TN Supreme Court Reinstates Aggravated Stalking Conviction

Friday, June 16, 2017
The Supreme Court has reinstated an aggravated stalking conviction of a defendant for knowingly violating an order of protection.  The Court reversed a Court of Criminal Appeals decision that there was insufficient evidence for the jury to have convicted the defendant on the aggravated stalking charge. 
 
This case arose from an incident in which the defendant physically and verbally accosted a woman to whom he had been married and with whom he had two children.  He confronted her in a parking lot while she was waiting to pick up a pizza and then followed her to a gas station.
 Police arrived at the gas station and arrested the defendant.  The next day, the victim obtained an order of protection against the defendant, and she was informed that the defendant had been served with the order of protection. That same day, the victim had an encounter with the defendant when the defendant and his mother drove past her, turned around, and then followed her.  The victim called the police, and the defendant was arrested again.  Over the next month, the defendant and victim had two other encounters.  At one, the defendant arrived at a Verizon store and banged on the window while the victim paid her phone bill inside.  At the other, the defendant drove past the victim’s house, shouting profanities and telling the victim’s daughter that he was “gonna get her.”  
 
The defendant was indicted on charges of domestic assault and aggravated stalking.  Following a jury trial, the defendant was acquitted of domestic assault but convicted of aggravated stalking.  The defendant appealed, arguing that the proof at trial was insufficient to support his conviction for aggravated stalking, and the Court of Criminal Appeals agreed, reducing the defendant’s conviction from aggravated stalking to misdemeanor stalking.
 
The Supreme Court granted the State’s application for permission to appeal from the Court of Criminal Appeals’ decision reversing the trial court’s judgment.  The Court considered whether the Court of Criminal Appeals erred in reducing the defendant’s conviction to misdemeanor stalking based on insufficiency of the trial evidence.
 
In the unanimous opinion, authored by Chief Justice Jeff Bivins, the Court determined that the Court of Criminal Appeals improperly reweighed the evidence presented at trial, rather than assessing the sufficiency of that evidence, as is required under the appellate standard of review.  In considering the sufficiency of the evidence, the Supreme Court determined that sufficient proof was adduced at trial for a jury to determine that the defendant had actual notice of the order of protection.  Therefore, he knowingly violated an order of protection.  Accordingly, the Court reversed the Court of Criminal Appeals’ judgment and reinstated the defendant’s aggravated stalking conviction.  
 
To read the Supreme Court’s opinion in State of Tennessee v. Rodney Stephens, authored by Chief Justice Jeff Bivins, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov.


Tennessee Supreme Court Rules Trial Judges May Set Minimum Term Of Confinement

Jason Ray brought a lawsuit in federal court in West Tennessee seeking money damages for an alleged violation of his civil rights.  Ray pled guilty in 2013 to theft of property over $60,000 and received a sentence of 10 years, with 11 months and 29 days to be served in the local jail and the rest on supervised probation.  This type of sentence is known as split confinement. ... (click for more)

Very Named One Of Amercia's Fastest-Growing Private Companies

Very, a software product development firm based in Chattanooga, Wednesday announced that it has been named one of the fastest-growing private companies in the country. The firm ranked in the top quarter of Inc. Magazine’s 2017 Inc. 5000 list, coming in at No. 1,146 overall and No. 15 in Tennessee.  Now in its 36th year, Inc. 5000 is a list of America’s 5,000 fastest-growing ... (click for more)

Opposing Sides Expected To Show Up For Coolidge Park Rally Thursday Night; Some Urged To "Bring Your Guns"

Chattanooga Police said they will be closely monitoring an organized rally at Coolidge Park on Thursday that may draw some of the same opposing sides that clashed - with deadly result - in Charlottesville, Va. The rally is set for 7:30 p.m. and initially was  in memory of a woman who was killed in the angry Virginia confrontation that initially began over a decision to ... (click for more)

Owners Of Larger Structures In Walker County To Pay More For Fire, Ambulance Service; Full-Time Fire Stations Increase From 4-6

Walker County Sole Commissioner Shannon Whitfield announced plans on Wednesday to update the county's fire fee schedule to offer improvements in fire protection and public safety efforts. The fee will now be known as a "public safety" fee and will fund fire and emergency management operations, along with contracted ambulance services.   The county will replace the existing ... (click for more)

Shame On Anyone Planning A Protest At Coolidge Park Thursday Evening - And Response

Whether you're Alt-Left or Alt-Right, Coolidge Park isn't the place to showcase your hate and indifference with one another. Just because it's your right, that doesn't necessarily mean that you should do it. Many have this misconception that this park is named after a President, Nope. It's named after a great man, a true patriot, and Medal of Honor recipient from right ... (click for more)

A Tale Of 3 Properties

Here in Lookout Valley on the far southwest edge of Chattanooga and Hamilton County, trees and rocks are plentiful but sidewalks are as rare as unicorns. It’s a land the governments forget – until tax collection time.  The recent county reappraisal spoke about ‘comps,’ recent sale prices of comparable local properties. But the assessors defined ‘comparable’ to suit themselves, ... (click for more)