Roy Exum: California’s Foolishness

Tuesday, June 27, 2017 - by Roy Exum
Roy Exum
Roy Exum

Over the weekend Hillary Clinton, the first runner-up in the latest presidential election, tweeted, “Forget death panels. If Republicans pass this (health) bill, they're the death party.” It was also being seriously debated if the psychotic action of the gunman who shot Louisiana Rep. Steve Scalise was due to the repugnant rhetoric being increasingly spewed by other liberals. Great goodness, it seems to be more outlandish by the day.

The Daily Caller website offered that the Scalise tragedy was “just the latest in an escalating pattern of violence and intimidation against Republicans,” and noted that conservative politicians were being targeted as victims of “an increasingly hostile political climate where left-wingers portrayed them as ‘fascists.’”

Kathy Griffin, the comedian who held up a bloody model of Donald Trump’s head to her later shame, is the queen of disturbing liberal rhetoric but – my gracious -- this vitriol has taken an even greater scope. Now the California legislature wants to brawl against other states in this America we love.

California, long labeled “The Left Coast,” just added four more of our United States to an unfathomable hate list, imposing a moralistic “travel ban” on Texas, Alabama, South Dakota and Kentucky. That brings the number of states that California dislikes enough to purposely inflict economic pain to eight, this in just the last six months. Earlier this year Tennessee, Kansas, Mississippi and North Carolina were announced in the inaugural “off limits” assault.

Here’s the deal:  California state law AB 1887 – which went into effect Jan. 1, 2017 -- staunchly prohibits state-funded and state-sponsored travel to states that authorize and require discrimination based on sexual gender, gender identity, gender expression or same-sex couples. Any state agency, departments, board, authorities and commissions associated with the University of California system, its regents, or California State University (system) are banned from the thus-far eight states now on the list. Individual travel is still permitted by California residents but not on the taxpayer’s dime.

The California Assembly passed the law 56-21 and the state Senate passed it 26-12. This was hardly on a whim.

Xavier Becerra, the Attorney General for California, decides what states are to be placed in what is laughingly called “the no-fly zone.” His stance? “Our country has made great strides in dismantling prejudicial laws that have deprived too many of our fellow Americans of their precious rights,” he said. “Sadly, that is not the case in parts of our nation, even in the 21st century.”

Yet California with its ban is, in fact, the most prejudiced of all the states in the Union.

This is as hysterical as it is ridiculous. Why alienate other states? And, at what price? For example, Fresno State’s football team is scheduled to play at Alabama this fall in a huge “money” game so the law was hurriedly altered to say all contractual agreements signed prior to Jan. 1, 2017, would be honored. There is a big conference in Dallas this week where California lawmakers are attending, loudly decreeing the trip is “personally financed.” Do you believe that from a politician? Really?

Tennessee was blacklisted early because of a law that allows a state-licensed therapist to deny treatment to members of the LGBT community based on the therapist’s individual beliefs. Kentucky was hit because its “Charlie Brown law” prevents school officials from punishing children from demonstrating their religious or political beliefs in homework, artwork, and speeches. (It’s called the Charlie Brown Law after some misguided school teacher cut a Bible verse from the script in the elementary school play, “Merry Christmas Charlie Brown.”)

Texas, Alabama and South Dakota got hit with the ban for passing laws that allow adoption agencies to follow faith-based policies, including the option of not placing children with same sex couples. North Carolina made the hate list for its bathroom policies. Kansas was faulted for allowing college religious groups to require that those who wish to join said group must adhere to the group’s beliefs.

Trust me, California is being scoffed and scorned in a scathing response, most especially by the eight states that have been chosen by the state district attorney to be banned.

John Whitman, press secretary for Texas Governor Greg Abbott, said, "California may be able to stop their state employees, but they can't stop all the businesses that are fleeing over taxation and regulation and relocating to Texas.”

And, a spokesman for Kentucky Governor Matt Bevin also criticized California officials. “It is fascinating that the very same West Coast liberals who rail against the President’s executive order, that protects our nation from foreign terrorists, have now contrived their own travel ban aimed at punishing states who don’t fall in lockstep with their far-left political ideology,” said Woody Maglinger.

Shortly after the California ban, the Tennessee legislature passed a Resolution (SJR0111) that decreed to its California counterparts they mind their own business and that the Volunteer State had little time for any “unfounded moral judgement.” Todd Gardenhire, Mike Carter, Patsy Hazlewood and Gerald McCormick were among those who voted for the resolution, while Bo Watson refused to be party to it, voting “present.”

It was signed by Governor Bill Haslam last month and copies were immediately sent to every other state legislator in the entire United States. Here's the text of the resolution:

* * *

"Whereas, California has passed legislation banning state sponsored travel to Tennessee and certain other states; and

Whereas, the ban stems from legislation enacted by Tennessee that allows counselors to refer patients to other counselors who can better meet their goals, which the California State Legislature has judged to be morally reprehensible; and

Whereas, California's attempt to influence public policy in our state is akin to Tennessee expressing its disapproval of California's exorbitant taxes, spiraling budget deficits, runaway social welfare programs, and rampant illegal immigration; and

Whereas, Tennessee is pleasantly surprised that California will not be sending its economic development teams to Tennessee to recruit our businesses, but we can still send our teams to recruit their businesses; and

Whereas, Tennessee is puzzled why California thinks it is a good idea to prohibit its state colleges and universities from participating in athletic competition in Tennessee (March Madness comes to Memphis this year via the South Regional), Kansas, Mississippi, and North Carolina; and

Whereas, this type of ban, the result of legitimate disagreements about government policy, is neither persuasive nor productive for either party and will lead to economic warfare among states, as one sovereign entity attempts to tell an equally sovereign entity how to conduct its affairs by restricting travel thereto; and

Whereas, the United States Constitution provides for a strong federal government for the common defense, but the Tenth Amendment grants the several states sovereignty in addressing issues solely within their jurisdiction, and all states should respect this most basic precept of American government; and

Whereas, if states such as California persist in banning travel to Tennessee as a punitive action for this body conducting its constitutionally mandated duties as its members see fit, our state leaders should consider strong reciprocal action in banning state sponsored travel to those misguided states; now, therefore,

BE IT RESOLVED BY THE SENATE OF THE ONE HUNDRED TENTH GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF TENNESSEE, THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES CONCURRING, that we urge and encourage the Governor, the Speaker of the Senate, and the Speaker of the House of Representatives to ban state -sponsored and state funded travel within their respective jurisdictions to any state of the Union that has banned state-sponsored travel to Tennessee in a selective way, so that the other states feel the pain and not Tennessee

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that we urge the other forty-eight states to refrain from imposing their unfounded moral judgment on their sister states as California has done in order to prevent escalating foolishness

BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that a certified copy of this resolution be transmitted to the National Conference of State Legislatures, the Council of State Governments, and the American Legislative Exchange Council and that a certified copy of this resolution be sent electronically to each member of each state legislative body in the nation, so they may also consider taking action against this type of blackmail."

* * *

As a very wise man once said, “Don’t hide your flaws while looking for mine.”

royexum@aol.com


Jim Bethune Is The Best Choice For East Ridge Mayor

I wanted to offer my support for Jim Bethune for mayor of East Ridge.  Jim has been an East Ridge boy for a long time, served his country in the military and came back home after his service.  He has been here through thick and thin and even when (just being honest) we have not agreed on everything we respected each other’s opinions without harming our friendship.  ... (click for more)

Vote For Danielle Mitchell

I am a 71 year old who lives in Chattanooga.  I am writing to urge you to vote for Danielle Mitchell for Congress.  She has been our family doctor for five years, so I know her and I trust her.  Please help send Dr. Mitchell to Washington where she can help to heal our country.  She is very smart and extremely passionate about fighting for regular folks ... (click for more)

City "Moves Away" From $4 Million Light Show On Walnut Street Bridge

The city is no longer pursuing a plan for a $4,050,000 light show on the Walnut Street Bridge. Dennis Malone, assistant city engineer, told City Council members on Tuesday, "We have moved away from that project." The council had earlier pulled capital funding that had been proposed for the "Ripples of Light" on the historic "walking bridge" that dates to 1891. “Ripples ... (click for more)

Developer Of Publix Grocery At St. Elmo To Go Before Variance Board

The developer of a planned Publix grocery in St. Elmo will go before the City Board of Zoning Appeals on Nov. 7 seeking three variances. Mike Price of MAP Engineers said the grocery has been working with community members to try to come up with an acceptable plan for the site where the former Mt. Vernon Restaurant and Pizza Hut are located. There has been controversy over ... (click for more)

Baylor Wins First Match In State Volleyball

MURFREESBORO – The first match of the 2018 TSSAA State Volleyball Tournament is in the books for the Baylor Lady Red Raiders. The defending Division II, Class AA state champs defeated Father Ryan for the third time this season, Tueday’s match by a 3-1 final at Blackman High School. Wednesday's second match at Siegel High School will be against the Briarcrest Saints, who improved ... (click for more)

East Hamilton Roars Back To Beat Camden, 3-1, In Class 2A State Vollleyball Tourney

(Story will be updated) MURFREESBORO, Tenn. – Sleepwalking through a lethargic first set after driving from Chattanooga, East Hamilton awoke and stormed past Camden, 3-1, Tuesday in the first round of the Class 2A state volleyball tournament at Middle Tennessee State University. The scores were 25-9, 23-25, 22-25, 16-25 and 20-25. The Lady Canes (29-2), who have ... (click for more)