HRC Medical And Its Principals Ordered To Pay $18 Million And Stop Unlawful Activity

Friday, July 21, 2017
Attorney General Herbert H. Slatery III announced Friday Senior Judge Don Ash, serving as special judge for the Davidson County Circuit Court, has granted the State’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment in its lawsuit against HRC Medical Centers, Inc. and the company’s principals, Dan Hale, Don Hale, and Dixie Hale. The Order is a significant step in concluding the case, officials said.
 
According to the ruling, HRC, Dan Hale, Don Hale, and Dixie Hale are ordered to pay consumers who purchased HRC’s bio-identical hormone replacement therapy (BHRT) a total of $18,141,750 for violations of the Tennessee Consumer Protection Act.
Additionally, the Court issued a permanent injunction barring the Defendants from engaging in conduct the Court has found unlawful.
 
The Order is subject to review by an appellate court.  If the appellate court agrees with the trial court ruling, HRC consumers will be paid from Defendants’ remaining available assets. However, company assets are likely to be significantly less than the court ordered amount, officials said.
 
“HRC and its principals made deceptive statements about the safety and efficacy of its hormone replacement therapy and omitted facts that were important to consumers,” General Slatery said. “It took years of hard work from our attorneys, but the trial court has sent a clear message about Defendants’ advertising practices.” 
 
The State’s original complaint, filed Oct. 8, 2012, alleged in part that HRC, Dan Hale, and Don Hale withheld important information concerning health risks and side effects from consumers and made a series of false, deceptive, and/or unsubstantiated claims about their alternative regimen of BHRT. For women, HRC’s BHRT consisted of estradiol, progesterone, and testosterone. For men, HRC’s BHRT consisted of testosterone.
 
In 2015, the Court found HRC violated the Tennessee Consumer Protection Act by deceptively claiming their products to be absolutely or completely safe, had no side effects, and restored a user’s hormones to prime levels. The Court also found HRC violated the TCPA by making false claims regarding FDA approval and by using company employees and family members in customer testimonial advertisements without disclosing that relationship to consumers.
 
“It is extremely important that consumers receive truthful information about the benefits and risks of any purchase,” said Director Cynthia Wiel of the Tennessee Division of Consumer Affairs. “We are pleased that the court’s decision recognizes this principle.”
 
HRC Medical Centers, Inc. operated clinics in Nashville, Knoxville, and Memphis that sold BHRT.  HRC is not currently operating in Tennessee.


Morning Pointe Residents Bond With Boyd Buchanan Students

The 2018 Olympics is over, but a group of students at Boyd Buchanan enjoyed keeping their version of the games going at Morning Pointe of Hixson.   The youth hosted a variety of activities for the residents at the assisted living and Alzheimer's memory care community, such as bowling, chair volleyball and a hula hoop contest, to name a few.    "It was a day ... (click for more)

Mark Kimball Named CEO Of Erlanger Murphy Medical Center

Mark Kimball, FACHE, has been named chief executive officer of Erlanger Murphy Medical Center, based in Murphy, N.C.  The announcement was made this week by Kevin M. Spiegel, FACHE, president & CEO of the Erlanger Health System.  The North Carolina-based healthcare facility became Erlanger’s sixth hospital on April 1 and its first in North Carolina.   When ... (click for more)

Robert Gillisse Was Pilot Killed In Plane Crash At Collegedale Airport

The pilot who was killed in a plane crash on the runway of the Collegedale Airport on Friday evening has been identified as Robert Gillisse, 62, of Ooltewah . Charles Swain, who is the director of the airport, said the plane was a total loss. It was a single-occupant plane. He said the plane was taking off when it crashed. He said Mr. Gillisse frequently had flown out of ... (click for more)

East Ridge To Build Open-Air Pavilion Near City Hall

East Ridge plans to construct an open-air pavilion that will include restrooms and a concession area near City Hall and the old McBrien School.  It will be part of a Town Center for East Ridge at the Tombras Avenue property. The city is also applying for a $500,000 grant to help convert Pioneer Park into a refurbished park with a splash pad. The firm of Hefferlin and ... (click for more)

A Tribute For My Brother – Sgt. Jonathan Gardner, U.S. Army

Seven years ago today, my family and I found out that my brother, Sgt. Jonathan D. Gardner, was seriously injured by a roadside bomb, (explosively formed penetrator - EFP), while on a mission in Kuwait. The EFP went through the bottom of his seat and put a softball size hole in his upper thigh. The doctors said that if the bomb had entered the Humvee an inch to the right, he ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: The Saturday Funnies

All of us who marvel at the sound of bagpipes at a funeral realize the majesty that people like piper Scottie Maclellan can lend to any “homecoming” and for years there has been a wonderful tale out of Nova Scotia that leads this week’s parade of The  Saturday  Funnies. Mind you, I do not write these stories, as many who have followed man’s laughter down through the ... (click for more)