Supreme Court Holds Personal Signature Of Party Appealing In Parental Termination Case Not Required

Wednesday, November 22, 2017
The Tennessee Supreme Court concluded that a father’s notice of appeal, signed by his attorney, but not the father personally, satisfies the statutory signature requirement for appeals in parental termination cases.  The Court remanded the case to the Court of Appeals for consideration of the father’s appeal on the merits. 
 
In this parental termination case, the trial court terminated the father’s parental rights of his minor child.  The father filed a timely notice of appeal, which was signed by his attorney but not by the father personally.  The Court of Appeals ordered the father to show cause why his appeal should not be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction because of his failure to personally sign the notice of appeal based on Tennessee Code Annotated section 36-1-124(d): “Any notice of appeal filed in a termination of parental rights action shall be signed by the appellant.”

The father filed a response to the show cause order, which included a challenge to the constitutionality of the statute at issue.  The Tennessee Attorney General filed a notice of intent to defend the statute’s constitutionality.
 
The Tennessee Supreme Court assumed jurisdiction over the case upon its own motion, pursuant to Tennessee Code Annotated section 16-3-201(d)(3), which allows the Court to assume jurisdiction over undecided cases pending before an intermediate state appellate court due to a compelling public interest.  In assuming jurisdiction, the Court ordered the parties and the Tennessee Attorney General to address whether a party’s failure to sign the notice of appeal results in a jurisdictional defect and whether the statute at issue is unconstitutional on the grounds of separation of powers, due process, and/or equal protection.  
 
In a unanimous opinion, the Court carefully reviewed the specific language of the statutory provision at issue in this case and compared that language to existing language in other current relevant statutes and court rules.  Based on this analysis, the Court determined that Tennessee Code Annotated section 36-1-124(d) does not require the party appealing the trial court’s decision to personally sign a notice of appeal.  In this case, the timely notice of appeal signed by the father’s attorney satisfied this statutory signature requirement.  As a result, the Court held that the father’s case was not subject to dismissal and remanded it to the Court of Appeals for consideration on the merits.  The Court’s holding as to the interpretation of the statutory signature requirement rendered the constitutional issues moot.
 
To read the Supreme Court’s opinion in In re Bentley D., authored by Chief Justice Jeff Bivins, go to the opinions section of TNCourts.gov


Habitat ReStore Opens At New Location In Dalton

Tennessee Revenues Rise In October

Tennessee American Water Submits 2019 Infrastructure Projects For Approval To TPUC


Habitat for Humanity of Greater Dalton’s ReStore is now officially open at 111 North Glenwood Ave. Habitat officials thanked the sponsors that helped fund the move, all staff members that ... (click for more)

Tennessee revenues grew from the same month a year ago and were slightly more than the budgeted estimate for October. Finance and Administration Commissioner Larry Martin reported that October ... (click for more)

Tennessee American Water announced Monday that it has submitted its 2019 list of capital infrastructure projects and associated costs to the Tennessee Public Utility Commission. The capital plan ... (click for more)


Business

Habitat ReStore Opens At New Location In Dalton

Habitat for Humanity of Greater Dalton’s ReStore is now officially open at 111 North Glenwood Ave. Habitat officials thanked the sponsors that helped fund the move, all staff members that put in countless hours beautifying the space, and all board members and volunteers that made the relocation event run smoothly. The ReStore is one of Habitat’s resource development engines. ... (click for more)

Tennessee Revenues Rise In October

Tennessee revenues grew from the same month a year ago and were slightly more than the budgeted estimate for October. Finance and Administration Commissioner Larry Martin reported that October revenues were $1.0 billion, which is $29.5 million more than October of last year and $3.2 million more than the budgeted estimate. The growth rate for October was 2.91%. “October sales ... (click for more)

Breaking News

County Commission Votes To Give Humane Educational Society $10 Million For New Shelter

The County Commission on Wednesday morning voted to give the Humane Educational Society (HES) $10 million for a new animal shelter. Commissioner Chip Baker said he had considered asking for a delay for talks on possible merging of services with the city's McKamey Animal Center. However, he said he was advised that the HES could lose out on a potential donor if the vote was delayed. ... (click for more)

Eddie Pierce Chosen New Red Bank Mayor; Ruth Jeno Returns To Commission

Three newly elected commissioners were sworn in by Judge Gary Starnes at the Red Bank Commission meeting on Tuesday night. Two are returning, Commissioners Ed LeCompte and Terry Pope, and the third, Ruth Jeno, is returning, after a lapse, for a third term on the commission. The commissioners elected Eddie Pierce to serve as the new mayor and Terry Pope to be vice mayor. ... (click for more)

Opinion

Discrimination And Double Taxation For Animal Shelters - And Response

Some Commissioners want Hamilton County to donate $10 million in tax dollars to help the Humane Education Society (HES) build a new facility. The majority of Hamilton County residents (specifically those residing in Chattanooga, East Ridge, Lakesite, Walden, Signal Mountain, Lookout Mountain, Soddy Daisy, and Collegedale) will be prohibited from using HES animal services unless ... (click for more)

Roy Exum: Thanksgiving Eve

At some point this spring, as I impatiently awaited the song birds as I do every year, I took a less-traveled path during My Morning Readings and came across a Thanksgiving story that I loved. Trust me, I have been waiting for about six months … yes, impatiently … to share a story that was written seven years ago by J. Allen Wilson. I searched for him yesterday but the closest ... (click for more)