HRC Medical And Its Principals Ordered To Pay $18 Million And Stop Unlawful Activity

Friday, July 21, 2017
Attorney General Herbert H. Slatery III announced Friday Senior Judge Don Ash, serving as special judge for the Davidson County Circuit Court, has granted the State’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment in its lawsuit against HRC Medical Centers, Inc. and the company’s principals, Dan Hale, Don Hale, and Dixie Hale. The Order is a significant step in concluding the case, officials said.
 
According to the ruling, HRC, Dan Hale, Don Hale, and Dixie Hale are ordered to pay consumers who purchased HRC’s bio-identical hormone replacement therapy (BHRT) a total of $18,141,750 for violations of the Tennessee Consumer Protection Act.
Additionally, the Court issued a permanent injunction barring the Defendants from engaging in conduct the Court has found unlawful.
 
The Order is subject to review by an appellate court.  If the appellate court agrees with the trial court ruling, HRC consumers will be paid from Defendants’ remaining available assets. However, company assets are likely to be significantly less than the court ordered amount, officials said.
 
“HRC and its principals made deceptive statements about the safety and efficacy of its hormone replacement therapy and omitted facts that were important to consumers,” General Slatery said. “It took years of hard work from our attorneys, but the trial court has sent a clear message about Defendants’ advertising practices.” 
 
The State’s original complaint, filed Oct. 8, 2012, alleged in part that HRC, Dan Hale, and Don Hale withheld important information concerning health risks and side effects from consumers and made a series of false, deceptive, and/or unsubstantiated claims about their alternative regimen of BHRT. For women, HRC’s BHRT consisted of estradiol, progesterone, and testosterone. For men, HRC’s BHRT consisted of testosterone.
 
In 2015, the Court found HRC violated the Tennessee Consumer Protection Act by deceptively claiming their products to be absolutely or completely safe, had no side effects, and restored a user’s hormones to prime levels. The Court also found HRC violated the TCPA by making false claims regarding FDA approval and by using company employees and family members in customer testimonial advertisements without disclosing that relationship to consumers.
 
“It is extremely important that consumers receive truthful information about the benefits and risks of any purchase,” said Director Cynthia Wiel of the Tennessee Division of Consumer Affairs. “We are pleased that the court’s decision recognizes this principle.”
 
HRC Medical Centers, Inc. operated clinics in Nashville, Knoxville, and Memphis that sold BHRT.  HRC is not currently operating in Tennessee.


Parkridge Bone And Joint Orthopedic Surgeon To Present Partial Knee Replacement Success At International Medical Conference

Orthopedic surgeon and founding member of Parkridge Bone & Joint, Martin Redish, MD, has been selected from among a host of international surgeons to present at the biennial THE Partial Knee Meeting in Bruges, Belgium, on Jan. 25.    Dr. Redish will present his published work describing the results of partial knees performed on patients over a four-year period ... (click for more)

Free Smoking Cessation Course Begins Feb. 1 At CHI Memorial

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates more than 16 million Americans live with a disease caused by smoking. It is the leading cause of preventable death, according to the American Lung Association.   CHI Memorial’s Rees Skillern Cancer Institute will offer a free seven-week Freedom From Smoking program that begins Feb. 1.  The program helps participants ... (click for more)

City's Top Traffic Reconstruction Expert: "Man, This Truck Just Creamed A Dozen Cars"

The Chattanooga Police Department's top traffic reconstruction expert testified Tuesday that when he first viewed the scene of an horrific crash at the Ooltewah exit he thought "Man, this truck just creamed a dozen cars." Officer Joe Warren told a jury from Nashville that, according to his calculations, Benjamin Scott Brewer was traveling at 81-82 miles per hour when he struck ... (click for more)

Taji Webb, 26, Shot And Killed Monday Night; Shooter Will Not Be Charged

Taji Webb, 26, was shot and killed Monday night. Police said they have determined that the shooting was justified and the unidentified shooter would not be charged.   The Chattanooga Police Department responded at 10:43 p.m. to a person shot call in the 1500 block of Ryan Street .  Upon arrival, officers located Webb lying on the ground suffering from a gunshot ... (click for more)

Dismal Educator Teaching At UTC - And Response

Roy Exum,  People are talking about the inability of UTC to turn out high quality teachers. Well, should any university be expected to turn a sow's ear into a silk purse? We all know how our school system students fail miserably on national scholastic aptitude tests as a whole.  Forget Tcap tests, those are teacher tests not meant for measuring student progress, but ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Making A Difference

It was about 50 years ago when the late writer Loren Eiseley penned an essay called “The Starfish Thrower” so it’s been one of my favorite stories for almost as long. It tells about a man who walks up to a young boy on a beach, this just after a strong storm had washed hundreds of helpless starfish onto the shore. The boy was picking up the stranded starfish and, one at a time, ... (click for more)