 18 seconds. Dylan Hassett, a promising 24-year-old from Atlanta who is making her way as a ... (click for more)

JOHN HUNT: Thanksgiving 2017 Special As Always

I can’t believe it’s that time again.  Another year has come and gone and where did it all go? My father once told me that time really flies as you get older and I’m starting to believe him. But we’re back to one of my favorite holidays of the year – Thanksgiving – and I’m looking forward to spending quality time with family and friends.  I’m sure that I’ll eat too ... (click for more)