Stuart Brown Given Chance To Continue As Magistrate After Multiple Mistakes Made

Wednesday, July 11, 2018 - by Gail Perry
 

Stuart Brown will be allowed to keep his job if the many mistakes made in his first month on the job stop, County Commission members said Wednesday. The commission’s Security and Corrections Committee heard details of the complaints that have come from judges, police officers and his boss, new Chief Magistrate Lorrie Miller who was hired at the same time that attorney Brown was brought on as a magistrate.


General Sessions Court Judges Lila Statom and Gary Starnes answered questions from the committee during an hour and a half meeting Wednesday morning regarding their experiences with Magistrate. Brown. They were invited because errors in their cases were documented. If other judges had been asked to the meeting, they would be talking about hearsay, said Judge Statom.


Judge Statom had received paperwork on a warrant issued by another magistrate. Magistrate Brown was called to look at the warrant and to set a bond. The warrant was denied even though another magistrate had determined cause, she said. This had also happened in one of Judge Clarence Shattuck’s cases, where the police officer had to release the suspect. In her case, the suspect was still in custody for another violation. Judge Statom said in Judge Shattuck’s case, it could have been a lack of knowledge about procedures, but in her case he had been informed. “I just don’t know how it could have happened,” she said.


Another issue is that after incidents like this, it is the police officer’s decision as to where to take a case, and they will avoid a magistrate and come to the judges, according to Judge Statom.


A big mistake was made in an order of protection case of Judge Gary Starnes, it was stated. “It concerns me, I found it very disturbing,” said the judge. In this case, the defendant was ordered to have no contact with the victim as a condition of the bond, but contact continued. Paperwork should have been filed and a bond set, he said and none of this was done. As a result, that person walked out of the jail. The police officer involved had to arrest, book and have a bond set again. That never should have happened, said Judge Starnes. Officers will not go to a magistrate if they think their case would be thrown out, he said.


Judge Starnes said, “I do not understand why mistakes keep happening, but once one is made you shouldn’t do it again. I am not uneasy now, but will be real uneasy with him continuing if it does not get better, said Judge Starnes. Chief Magistrate has documented many mistakes and that is what she is supposed to do, said the judge. “She is the supervisor and you are the boss, so it is your responsibility to decide,” said Judge Statom.


Alicia Poe from the human resources department spoke of potential liability for Hamilton County regarding documented, continuing mistakes and if they are serious enough to have repercussions. There is especially concern with the order of protection case, she said.


Magmistrate Brown had the opportunity to speak, saying that he began working 10-hour shifts on June 3, three days after being hired, and said that most of the mistakes occurred in the first four days. “If you do not have training, you will make mistakes,” he said. Ms. Miller met with him on June 11 and told him she did not believe he could do the job. She asked him to retain his health insurance because he might be fired. At the end of June, he received a letter outlining mistakes. He told the committee that he would be willing to do more training in order to improve performance.


Chief Magistrate Miller said it gave her no pleasure to recommend termination, but from the beginning, she said, mistakes happened. She said she explained things to him and the next shift he made the same mistake. She told the committee that she had already provided additional training, and given written and verbal instructions but she had received no response. Magistrate Brown failed to correct mistakes that he had been made aware of, and she added that 11 search warrants are missing. It could be a comprehension problem or maybe he is disorganized, she said. When asked, she replied that additional training would not rectify the problem in a short period of time.


Several concerns were expressed by the commissioners. “Do we provide training to all magistrates?” asked Sabrena Smedley. “I understood during interviews that they were ready to go to work from day one.” The other three can ask for it, answered County Attorney Rheubin Taylor. Ms. Poe from H.R. said she was concerned that it is claimed he needs training on the law. “He should already be there,” she said. Commissioner Tim Boyd said that Magistrate Brown is a practicing lawyer in criminal law and should have adequate knowledge of criminal law. And, he has already had training from another magistrate. Retraining has not been done in the past, said Commissioner Fairbanks. The budget may have to be amended to pay for the training, said County Mayor Jim Coppinger.


A big concern for all the commissioners is exposure for liability, especially since the commissioners are aware of the multiple problems, and the fact that Magistrate Brown has allegedly lost 11 warrants. It is county liability plus a livelihood issue, said Chairman Fairbanks. Magistrate. Brown closed his law practice to take this job and there is an issue with breaking a contract. His job performance also places the county in enormous liability for protecting citizens, said Commissionier Boyd, but a number cannot be put on losing 11 warrants.


He told the entire commission that because of performance concerns about Stuart Brown over the last five-six weeks, termination was recommended. Commissioner Joe Graham made a motion to provide proper training and, if he still cannot do his job 30 days after the training begins, he will be terminated. Attorney Taylor will find the person to do the training for $60 per hour.


Before the vote Attorney Taylor requested a recess to inform the commissioners regarding conversations about a threatened lawsuit.


The motion passed on a vote of six to three, with Commissioners Chester Bankston, Smedley and Fairbanks the only votes against.






Latest Hamilton County Jail Booking Report

Here is the latest jail booking report from Hamilton County: AKINS, JORDAN NICHOLAS  3437 CAGLE RD CHATTANOOGA, 37419  Age at Arrest: 27 years old Arresting Agency: Hamilton County FAILURE TO APPEAR --- AVERY, PAUL DELOZIER  1604 EAST MAIN STREET A6D MURFREESBORO, 37130  Age at Arrest: 20 years old Arresting Agency: Alcoholic BEV Comm RECEIVING, ... (click for more)

Mobley Found Guilty Of Murder; Gets Life Sentence

A Criminal Court jury on Saturday night found Stephen Mobley guilty on all counts, including two of criminal homicide.  He was sentenced to life in prison. Defendant Mobley’s trial for the 2016 Labor Day slayings concluded Saturday with closing statements from both sides. The sequestered jury began deliberations sometime after 3 p.m. Defense attorney Steven ... (click for more)

Here We Go Again With The Same Cummings Highway, 12th Street Flooding

Here we go again with the same pitiful news reports about the Cummings Highway Interstate interchange with I-24 - Flooding yet again after a heavy rain.  TDOT is derelict in not having repaired this years ago.  How hard is it to get some excavators out there to dig up the collapsed drainage pipes which TDOT says are the cause of the flooding and replace them with ... (click for more)

Deal With The Graffiti Vandals

I travel to other neat old cities and don't see nearly the graffiti vandalism as in Chattanooga. Why do we allow one or two or three repeat vandals to mar our venerable Walnut Street Bridge, the pillars to the Holmberg Bridge, the remodeled Chief John Ross Market Street Bridge, the walls along our multi-million-dollar Riverwalk, our sidewalks, street signs and our old limestone ... (click for more)

Dalton Swimmers Win CASL City Meet

Chances are really good that Dalton coach Jason Mezaros will sleep good Saturday night. No question he is dog tired after directing the Chattanooga Area Swim League’s annual Bill Caulkins City Meet, but he will probably sleep with a smile on his face after his Dolphins captured the team championship Saturday night at Fort Oglethorpe’s Arlene Crye Municipal Pool. The Dolphins ... (click for more)

Local Tennis: The City Championships are July 19-22

The annual City Tennis Championships will be held July 19-22 at Manker Patten Tennis Club   Open Division:  The event will include the open division in men’s and women’s singles, doubles and mixed with prize money at $1000 for men’s and women’s singles winners and $500 for the runners-up and $250 for the semifinalists. NTRP Doubles Pla y: Doubles play ... (click for more)